Lhalu Tsewang Dorje

Lhalu Tsewang Dorje (Tibetan: ལྷ་ཀླུ་ཚེ་དབང་རྡོ་རྗེ་, Chinese: 拉鲁·次旺多吉, January 1914 – 15 September 2011) commonly known as Lhalu, Lhalu Se, or Lhalu Shape, was a Tibetan aristocrat and politician who held a variety of positions in various Tibetan governments before and after 1951.

Lhalu Tsewang Dorje
ལྷ་ཀླུ་ཚེ་དབང་རྡོ་རྗེ་ 拉鲁·次旺多吉
Lhalu Tsewang Dorje on 8 January 1937 in photo taken by Frederick Spencer Chapman
Vice Chairman of the Tibet Autonomous Regional Political Consultative Conference
In office April 1983 – January 2003
Chairman	Yangling Dorje→Raidi→Pagbalha Geleg Namgyai
Member of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference (5th, 6th, 7th, 8th, 9th)
In office August 1978 – March 2003
Finance Minister of Tibet
In office 1946–1947
Monarch	14th Dalai Lama
Preceded by	title created
Succeeded by	Tsepon W. D. Shakabpa
Kalön of Tibet
In office 1946–1952 Serving with Kashopa Chogyal Nyima (until 1949), Dokhar Püntsog Rabgye (since 1949), Ngabo Ngawang Jigme (since 1950), Khyenrab Wangchug (since 1951), Surkhang Wangchen Gelek, and Thupten Kunkhen
Monarch	14th Dalai Lama
Governor of Domai
In office 1947 – September 1950
Monarch	14th Dalai Lama
Preceded by	Yuthok Tashi Dhondup
Succeeded by	Ngapoi Ngawang Jigme
Personal details
Born	January 1914 Lhasa, Tibet
Died	15 September 2011(2011-09-15) (aged 97) Lhasa, Tibet Autonomous Region, People's Republic of China
Nationality	Chinese
Parent	Lungshar (father)

Lhalu Tsewang Dorje
Tibetan name
Tibetan	ལྷ་ཀླུ་ཚེ་དབང་རྡོ་རྗེ་
Transcriptions Wylie lha klu tshe dbang rdo rje Tibetan Pinyin Lhalu Cêwang Dojê
Chinese name
Traditional Chinese	拉魯·次旺多吉
Simplified Chinese	拉鲁·次旺多吉
Transcriptions Standard Mandarin Hanyu Pinyin Lālǔ Cìwàng Duōjí

Lhalu Tsewang Dorje and Dundul Namgyal Tsarong in 1950

Biography

Early years

Lhalu's father was Lungsharwa Dorje Tsegyel, an influential official in the Lhasa government and a favourite of the 13th Dalai Lama's.^[1] His mother was Yangdzon Tsering, the Shatra family's youngest daughter, with whom Lungshar had been having an affair.^[2]

Lungshar was born into the noble Lhalu family whose ancestors lived in Tana of the Tsang region at the time of the 5th Dalai Lama. He is famous for taking four noble youths – "the Rugby Four" – to the United Kingdom to receive a modern education (for the first time in Tibet's history).^[3]

As a child, Lhalu attended a private school at the foot of the Potala Palace in Lhasa. He then went on to a school for children of secular officials at Jokhang monastery.^[4]

Earlier official positions

Following the Dalai Lama's death in 1934, Lungshar Dorje Tsegyel, a moderate reformist who advocated replacing lifelong tenure for the government ministers (Kalon) with a vote for a four-year term, was outmanœuvred by the more conservative minister Trimön; Lungshar was arrested and punished by blinding. All of Lungshar's descendants were then banned from government service. Lhalu had entered government service as a boy in 1927, but he was dismissed from his position after his father's arrest.^[5]

Lhalu was later adopted into the wealthy family of Lungshar's common law wife, the Lhalu family,^[6][7] which lacked a male heir. By making the public claim that Lungshar was not his biological father, and by applying in the name of Lhalu se and paying large bribes,^[8] he was able to become an official again in 1937, after which he became increasingly influential. The Lhalu family had attained nobility by producing two incarnations of the Dalai Lama^[9][10][11] but did not belong to the old nobility that traces back its lineage to ancient Tibetan kings.^[12]

In 1940, Lhalu married a daughter of the Labrang Nyingpa (Thonpa) family. In 1941, he was promoted to 4th rank and made a tsepön.^[13]

In 1946, he was appointed a shape, i.e. a member of cabinet, by the regent, Taktra.^[14] He played an active role in the arrest of the former regent, Reting Rinpoche, when Reting was charged with attempting to assassinate Taktra.

