GER Classes S46, D56 and H88

The GER Classes S46, D56 and H88 (classified Classes D14, D15, and D16 by the London and North Eastern Railway) were three classes of similar 4-4-0 steam locomotive designed by James Holden (S46 and D56) and A. J. Hill (H88) for the Great Eastern Railway.

GER S46, D56 and H88 "Claud Hamilton" LNER Class D14/D15/D16
GER No. 1900 shortly after its completion in 1900.
Type and origin Power type Steam Designer James Holden and A. J. Hill Builder Stratford Works Build date 1900-1923 Total produced 121
Specifications Configuration: ​  • Whyte 4-4-0  • UIC 2′B n2, 2′B h2 Gauge 4 ft 8+1⁄2 in (1,435 mm) Leading dia. 3 ft 9 in (1.14 m) Driver dia. 7 ft (2.1 m) Length 53 ft 4+3⁄4 in (16.275 m) Loco weight 52.2–55.9 long tons (53.0–56.8 t) Fuel type Coal Firebox: ​  • Grate area 21.3 sq ft (1.98 m2) Boiler pressure 180 psi (1,200 kPa) Cylinders Two inside Cylinder size 19 in × 26 in (480 mm × 660 mm)
Performance figures Tractive effort 17,095 lbf (76,040 N)
Career Operators Great Eastern Railway → London and North Eastern Railway → British Railways Power class BR: 2P (3P for D16/3 from 1953) Axle load class LNER/BR: RA 5 Withdrawn D15: 1948–1952 D16/2: 1950-1952 D16/3: 1945-1953, 1955-1960 Disposition All original locomotives scrapped.

They were given the nickname Claud Hamilton after the pioneer engine of the class, named after Lord Claud Hamilton (1843–1925) the chairman of the Great Eastern Railway. The D56 class of 1903-4 evolved the design to include a square-topped Belpaire firebox. The H88 class of 1923 featured a larger superheated boiler, leading them to be known as Super Clauds. Many earlier members of the class were rebuilt during their working life.

During the Edwardian era, they were the flagship express locomotive on the Great Eastern Main Line, and although displaced on the heaviest express trains by the larger S69 class from 1911 (itself a 4-6-0 development of the Claud design), members of the class were used on passenger and goods services throughout the Eastern Region until 1960. No locomotives of the three classes survived to preservation.

Design

GER Class D56 in original Great Eastern blue livery with decorative features as depicted in a 1910 colour plate by W.J. Stokoe (note the square Belpaire firebox).

The Claud Hamilton, particularly in its original GER blue livery, is widely considered one of the most elegant locomotive designs of the pre-grouping era.^[1]

In his 1955 history of the Great Eastern Railway, Cecil J. Allen devotes a whole chapter to the class and noted that

Of all the locomotive designs that emerged from Stratford Works during the reign of James Holden, the one destined to achieve the greatest fame, beyond question, was his Claud Hamilton type 4-4-0, of which the pioneer example, No. 1900 Claud Hamilton, took the rails in 1900.^[2]

Although credited to James Holden, the Locomotive Superintendent of the Great Eastern, Frederick Vernon Russell (Holden's Chief Designer) is thought to have contributed substantially to the design of the Claud Hamiltons; while researching his Some Classic Locomotives of 1949, C.H. Ellis was informed by Russell that during the process of designing the locomotive "Mr Holden, by then a valetudinarian was making a long recuperative stay in Egypt."^[3]

The 4-4-0 inside cylinder locomotive included a number of features that were to appear on later Great Eastern locomotive classes, including a circular polished steel smokebox door surround (instead of the usual horizontal straps) and decorative splashers.^[2] Class pioneer No 1900 Claud Hamilton featuring red lining and connecting rods, copper chimney cap and GER coat of arms was much admired when it was exhibited at the 1900 Paris Exposition.^[4]

The original S46 boiler had 1,630 sq ft (151 m²) of heating surface, with a 21.3 sq ft (1.98 m²) grate. The cylinders were 19 x 26 in. with flat valves placed below, operated by Stephenson's motion. The coupled wheels were 7 ft (2.1 m) in diameter.

