Extreme form of nationalism From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
"Ultranationalist" redirects here. For the fictional "Ultranationalists" faction from the Call of Duty video game series, see Call of Duty §Modern Warfare series.
Ultranationalism or extreme nationalism is an extreme form of nationalism in which a country asserts or maintains detrimental hegemony, supremacy, or other forms of control over other nations (usually through violent coercion) to pursue its specific interests.[1][2][3] Ultranationalist entities have been associated with the engagement of political violence even during peacetime.[4]
In ideological terms, scholars such as the British political theoristRoger Griffin have found that ultranationalism arises from seeing modernnation-states as living organisms which are directly akin to physical people because they can decay, grow, and die, and additionally, they can experience rebirth. In stark, mythological ways, political campaigners have divided societies into those which are perceived as being degenerately inferior and those which are perceived as having great cultural destinies. Ultranationalism has been an aspect of fascism, with historic governments such as the regimes of Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany building on ultranationalist foundations by using specific plans for supposed widespread national renewal.[3]
Ultranationalism played a dominant role in the politics of the Empire of Japan, the Democratic Kampuchea, and the Socialist Republic of Romania. It has influenced parts of modern societies in Hungary, Israel, Russia, China, Saudi Arabia, and inspired terrorist groups in Sri Lanka and Greece. Ultranationalist characters have served as villains in multiple works of fictional media with popular acclaim.[5][6]
Britishpolitical theoristRoger Griffin has stated that ultranationalism is essentially founded on xenophobia in a way that finds supposed legitimacy "through deeply mythicized narratives of past cultural or political periods of historical greatness or of old scores to settle against alleged enemies". It can also draw on "vulgarized forms" of different aspects of the natural sciences such as anthropology and genetics, eugenics specifically playing a role, in order "to rationalize ideas of national superiority and destiny, of degeneracy and subhumanness" in Griffin's opinion. Ultranationalists view the modernnation-state as, according to Griffin, a living organism directly akin to a physical person such that it can decay, grow, die, and additionally experience rebirth. He has highlighted Nazi Germany as a regime which was founded on ultranationalism.[3]
According to American scholar Janusz Bugajski, summing up the doctrine in practical terms, "in its most extreme or developed forms, ultra-nationalism resembles fascism, marked by a xenophobic disdain of other nations, support for authoritarian political arrangements verging on totalitarianism, and a mythical emphasis on the 'organic unity' between a charismatic leader, an organizationally amorphous movement-type party, and the nation". Bugajski believes that civic nationalism and the related concept of patriotism both can contain significantly positive elements, contributing to the common social good at times such as during national calamities. These doctrines stand in contrast, in his opinion, to the extreme approach of certain ideologies with more irrational actions.[7]
The Cambodian historian Sambo Manara has found that the belief system sets forth a vision of supremacism in terms of international relations whereby xenophobia or hatred of foreigners to the point of extremism leads to policies of social separation and segregation. He has argued that the Cambodian genocide is a specific example of this ideology when it is applied in practice. "Obviously, it was ultranationalism, combined with the notion of class struggle in communism and a group of politicians, which lead to the establishment of Democratic Kampuchea, a ruthless regime which claimed approximately three million lives", he has remarked, with militant leaders finally deciding to "cut all diplomatic and economic ties with almost all countries" due to a "narrow-minded doctrine without taking into account all the losses they would face". In Manara's opinion, "this effectively destroyed the nation."[8]
Haaretz has also labeled the HungarianPrime MinisterViktor Orban an ultranationalist, due to his views on autocratic rule and racial identity, particularly, Orban's public condemnation of "race-mixing".[9] He has also been called an ultranationalist by NPR, an American news agency, citing his opposition to democratic liberalism.[10]
In late 2015, the Israeli political journalist Gideon Levy wrote that the Israeli–Palestinian conflict has led to the decay of the civil society within Israel, with an ultranationalist movement that "bases its power on incitement to hatred" using "folkloric religion" gaining ground over decades so that:
"They were the only ones willing to fight for a collective goal. They did not rule out any means. They extorted and exploited the weaknesses of government, the guilt feelings and confusion of the secular camp, and they won. They did so systematically and smartly: First they established the foundation of their existence, the settlement enterprise. After they achieved their goal– the killing off of any diplomatic agreement and destruction of the two-state solution– they were free to turn to their next target: taking control of the public debate in Israel on the road to changing its power structure, character and substance."[11]
In a 2021 story, the business-centered publication Bloomberg News stated that the rise of ultranationalist viewpoints in China, particularly in terms of those who advocate extremism on social media, presents a direct challenge to the current government of the nation, with CCP General SecretaryXi Jinping facing opposition to his attempts to set forth climate change based economic reforms in relation to greenhouse gases. Chinese political activists have asserted, according to the publication, a conspiracy theory that said that the reforms represent some kind of capitulation to foreign interests at the expense of individual Chinese people. Environmentalist policies have come into being in a complex fashion inside China, facing complicated opinions among many.[13]
Under the rule of Mohammed bin Salman, who formally serves as a Crown Prince, Saudi Arabia has been described by multiple analysts as embracing ultranationalism in a shift away from the government's previous reliance on Islamist political arguments.[14][15][16] For instance, the news agency France 24 stated in a 2019 report that while "promoting ultra-nationalism" the Crown Prince "has introduced glitzy concerts, magic shows and sporting extravaganzas with thumping after parties."[16] A 2019 article by the Financial Times likewise described the ideological shift as "a wave" that the leader had "swept across the kingdom".[15]
Currently represented in national governments or legislatures
The following political parties have been characterised as ultranationalist.