Governor of Kham

Shortly after the Reting incident, Lhalu was appointed governor of Kham, with his headquarters in Chamdo. He was serving in this position in 1949 when the People's Republic of China consolidated its control of China proper and began a build-up of troops in the provinces bordering Tibet. Lhalu began preparations to resist Chinese forces, but he was replaced by Ngabö Ngawang Jigme before the invasion actually occurred.

Robert W. Ford's testimony

In his book Captured in Tibet, Robert W. Ford, a former British radio operator in Kham, portrays Lhalu "as typical of the more progressive Tibetan officials. They knew they were backward, and genuinely wanted to learn and to modernize their country - so long as no harm was done to their religion." Although Lhalu had never left Tibet (unlike his father, who "was one of the very few Tibetans who ever went to Britain"), he "was keenly interested in the outside world and studied the pictures in [Ford's] illustrated magazines. He wanted to know about tractors and other agricultural machinery and about industrial processes in the West."^[15]

Commander-in-chief of the 1959 uprising

Lhalu returned to Lhasa in July 1951. After Tibet was annexed by the People's Republic of China, the Tibetan government was reorganised. He was dismissed from government service in May 1952 (on account of his maladministration of Kham during his tenure as Governor) but was allowed to retain his rank.

In 1955, he headed a delegation to Beijing and met Mao Zedong and Zhou Enlai.^[16]

In 1957, he was appointed "Governor of the grain supply".^[17]

According to American journalist and Marxist writer Anna Louise Strong, unlike some of the sincere signers of the 17-point agreement, Lhalu continued plotting for Tibet's secession from China.^[18]

In 1959, he participated in the Tibetan uprising, and would later describe himself as having been the commander-in-chief of the rebel forces.^[19]

He was captured, subjected to struggle sessions (known in Tibetan as thamzing), and imprisoned in Drapchi Prison.^[20]

At a mass meeting of ten thousand people in Lhasa circa 1959, he was implicated in the murders of former Regent Reting and tulku Geda, both supposedly sympathetic to the Chinese.^[21] He narrowly escaped being beaten up thanks to the protection of PLA soldiers.^[22]

Anna Louise Strong's testimony

In 1959, Anna Louise Strong was allowed to travel to Tibet to report on the political situation there. In a book published the following year, When Serfs Stood Up in Tibet, she described a hearing on Lhalu's treatment of his local serfs organized by the Fourth Inhabitants' Committee of the Western District of Lhasa. Lhalu, then 43 years old, was to reply to the accusations levelled at him by former serfs and slaves from one of his 24 manorial estates: mistreatment, non respect of his peasants and servants' rights, imprisonment in the manor's jail. Lhalu is forced to admit that he had been "too harsh", had "a touchy temper", had "made mistakes" or "gone to excess". The accusation meeting ends with the burning of his titles of debts (All "feudal debts" had been outlawed by the resolution passed 17 July by the Preparatory Committee for the Tibet Autonomous Region).^[23]

Political rehabilitation

After he was set free on special amnesty in 1965, Lhalu took up farming.^[24]

With Deng Xiaoping's return to office and the abandonment of the class-struggle line,^[25] he was given a job in 1977 and was eventually politically rehabilitated in 1983,^[24] becoming one of the vice-chairmen of the Tibetan Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference.^[26]

Political stances

He has praised the Chinese government's policies in Tibet and has been strongly critical of the old Tibetan government and of the Dalai Lama. He said in an interview, "I have become disappointed with the Dalai Lama," and "[h]e does not behave like a reincarnated living Buddha but is a stooge of the Westerners."^[4]

According to English writer Patrick French, in 1999 he took his distance from the official rhetoric, indicating that he was missing his former friends and that he wished the return of the Dalai Lama: "There is a Tibetan saying: 'Old bird misses forests and old people miss hometown'. I sincerely wish the Fourteenth Dalai Lama will return, in the interests of the motherland, at an early date and join us in socialist construction."^[27]

Lhalu's recollections of his life appear in his book, Recalling the Road I Took.

His children

He has one daughter and five sons (three of which are reincarnated Lamas, so called "Tulkus").^[28][29] In 2003, his son Gyai'ra Losang Dainzin (Jagra Lobsang Tenzin) became vice-chairman of the Tibet Autonomous Region government.^[30]

His published work

• Recalling the Road I Took (published both in Tibetan and Chinese; does not seem to have been translated into English)
• Collected Materials of Literature and History in Tibet, a multi-volume compilation he has spent much of his time editing and publishing, Cultural and Historical Materials Office, Beijing^[28]
• Recollections of My Father Dorje Tsegye Lungshar, in Collected Materials of Literature and History in Tibet, Cultural and Historical Materials Office, Nationalities Publishing House, Beijing, 1983, 2:93-109
• The Purple Kasaya, coll. Tibetan People (2/4) (DVD), 2007^[31]

