Superstate

This article is about the political concept. For the quantum mechanics principle, see Quantum superposition.

Not to be confused with Supranational union.

A superstate is defined as "a large and powerful state formed when several smaller countries unite",^[1] or "A large and powerful state formed from a federation or union of nations",^[2] or "a hybrid form of polity that combines features of ancient empires and modern states."^[3] This is distinct from the concept of superpower, although these are sometimes seen together.^[4]

History

In the early 20th century, "superstate" had a similar definition as today's supranational organisations. In a 1927 article by Edward A. Harriman on the League of Nations, a superstate was defined as merely "an organisation, of which a state is a member, which is superior to the member themselves", in that "[a] complete superstate has legislative, executive and judicial organs to make, to execute and to interpret its laws". According to this definition, Harriman saw the League of Nations as a "rudimentary superstate", and the United States of America as "an example of a complete and perfect superstate".^[5]

In World Order of Bahá'u'lláh, first published in 1938, Shoghi Effendi, the Guardian of the Baháʼí Faith, described the anticipated world government of that religion as the "world’s future super-state" with the Baháʼí Faith as the "State Religion of an independent and Sovereign Power."^[6]

In the 1970s, academic literature used the term "superstate" to indicate a particularly rich and powerful state, in a similar fashion to the term superpower. In this context, the term was applied to Japan,^[7][8] as contemporary academics suggested that Japan could displace the U.S. as the world's sole superpower, becoming the world's foremost economic power in the (then) near future because of its economic growth in recent decades.^[7] The prediction did not come true.

In contemporary political debate, especially the one centred on the European Union, the term "superstate" is used to indicate a development in which the Union develops from its current de facto status^[9] as a confederation to become a fully-fledged federation, known as the United States of Europe. For instance, Glyn Morgan contrasts the perspective of a "European superstate" to the ones of "a Europe of nation-states" and of "a post-sovereign European polity".^[10]: 202 In her definition, a "European superstate is nothing more than a sovereign state - a tried and tested type of polity that predominates in the modern world - operating on a European wide scale",^[10]: 204 i.e., "a unitary European state".^[10]: ix Especially after the European debt crisis, economic literature started to discuss the role of European union as a European superstate. In particular,^[11] they compared the emergence of a debt union to the federal structure of Germany.

The term was famously used by Margaret Thatcher in her 1988 Bruges speech, when she decried the perspective of "a European super-state exercising a new dominance from Brussels",^[12] and has since entered the eurosceptic lexicon. Tony Blair argued in 2000 that he welcomed an EU as a "superpower, not a superstate".^[13]

In a 2022 study, Alasdair Roberts argues that superstates should be construed as hybrid forms of political organization: "Every superstate carries the burdens of statehood, that is, the duties of intensive governance and respect for human rights that are carried by all modern states. But superstates also carry the burdens of empire, principally the burden of holding together a large and diverse population spread across a vast territory. Superstates are distinguished from ordinary states by problems of governance that are intensified by scale, diversity, and complexity".^[14]: 18 In this view, a superstate need not be highly centralized, just as some empires were not highly centralized. Thus is it possible to describe the European Union as a superstate without conceding that is a "centralized, unitary leviathan".^{[14] : 121}

Fictional superstates

• Atlantic Federation (Gundam anime metaseries)
• The Alliance for Democracy in The Domination, which originated as a military alliance before being unified into a single nation.
• Earth Alliance in:
  • Babylon 5
  • The History of Galaxy novel series
• Eastasia, Eurasia and Oceania in Nineteen Eighty-Four
• Federation of the Americas from Call of Duty: Ghosts
• Gundam in the Cosmic Era timeline of Mobile Suit Gundam SEED
• Interstellar Alliance (Babylon 5)
• Fleet of Worlds
• Galactic Empire (Star Wars)
• Galactic Empire (Isaac Asimov universe)
• Galactic Republic
• Imperium of Mankind
• Mega-City One
• Meccania
• United Federation of Planets
• The Dominion (Star Trek)
• The World State
• Unified Earth Government from Halo
• United States of Africa
• United States of Europe
• United Nations (Of Earth) from The Expanse
• The Outer Planets Alliance (OPA) from The Expanse
• Tamrielic Empire (Septim Dynasty) from The Elder Scrolls

See also

• China
• Imperial Federation
• India
• List of countries and dependencies by area
• Organization of American States
• Soviet Union
• United States

Notes

1. "Superstate", Cambridge dictionaries online
2. "superstate - Definition of superstate in English by Oxford Dictionaries". Oxford Dictionaries - English. Archived from the original on July 12, 2012.
3. Roberts, Alasdair. Superstates: Empires of the Twenty-First Century. (Cambridge, UK: Polity Press, 2022), 122.
4. Roberts, Alasdair. Superstates: Empires of the Twenty-First Century. (Cambridge, UK: Polity Press, 2022), 17.
5. Edward A. Harriman, The League of Nations a Rudimentary Superstate, American Political Science Review / Volume 21 / Issue 01 / February 1927, pp 137-140
6. Effendi, Shoghi (1938). "Local and National Houses of Justice". The World Order of Bahá'u'lláh. Wilmette, Illinois, USA: Baháʼí Publishing Trust. p. 7. ISBN 978-0-87743-231-9 – via Bahá’í Reference Library.
7. WICKRAMASINGHE, V. K. (June 1973). "JAPAN — THE EMERGING SUPERSTATE ? Some Thoughts on Herman Kahn". The Developing Economies. 11 (2): 196–210. doi:10.1111/j.1746-1049.1973.tb00306.x.
8. Oka, Takashi (1970-12-13). "The Emerging Japanese Superstate". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2024-07-10.
9. Kiljunen, Kimmo (2004). The European Constitution in the Making. Centre for European Policy Studies. pp. 21–26. ISBN 978-92-9079-493-6.
10. Glyn Morgan, The Idea of a European Superstate: Public Justification and European Integration Princeton University Press, 2009, ISBN 9781400828050
11. Erkut, Burak (24 December 2015). "A Super Indebted European Superstate". Review of Applied Socio-Economic Research. 10: 4–10 – via ResearchGate.
12. Margaret Thatcher, Speech to the College of Europe ("The Bruges Speech"), 20 September 1988
13. Stephen Haseler, Super-State: The New Europe and Its Challenge to America, p. 85
14. Roberts, Alasdair (2022). Superstates: Empires of the Twenty-First Century. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press. ISBN 9781509544479.