As built, the S46s were all fired by oil, using Holden's patented oil-burning apparatus which used a bed of fire brick, a supply of air fed from a pre-heater in the smokebox and steam-powered injectors which sprayed atomised oil onto the firebed. The firebox was heated, and steam for the injectors initially generated, by burning coal before switching to oil. The oil burnt was a waste product of the GER's gasworks that produced Pintsch gas for lighting its carriages. The GER had previously been fined for discharging this waste product into the River Lea, and the railway was thus able to fuel its oil-burning locomotives at little extra cost.^[1]

The first ten of the D56 types were also built as oil-burners, but during the 1900s the increasing use of electric lighting in carriages and growing industrial demand for fuel oil meant that it was no longer cost-effective to use it as a locomotive fuel. Holden had always intended that his oil-burning system would allow engines so fitted to be easily converted to burn coal if required, and all the S46s and D56s had been switched to coal-burning by the end of 1911. When oil prices were low or coal was in short supply due to strike action some examples were re-fitted to burn oil for short periods but this was not done past 1927.^[1]

Allen reports that Claud Hamiltons in their original state were capable of taking around 350 tons from Liverpool Street to North Walsham in under the booked time. No. 1882 with round-top boiler ran the 130.2 miles (209.5 km) in 156 min 60 sec. Even heavier trains were managed in the up direction: No. 1809 (Belpaire boiler) took 400 tons up in 157 minutes 24 seconds.

The S46 design was substantially modified in later incarnations, particularly with the introduction of a larger superheated boiler on the H88 designed by Alfred John Hill. Most earlier members of the class were substantially modified by Hill or during the tenure of Sir Nigel Gresley as CME of the LNER from 1923.^[5]

Two separate classes were also developed from the design of the Claud Hamilton; Holden's Class F48 (constructed between 1900 and 1903) was essentially an 0-6-0 goods version of the S46^[6] and the Class S69 (built between 1911 and 1921) was a larger 4-6-0 version using many of the same design cues as the H88, built to replace the Clauds on the heaviest express trains.

Classification and numbering

Class D15 No. 62503 at Cambridge Shed in August 1949. Note the cut-out splashers and small 'water-cart' tender.

The classification of the Claud Hamiltons is complex but is summarised here:

• GER Class S46 (LNER Class D14), 4 ft 9 in diameter boiler, round-top firebox^[7]
• GER Class D56 (LNER Class D15), 4 ft 9 in diameter boiler, Belpaire firebox^[7]
  • LNER Class D15/1, D15 as built with short smokebox, some with superheater
  • LNER Class D15/2, D15 with superheater and long smokebox
• GER Class H88 (LNER Class D16), "Super Claud" with superheater, larger boiler (5 ft 1+1⁄8 in diameter) and Belpaire firebox^[7]
  • LNER Class D16/1, D16 as built (with short smokebox)
  • LNER Class D16/2, as D16/1 but with extended smokebox
  • LNER Class D16/3, Gresley rebuild of D15 and D16 with round-top firebox, some with piston valves

The class pioneer was numbered 1900 (to coincide with the year the locomotive was built), with subsequent batches numbered backwards in tens as follows:

Table of orders and numbers^[8][9]

Year	Order	Quantity	GER Nos.	LNER Nos.	1946 Nos.	Notes
1900	S46	1	1900	8900	2500
1900	L47	10	1890–1899	8890–8899	2501–2510
1901	M51	10	1880–1889	8880–8889	2511–2520
1902	F53	10	1870–1879	8870–8879	2521–2530
1903	L55	10	1860–1869	8860–8869	2531–2540
1903–04	D56	10	1850–1859	8850–8859	2541–2550	Belpaire boiler
1906–07	G61	10	1840–1849	8840–8849	2551–2560
1908	A64	10	1830–1839	8830–8839	2561–2570
1909	B66	10	1820–1829	8820–8829	2571–2580
1910	D67	10	1810–1819	8810–8819	2581–2590
1910	P67	10	1800–1809	8800–8809	2591–2600
1911	E69	10	1790–1799	8790–8799	2601–2610
1923	H88	10	1780–1789	8780–8789	2611–2620	Never carried GER numbers in service

The Railway Magazine of November 1923 includes the log of a run from Liverpool Street to Ipswich with 4-4-0 number 1780, so this loco at least must have carried a GER number.^[10]

Appearance

D16/2 'Super-Claud' No. 8813 in disguised wartime 'NE' black livery at March Locomotive Depot 14 July 1946.