Death

On 15 September 2011, Lhalu Tsewang Dorje died in Lhasa at the age of 98, as announced in Chinese by Tibet Daily, at the time of the funeral, 18 September, in Lhasa.^[32]

Notes and references

1. According to the Xinhua press agency "he is the son of high-ranking Tibetan official appointed by the Qing emperor."
2. Cirenyangzong, The aristocratic families in Tibetan history, op. cit., p. 23: "When Lungsharwa Dorje Tsegyel was giving full play to his political talent, Yangdzom Tsering became his intimate friend."
3. Tsering Yangdzom, Shao Da, On the dominant Dalai Lama's Yabgzhis families Archived 27 July 2008 at the Wayback Machine, China Tibet Information Center.
4. Tibetan Consultative Body Member Says Dalai Lama "Stooge of the Westerners", Xinhua News Agency, 6 mars 1996.
5. Cirenyangzong, The aristocratic families in Tibetan history, op. cit., p. 24: "Lungsharwa Dorje Tsegyel, who was in the 13th's favor, advocated abolishing lifelong tenure for the Galoin; instead, a 'referendum' should be held to vote the Galoin for a four-year term. Since his radical reform was targeted at the Gaxag - the supreme administrative organization of the local government, and thus encroached on the interests of the big nobility, after the 13th's death Lungshar was removed from office and his eyes were gouged out. The government also issued orders that none of the Lungsharwa family's offspring could inherit a noble title or have an official career."
6. The Lhalu owned a magnificent mansion about one kilometer north of the Potala Palace. The three-story residence was originally built by the Tibetan government for Tsangyang Gyatso, the 6th Dalai Lama. See Tsering Yangdzom, Shao Da, On the dominant Dalai Lama's Yabgshis' families Archived 27 July 2008 at the Wayback Machine, China Tibetology.
7. Sir Charles Bell took a picture of it while on a mission to Lhasa in 1920-1921. It was published in his book The People of Tibet (Oxford, Clarendon Press) in 1928, with the caption Lha-lu Mansion. Reckoned by the Chinese as one of the five beauties of Lhasa. See The Tibet Album. British photography in Central Tibet 1920-1950.
8. Tsering Yangdzom, Shao Da, op. cit.: "Goldstein writes: 'Lungshar's' son Lhalu later petitioned to be reinstated as a government official, arguing that he was not really Lungshar's son. He claimed his biological father was Shekarlingpa, another aristocrat, and both his mother and Shekarlingpa swore that this was so. Using this rather feeble ploy (and massive bribes), he was reinstated under the family name of Lhalu and given the Seynamba status."
9. Tibetan Consultative Body Member Says Dalai Lama "Stooge of the Westerners", Xinhua News Agency, 6 March 1996.
10. Governmental Organization of Old Tibet: "From the seventh Dalai Lama to the 14th, seven families had been formed, such as the Lhangdun and Lhalu families."
11. Cirenyangzong, The aristocratic families in Tibetan history, 五洲传播出版社, 2006, 272 p., ISBN 7-5085-0937-4, ISBN 978-7-5085-0937-2, p. 18: "The Lhalu family has produced two Dalai Lamas - the 8th and the 12th Dalai Lama – as well as numerous reincarnated soul boys."
12. Anna Louise Strong, When Serfs Stood Up in Tibet, New World Press, Beijing, 1960, chap. VIII Lhalu's Serfs Accuse: "Lhalu's family was not of the 'old nobility' in Tibet; it did not, like Apei's (Ngabo Ngawang Jigme), trace lineage back a thousand years to ancient kings. It had produced the eighth and twelfth incarnations of the Dalai Lama and thus attained nobility."
13. Lhalu Se, Tibet Album. British photography in Central Tibet 1920-1950 (entry from Who Was Who In Tibet? by Frank Drauschke).
14. Anna Louise Strong, When Serfs Stood Up in Tibet, op. cit., chap. VIII Lhalu(s Serfs Accuse: "He had been one of the six kaloons who made up the kashag, the local secular government under the Dalai Lama ; it was said that he had bribed the kashag in 1945 with two hundred and fifty thousand taels of silver for the post. He had then become both secretary and vice-chairman of the kashag at different times."
15. Robert W. Ford, Captured in Tibet, p. 23.
16. Jiawei Wang, Nimajianzan, The historical status of China's Tibet, China Hanban donation, 五洲传播出版社, 1997, 333 p. ISBN 7-80113-304-8, ISBN 978-7-80113-304-5, p. 280.
17. Anna Louise Strong, When Serfs Stood Up, New World Press, Beijing, 1960, chap. VIII Lhalu's Serfs Accuse: "He continued to hold high post in Tibet's local government (..) and was governor of grain supply in 1957."