Arising out of strident Sri Lankan Tamil nationalism, with differing ethnic and religious groups placed at odds, the militant faction known as the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) orchestrated a decades long campaign of terrorism in the country of Sri Lanka, which is inside of the Indian Ocean and has been influenced by broader socio-political trends. Both ultranationalism as well as revolutionary ideologies aligned against capitalist policies influencing Sri Lankan life motivated the organization as it undertook a series of violent actions against both the national government and the supporters of the state. These attacks have collectively caused a large number of civilian deaths. For example, the Anuradhapura massacre committed by the LTTE on May 14, 1985 resulted in the killing of over one-hundred individuals inside of a holy city associated with local Buddhist worshippers. The militants deliberately targeted civilians socializing outdoors, such as by executing an elderlyflorist serving religious travelers.[257][258][259]
In the context of the LTTE's militant campaign, the academic publication Journal of Hate Studies found in a 2006 analysis that "ultranationalism subordinates all other claims for loyalty and allegiance" given that "[l]oyalty to the nation transcends loyalty to the family." Thus, "this notion explains the commitment of Tamil Tiger nationalists to [even] engage in suicide missions", since the journal stated that "[u]ltranationalist loyalty demands the willingness to sacrifice the self." In conclusion, the publication reported that an "extremist nationalist claim not only is understood as supreme, but [it] also is presented as urgent" and then demands political activists "must engage in preventive measures, such as ethnic cleansing or deportation".[259]
The assassination of Pavlos Fyssas in September 2013, a hip-hop musician with left-wing views, from stabbing wounds to the heart and ribs that occurred after his surrounding by multiple dozen Golden Dawn militants triggered widespread outrage at the Greek political organization. The ultranationalist attack occurred in an Athens suburb and resulted in a police crackdown with several arrests. The then Ministry of Public Order and Citizen Protection, Nikos Dendias, remarked that the "abominable murder" done "by an attacker sympathizing with Golden Dawn" publicly "illustrates, in the clearest way, the intentions of neo-Nazism".[260][261][262]
The organization held, at the time, 18 of the 300 seats in the Hellenic Parliament. Characterized as an extremist political party directly adapting the beliefs of Adolf Hitler, support for its ultranationalism increased in the context of the debate over spiking immigration to Greece. However, the Greek legal system ultimately investigated the assassination and other acts of violence with the outcome of an October 2020 verdict by the Athens Court of Appeals wiping out the party's leadership through prison sentences. Looking back, the British publication The Guardian reported in 2021, "Golden Dawn hit squads sowed terror on the streets, targeting immigrants, left[-]wing trade unionists[,] and other perceived opponents before a party operative ultimately confessed to the killing of Fyssas."[260][261][262]
The video gameCall of Duty 4: Modern Warfare has gained notice for its depiction of a civil war inside Russia between the country's government and an ultranationalist faction, with the entertainment production being released in 2007. Its sequels, Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 (2009) and Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 (2011), were set in the aftermath of an ultranationalist coup d'état in Russia and a subsequent war involving the American military. Militant leader Vladimir Makarov, a character in multiple games, notably declares at one point, "Russia will take all of Europe, even if it must stand upon a pile of ashes."[265][266]
"Nationalism on the rise as Saudi Arabia seeks sense of identity". Financial Times. 7 May 2019. Retrieved 23 February 2024. The attacks on the 10-second video, which was posted on Snapchat, were the latest example of a wave of ultranationalism that has swept across the kingdom in the three years since Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman consolidated his power.