D16/3 'Super Claud' 4-4-0 No. 62530 departs March in August 1958.

Originally painted in GER blue with red lining and bronze highlights, following the 1923 grouping the GER became part of the London and North Eastern Railway, and were painted in the company's apple green with LNER on the tender and cab-side numbers. Side rods were polished steel. The appearance was altered when a larger boiler and Belpaire firebox was fitted, meaning a change in the cab window shape as well.^[11]

8783 and 8787 were kept in immaculate condition as dedicated Royal locos for hauling the Royal Train from King's Cross to Wolferton (the nearest station for Sandringham House).^[12] 8783 was also fitted with a copper-capped chimney. Later some locos carried numbers and London & North Eastern Railway on the tender. During the Second World War most were repainted into unlined black livery with the letters "N E" on the tender. "Royal Claud" 8783 retained its LNER apple green livery into British Railways days (after 1948), but with BRITISH RAILWAYS on the tender initially.

Others were painted black with BRITISH RAILWAYS on the tender. Later on they carried both lined and unlined black with the early BR crest and those which survived after 1956 lined and unlined black with the later crest. Many of the class retained steel smokebox door rings until withdrawal, except those rebuilt by Gresley with a larger boiler which also required a new smokebox. Many locos had their decorative valances removed in later years as well, though they still retained their distinctive character.

Accidents and incidents

Main article: Ilford rail crash (1915)

• On 1 January 1915, locomotive No. 1813 was hauling an express passenger train that overran signals and collided with a local passenger train at Ilford, Essex. Ten people were killed and more than 500 were injured.^[13]
• On 12 February 1927, locomotive No. 8808 was hauling an express passenger train that was in collision with a lorry on a level crossing at Tottenham, London. Due to foggy conditions, the train was not travelling at a high speed.^[14]
• On 17 January 1931, locomotive No. 8781 was running light engine at Great Holland, Essex when it was in a head-on collision with a newspaper train, which was being hauled by LNER Class B12 4-6-0 No. 8578 . Two people were killed and two were seriously injured. The newspaper train had departed from Thorpe-le-Soken station against signals.^[15]
• On 27 November 1934, D15/2 No. 8896 locomotive was derailed at Wormley, Hertfordshire when it collided with a lorry on a level crossing. Both engine crew were killed.^[16]
• On 1 June 1939, locomotive No. 8783 was hauling a passenger train that collided with a lorry on an occupation crossing at Hilgay, Norfolk and was derailed. ^[17]

Withdrawals

Withdrawals of the class began in 1945, with the final member, a D16/3, scrapped in 1960 leaving no survivors of the class.

Table of withdrawals^[18][9]

Year	Quantity in service at start of year	Quantity withdrawn	Locomotive numbers	Notes
1945	121	1	8866	Not renumbered
1946	120	2	2550/95
1947	118	1	2500	Name transferred to 2546
1948	117	6	2504/60/63/83, 2600/02
1949	111	1	2594
1950	110	3	62508/12/91
1951	107	7	62501/03/05/20/28/47, 62603
1952	100	8	62502/06-07/09/27/38/90/98
1953	92	2	62581, 62616
1954	90	0	–
1955	90	15	62525/31/36/41/49/52/54/57/59/73–74/79/85, 62607/20
1956	75	8	62523/32/42/51/67/69/77/87
1957	67	28	62510/14/16/19/26/33/35/39/46/48/53/56/58/62/65/75–76/78/84/93/96, 62601/05/08–09/11/17/19
1958	39	23	62513/15/18/21–22/30/34/43/45/55/61/64/66/68/72/80/86/88/92/99, 62610/14–15
1959	16	12	62511/17/29/40/44/70–71/82/89, 62606/12/18
1960	4	4	62524/97, 62604/13