18. Cf Anna Louise Strong, When Serfs Stood Up in Tibet, op. cit., chap. VIII Lhalu's Serfs Accuse: "Some of the signers of the Agreement took it sincerely; Lhalu did not. (..) His plotting for Tibet's secession from China continued; it had a history of years."
19. Anna Louise Strong, When Serfs Stood Up in Tibet, op. cit., chap. VIII Lhalu's Serfs Accuse: "Lhalu Tsewong-Dorje, commander-in-chief of the March rebellion in Lhasa."
20. Palden Gyatso, Le feu sous la neige: "Drapchi housed some of Tibet's most famous prisoners and dissidents. The prison was divided into five different brigades, or ruka. The fifth ruka housed all the former Tibetan government officials and high lamas, including Lobsang Tashi, the last prime minister of Tibet, and Lhalu, the former commander of the Tibetan army in eastern Tibet."
21. Cf Anna Louise Strong, When Serfs Stood Up in Tibet, op. cit., chap. VIII Lhalu's Serfs Accuse: "Recent accusations made before a mass meeting of ten thousand people in Lhasa had implicated him in the murder of Rabchen, the Dalai Lama's first regent, and of the progressive Living Buddha Geda, both of whom opposed secession and had been killed for this not long before the liberation. Evidence of Lhalu's participation had been filed with the courts and would be considered later."
22. Jiawei Wang, Nyima Gyaincain, The historical status of China's Tibet, op. cit., p. 280: "how the PLA soldiers protected him from being beaten at the mass rally."
23. Anna Louise Strong, When Serfs Stood Up in Tibet, op. cit. chap. VII Lhalu's Serfs Accuse : "The accusation meeting (...) was a local affair, a hearing on Lhalu's treatment of his local serfs. It was being held under the Fourth Inhabitants' Committee of the Western District of Lhasa. (...) It was clear that Lhalu, like other serf-owners, had a large number of nantsam, and that those who were house and stable slaves, being in frequent contact with their master, were quickly detected in misdemeanors and at once flogged, and sometimes also cast for periods of various lengths into the 'private jail' which all manorial estates maintained in their cellars. (...) At times some response was forced from Lhalu. On some charges he admitted that he had been 'too harsh', had 'a touchy temper', had 'made mistakes' or 'gone to excess'. (..) Suddenly a loud shout rose like a war cry from the audience: 'Burn the debts! Burn the debts!' (...) Lhalu's steward was bringing in the 'titles of debts'. (...) All 'feudal debts' had been outlawed by the resolution passed July 17 by the Preparatory Committee for the Tibet Autonomous Region. (...) Matches were put to the pile (...) [Lhalu] gazed without expression at the fire which was burning away the documents of his feudal power. Then a few of the guards came to take him away. He went without handcuffs."
24. Jiawei Wang, Nimajianzan, The historical status of China's Tibet, op. cit., p. 280.
25. Wang Lixiong, Reflections on Tibet, in New Left Review 14, March–April 2002: "Under Deng, the class-struggle line was abandoned, and the old aristocrats, clan chiefs and lamas once again were invited to the National People's Congress and the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference."
26. Wang Lixiong, Reflections on Tibet, op. cit.: "Lhalu Tsewang Dorje [...] is currently a Vice Chairman of the regional Political Consultative Conference and is a member of its standing committee."
27. Patrick French, Tibet, Tibet: a personal history of a lost land, p. 178.
28. Tibetan Consultative Body Member Says Dalai Lama "Stooge of the Westerners", op. cit.
29. Lhalu Tsewang Dorjee and Lhalu Sonam Dekyi's progeny:

    • eldest daughter, Tsering Wangmo, married to Sampho Samdup Norbu ; they have four children: Paldon, Yangzom, Kalsang, Tseten gyurme
    • eldest son, Kunchok Gyaltsen, married to Kunsang Dechen, grand-daughter of Raja Tsodak Namgyal of Sikkim, later to become Taring in Tibet ; they have two sons, Lhalu Tseten Dorjee, Lhalu Dorjee Gyaltsen ;
    • second son, Jigme Namling Tana Rinpoche ;
    • third son, Jampa Tenzin Puchok Jamgon Rinpoche ;
    • fourth son, Lobsang Tenzin Chamdo Jagra Rinpoche ;
    • fifth son, Sithar Tsering, died in the 1980s.
30. Tibetans live with democracy for half century Archived 22 May 2011 at the Wayback Machine, China Tibet Information Center.
31. The Purple Kasaya Archived 25 April 2012 at the Wayback Machine, synopsis: "Through Lhalu's account and precious historical footage, the film demonstrates the change a Tibetan family and the whole region have undergone."
32. "拉鲁·次旺多吉同志遗体告别仪式在拉萨举行". 中国共产党新闻网. 19 September 2011..

External links

• Captured in Tibet, Robert W. Ford