Stewart, James (2 November 2019). "Anti-Muslim hate speech and displacement narratives: Case studies from Sri Lanka and Australia". Australian Journal of Social Issues. 54 (4): 418–435. doi:10.1002/ajs4.83. S2CID211418443.
Berlin, Oliver Moody (23 July 2019). "Frankenstein pact puts AfD in coalition". The Times. A married couple have run into trouble for forging the first local pact between Angela Merkel's party and the ultranationalist Alternative for Germany (AfD) in defiance of the chancellor.
"Serbia Names US-Sanctioned, Pro-Russian Politicians as Ministers". Balkan Insight. 30 April 2024. As expected, Milica Djurdjevic Stamenkovski, the leader of far-right party Zavetnici (Oathkeepers), which did not make it into parliament in December's elections, was given a post in the government, leading the Ministry for Demography and Family Care.
P. Ramet, Sabrina (1997). Whose democracy?: nationalism, religion, and the doctrine of collective rights in post-1989 Eastern Europe. Rowman & Littlefield. p.128. ISBN9780847683246. ...Meciar established his 1994 coalition government with the extreme-nacionalist Slovak National Party (SNS), led by Ján Slota, mayor of Zilina...
Eissenstat, Howard. (November 2002). Anatolianism: The History of a Failed Metaphor of Turkish Nationalism. Middle East Studies Association Conference. Washington, D.C.
Cupples, Julie (2022). Development and Decolonization in Latin America. Taylor & Francis. election of right-wing ultranationalist populist, Jair Bolsonaro
Minkenberg, Michael (2015). Transforming the Transformation?. Taylor & Francis. p.126. the rightward shift of Fidesz is noticeable by their growing co-optation of ultranationalist narratives
Rosenfeld, Alvin (2021). Contending with Antisemitism in a Rapidly Changing Political Climate. Indiana University Press. p.255. With its ultranationalist policy, Orban's Fidesz party managed to take over the positions of the far-right Jobbik party
deSouza, Peter Ronald (2006). India's Political Parties. SAGE. p.19. The other major national party of today, the Bharatiya Janata Party, does not quite fit the religious fundamentalist, the ethnicity-based or the fascist/ultra nationalist categories although it shares, to a large degree, elements of all three
Krieg, Andreas (2023). Subversion: The Strategic Weaponization of Narratives. Georgetown University Press. it has maintained connections with anti-EU, ultranationalist radical elements of ... Lega Nord
"Beautiful Harmony: Political Project Behind Japan's New Era Name – Analysis". eurasia review. 16 July 2019. The shifting dynamics around the new era name (gengō 元号) offers an opportunity to understand how the domestic politics of the LDP's project of ultranationalism is shaping a new Japan and a new form of nationalism.
Lunning, Frenchy, ed. (2013). Mechademia 4: War/Time. U of Minnesota Press. p.291. ISBN9781452942650. The overturning of the cab driver's 1998 sentiment in Akamatsu's 2007 piece had its political correlative in the victory of the ultranationalist wing of the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) when Abe Shinzō became Japan's prime minister in ...
Maki Kimura, ed. (2016). Unfolding the 'Comfort Women' Debates: Modernity, Violence, Women's Voices. Springer. ISBN9781137392510. ... a gradual drift towards more nationalistic attitudes to education and politics in general in contemporary Japanese society may party be explained by the effect of ultranationalist politicians in the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP).
Masanori Nakamura, ed. (2016). The Japanese Monarchy: Ambassador Joseph Grew and the Making of the "Symbol Emperor System," 1931-1991. M.E. Sharpe. p.1992. ISBN9781563241093. On July 31, a group of ultranationalist LDP Diet men, alarmed by Nakasone's diplomacy of "submission to foreign pressure" on issues like textbook revision and the Yasukuni Shrine problem, formed the "Association of Those Concerned ...