Revival

A group based at the Whitwell & Reepham railway plan to build a replica of D16/2 No. 8783 to be named Phoenix.^[19]

In fiction

The design was the basis of the character Molly in the children's TV series Thomas the Tank Engine and Friends.^[20]

References

1. "The Holden 'Claud Hamilton' Class D14, D15, & D16 4-4-0 Locomotives". LNER Encyclopedia. Retrieved 27 May 2019.
2. Allen 1955, p. 127.
3. Ellis 1965, p. 61.
4. Allen 1955, p. 130.
5. Fry et al. 1981, pp. 1, 3, 18–21.
6. Aldrich 1969, p. 71.
7. Fry et al. 1981, p. 20.
8. Fry et al. 1981, pp. 19, 53–55.
9. Baxter 2012, pp. 59–67, 105–106.
10. Allen 1923, p. 398.
11. Allen 1955, pp. 129–130.
12. Jenkinson, Edgington & Smart 1994, p. 78.
13. Earnshaw 1991, p. 16.
14. Earnshaw 1990, p. 16.
15. Vaughan 1989, pp. 69–73.
16. Trevena 1980, pp. 36–37.
17. Earnshaw 1990, p. 21.
18. Fry et al. 1981, pp. 53–55.
19. "Claud Hamilton Locomotive Group". Claud Hamilton Locomotive Group. Retrieved 14 October 2016.
20. "Molly - Character Profile & Bio". Thomas & Friends - Official Website. Retrieved 31 July 2019.

Bibliography

• Aldrich, C. Langley (1969). The Locomotives of the Great Eastern Railway 1862–1962 (7th ed.). Wickford, Essex: C. Langley Aldrich. OCLC 30278831.
• Allen, Cecil J. (November 1923). "British Locomotive Practice and Performance". The Railway Magazine. Vol. 53, no. 313. pp. 385–400.
• Allen, Cecil J. (1955). The Great Eastern Railway. Shepperton: Ian Allan. ISBN 9780711006591.
• Baxter, Bertram (2012). Baxter, David; Mitchell, Peter (eds.). British Locomotive Catalogue 1825–1923, Volume 6: Great Eastern Railway, North British Railway, Great North of Scotland Railway, Midland & Great Northern Joint Railway, remaining companies in the LNER group. Southampton: Kestrel Railway Books. ISBN 978-1-905505-26-5.
• Earnshaw, Alan (1990). Trains in Trouble: Vol. 6. Penryn: Atlantic Books. ISBN 0-906899-37-0.
• Earnshaw, Alan (1991). Trains in Trouble: Vol. 7. Penryn: Atlantic Books. ISBN 0-906899-50-8.
• Ellis, C.H. (1942). "Famous locomotive engineers: No. 20 James Holden". Locomotive Carriage and Wagon Review. 47: 110–115.
• Ellis, C.H. (1949). Some classic locomotives. London: George Allen & Unwin.
• Ellis, C.H. (1965). The splendour of steam. London: George Allen & Unwin. ISBN 0-04-385016-2.
• Fry, E.V.; Hoole, Ken; Manners, F.; Neve, E.; Proud, P.; Yeadon, W.B. (August 1981). Fry, E.V. (ed.). Locomotives of the LNER. Part 3C. Tender engines—classes D13 to D24. Kenilworth: Railway Correspondence & Travel Society. ISBN 0-901115-52-5.
• Jenkinson, David; Edgington, John; Smart, John (1994). The Big Four in Colour, 1935-50. Penryn: Atlantic Books. ISBN 0-906899-62-1.
• Trevena, Arthur (1980). Trains in Trouble. Vol. 1. Redruth: Atlantic Books. ISBN 0-906899-01-X.
• Vaughan, Adrian (1989). Obstruction Danger. Wellingborough: Patrick Stephens Limited. ISBN 1-85260-055-1.

External links

• Great Eastern Railway Society: Classes S46/D56/H88
• LNER Encyclopedia: Classes S46/D56/H88
• Claud Hamilton Locomotive Group