Minkenberg, Michael (2023). Depleting Democracies. Manchester University Press. PiS adopted LPR's identity politics both regarding minorities and the ultranationalist interpretation of Polish history and continued its ideological trajectory
Baybars Hawks, Banu (2018). Non-state actors in conflicts. p.43. In Poland, the ultranationalist Law and Justice Party (PiS) has significantly increased its vote share
Sabri Kiçmari, ed. (2022). History Continues: Three Models of the Continuation of History. Springer Nature. p.59. ISBN9789811984020. Putinism is not consistent as an ideology and political system. Public political attitudes have changed according to the circumstances. From a kind of cautious system to an open society, Putinism has moved significantly in the direction of the authoritarian system. His political party United Russia started as the conservative party of the former communists has moved towards ultranationalist and neo-imperialist ideology (Van Herpen 2013: 7). Van Harpen even qualifies Putinism as an unstable system of a slight variant of fascism-fascism lite. According to him, this system combines elements of proto-fascism, fascism and post-fascism, with a nucleus of ultra-nationalism, militarism and neo-imperialism (Van Herpen 2013: 8).
Chuck Stewart, ed. (2010). The Greenwood Encyclopedia of LGBT Issues Worldwide. Greenwood Press. p.360. ISBN9780313342356. In particular, Putin's efforts are attributed to the burgeoning growth of Russian ultranationalist sociopolitical organizations, such as United Russia (Yedinaya Rossiya) and Ours (Nashi, or Youth Movement - Ours!).
De Riencourt, Amauary (1950). Roof of the World, Tibet. Rinehart. p.176. Chiang Kai-Shek shook off the Soviet supervision and transmuted the Kuomintang into an ultranationalist movement
Gleis, Joshua (2012). Hezbollah and Hamas. Johns Hopkins University Press. p.19. It emphasized internal discipline, paramilitary organization and ultranationalist ideals
Piacentini A., Make Macedonia Great Again! The New Face of Skopje and the Macedonians’ identity dilemma edited by Evinç Doğan in Reinventing Eastern Europe: Imaginaries, Identities and Transformations; Place and space series; Transnational Press London, 2019; ISBN1910781878, p. 87.
Stojarová, Věra; Emerson, Peter. "Political parties in Serbia"(PDF). bochsler.eu. Bochsler, Center for Comparative and International Studies, University of Zurich.
"Escaping Ethnocentrism: The Radical Right in the Middle East and Africa". Centre for Analysis of the Radical Right. 6 April 2018. Archived from the original on 12 July 2023. Retrieved 10 June 2023. Moreover, the rise of fascism in interwar Europe was an inspirational source for variety of ultranationalist movements and parties that emerged in the Middle East and Africa. Take the Syrian Social Nationalist Party (SSNP), founded in 1932 by Antun Sa'adih, who had a specific mission: to lead the Lebanese people to their destiny.
"Ultra-nationalists, populists form 'Bulgarian Patriots' alliance for July elections". The Sofia Globe. 20 May 2021. Retrieved 17 June 2021. Ultra-nationalist parties VMRO and the National Front for the Salvation of Bulgaria, along with populists Volya, have agreed to stand together in Bulgaria's July 11, 2021 parliamentary elections under the name "Bulgarian Patriots", the parties announced on May 20.
Ruzicic-Kessler, Karlo (2011). From the Industrial Revolution to World War II in East Central Europe. Lit. p.194. the ultra-nationalist Ustase of Ante Pavelic
Cengiz, Firat (2013). Turkey and the European Union. Taylor & Francis. p.105. the ultranationalist Coalition for Republic-Republican Party of Czechoslovakia
Nissen, Henrik (1983). Scandinavia during the Second World War. Universitetsforlaget. p.25. The fascist-inspired, ultranationalist IKL (the Patriotic People's Movement)
Zander, Patrick (2020). Fascism Through History: Culture, Ideology, and Daily Life. ABC-CLIO. p.314. In Germany, the pressures of the depression helped the ultranationalist Nazi Party come to power by 1933
Payne, Stanley (1996). A History of Fascism, 1914–1945. University of Wisconsin Press. p.163. The chief political party of the ultranationalist right was the DNVP
Germany's New Nazis. Philosophical Library. 1952. p.17. The German Reich Party (conservative ultra-nationalist), which sent five members to the Federal Parliament in 1949
Tsatsanis, Emmanouil (2011), "Hellenism under siege: the national-populist logic of antiglobalization rhetoric in Greece", Journal of Political Ideologies, 16 (1): 11–31, doi:10.1080/13569317.2011.540939, S2CID143633586, ...and far right-wing newspapers such as Alpha Ena, Eleytheros Kosmos, Eleytheri Ora and Stohos (the mouthpiece of ultra-nationalist group Chrysi Avgi).
Faath, Sigrid (2006). Anti-Americanism in the Islamic World. Hurst. p.156. Considering the ultra-nationalist, anti-American rhetoric of the ruling Baath Party
Aronoff, Myron (2015). Power and Ritual in the Israel Labor Party. Taylor & Francis. Rehavim Zeevi, leader of the Ultranationalist Moledet (Homeland) Party
Khalfa, David (2009). Civil Organizations and Protest Movements in Israel. Palgrave Macmillan. p.50. The ultranationalist Right is represented by little political parties that compose the "orange camp," dedicated to retaining all parts of the "remained Land of Israel" at any cost: Benny Elon's HaIchud Haleumi, Baruch Marzel's Jewish National Front, and Mikael Kleiner's Herut party.
Todd, Allan (2015). European States in the Interwar Years (1918-1939). Cambridge University Press. p.19. Mussolini later formed the far-right ultra-nationalist Fascist Party
Djassi Amado, Abel. "The União Nacional in Cabo Verde, 1937-1945: Local Politics in an Imperial Political Party". Portuguese Literary & Cultural Studies: 132. The União Nacional was initially founded as a "patriotic league," tasked with buttressing support for the military regime. Upon assuming power in 1932, Salazar reengineered the party to his ideological and political image to stand on the twin pillars of ultranationalism and corporativism
Zelinska, Elisabeta (2013). Racism Postcolonialism Europe. Liverpool University Press. p.42. The Iron Guard was the ultra-nationalist, anti-Semitic, fascist movement and political party in Romania
Cercel, Cosmin (2015). Fascism and Criminal Law. Bloomsbury. p.112. King Carol II appointed a government from one of the wings of the ultranationalist movement, namely the National Christian Party led by Octavian Goga
Party Development and Democratic Change in Post-Communist Europe. 2001. p.169. Romania also witnessed cooperation between the ex-Communist PDSR and the ultra-nationalist National Unity Party
Coleman, Edmond (2014). Sexuality and Gender in Postcommunist Eastern Europe and Russia. Taylor & Francis. p.63. the ultranationalist Greater Romania Party
Genocide and Fascism. Taylor & Francis. 2008. p.244. The SLS was an ultranationalist, socially conservative, strongly anticommunist and anti-Semitic (albeit in the rather conventional 'anti-Jewish/Bolshevik' form) Catholic political movement
Dafydd Fell (22 January 2018). Government and Politics in Taiwan. Taylor & Francis. ISBN978-1-317-28506-9. The NP's shift to extreme nationalist positions after the late 1990s was also a reaction to the widespread departure of party moderates and subsequent domination by extremists. In the case of the NP, it appears that defeats no longer have any effect; instead, it operates consistently.
Gunter Schubert (20 May 2016). Routledge Handbook of Contemporary Taiwan. Taylor & Francis. ISBN978-1-317-66969-2. ... the rise of Chinese nationalist radicals in the NP after 1997 meant the party continued its move towards more extreme positions even after electoral setbacks (Fell 2006b: 47-67)
American Journal of Chinese Studies. American Association for Chinese Studies. 2005. p.12. ... Taiwan Solidarity Union (an ultranationalist pro-independence party created by former president Lee Teng-hui) won ...
Kuromiya, Hiroaki (2022). Stalin, Japan, and the Struggle for Supremacy Over China, 1894–1945. Taylor & Francis. Blue-Shirt society, an ultranationalist secret society
Neiberg, Michael (2004). Warfare & Society in Europe. Routledge. p.96. Several ultra - nationalist groups such as Action française and the veterans' group Croix de Feu
Nilsson, Per-Erik (2017). Unveiling the French Republic: National Identity, Secularism, and Islam in Contemporary France. Brill. p.70. Ultra-nationalist groups and parties like the Bloc identitaire
Fionna, Ulla, ed. (2015). Watching the Indonesian Elections 2014. ISEAS Publishing. p.106. ISBN9789814620833. Prabowo has accepted support from and declared his willingness to work with such organizations as the (notorious) radical Islamic group Front Pembela Islam (Defenders of Islam Front) and the ultra-nationalist Pemuda Pancasila
The German Side of the War in the Middle East 1939-1942. Stanford University. 1962. p.41. the notorious "Golden Square", four young ultra-nationalist colonels
"Israeli human rights groups alarmed by Zionist video attack". Sydney Morning Herald. 1 January 2016. An ultra-nationalist Israeli group has published a video accusing the heads of four of Israel's leading human rights organisations of being foreign agents funded by Europe and supporting Palestinians "involved in terrorism". The widely-viewed 68-second video, made by radical Zionist group Im Tirtzu
"Jerusalem Jewish group on anti-Arab patrol". BBC. 9 February 2016. an ultra-nationalist Jewish group called Lehava has been organising patrols aimed at stopping Jewish Israelis from even talking to Arabs.
Pedahzur, Ami (2013). The Israeli Response to Jewish Extremism and Violence. Manchester University Press. Of the movements associated with ultranationalist right-wing notions, the Etzel and the Lehi were the most noteworthy in their use of violence and terrorism
Sprinzak, Ehud (1991). The Ascendance of Israel's Radical Right. OUP. p.23. It was the ultranationalist wing of Revisionism, and was articulated by organizations such as Brit Habirionim and Lehi
O'Connor, Eimear (2009). Sean Keating in Context: Responses to Culture and Politics in Post-civil War Ireland. Carysfort Press. p.36. ISBN978-1904505419.
"Abe's cabinet reshuffle". East Asia Forum. 14 September 2019. Abe also rewarded right-wing politicians who are close to him — so-called 'ideological friends' who are being increasingly pushed to the forefront of his administration — such as LDP Executive Acting Secretary-General Koichi Hagiuda who was appointed Education Minister. As a member of the ultranationalist Nippon Kaigi (Japan Conference), which seeks to promote patriotic education, he can be considered 'reliable' as the government's policy leader on national education.
"Japanese minister becomes first in two years to visit Tokyo's controversial Yasukuni Shrine". South China Morning Post. 17 October 2019. Retrieved 5 June 2020. Eto is serving in his first cabinet position and is a member of the ultranationalist Nippon Kaigi organisation, whose aims are to revise the "national consciousness" surrounding the prosecution of Japan's war criminals and to change the nation's pacifist constitution implemented after the war. The group also promotes "patriotic education".
"Japan combats rise in hate speech". Al Jazeera. 30 November 2015. Retrieved 5 June 2020. ... and many don't speak Korean or have ties to Korea. Even so, ultranationalist groups like Zaitokukai have singled them out and used Japan's very liberal protection of speech to harass, intimidate and silence Zainichi with noisy street protests and attacks online, often anonymously.
"Head of anti-foreigner group Zaitokukai to step down". Japan Times. 30 November 2015. Retrieved 5 June 2020. The longtime chairman of the ultranationalist group Zaitokukai has announced he will step down and even give up his membership in the group, saying the move will eventually bolster the organization's influence.
"The Palestinian Islamic Jihad's US Cell"(PDF). Foreign Policy Research Institute. December 2009. a central feature of the PIJ platform combines Islamic fanaticism and extreme nationalism
"מילון ארגוני טרור". Shabak. בהשפעת הענף המצרי הוקם בעזה, בשנת 1981, "הג'האד האסלאמי בפלסטין", המשלב אידיאולוגיה לאומית קיצונית עם התפיסות האסלאמיות: השמדת מדינת ישראל והחלפתה במדינה פלסטינית אסלאמית, שתוקם על כל שטחי פלסטין.
Transformations in Central Europe between 1989 and 2012: Geopolitical, Cultural, and Socioeconomic Shifts. Tomas Kavaliauskas. Lexington Books. 2012. ISBN9780739174111. Chapter 4, page 60.
Kang, Jun-man (13 November 2006), 한국 현대사 산책 1940년대편 1: 8·15 해방에서 6·25 전야까지(개정판)[A Walk Through Modern Korean History, 1940s Vol. 1: From the 15 August Liberation until the Eve of the Korean War (Revised Edition)] (in Korean), 인물과사상사, p.326, ISBN978-89-5906-044-3, archived from the original on 15 December 2023, retrieved 15 May 2023
Alessio, Dominic; Meredith, Kristen (2014). "Blackshirts for the Twenty–First Century? Fascism and the English Defence League". Social Identities. 20 (1): 104–118. doi:10.1080/13504630.2013.843058. S2CID143518291.
Combs, Cynthia (2022). Terrorism in the Twenty-First Century. Taylor & Francis. The Proud Boys are an ultranationalist organization active in the United States