Wahhabi War

The Wahhabi war,^[4] also known as the Ottoman–Saudi War,^[5] was fought from early 1811 until 1818 between the Ottoman Empire, its vassal the Eyalet of Egypt, and the Emirate of Diriyah, the First Saudi State, resulting in the destruction of the latter.

Wahhabi War
Yanbu Al-Safra Medina Jeddah Mecca Diriyah
Date 1811 – 15 September 1818 Location Arabian Peninsula Result Ottoman-Egyptian victory
Belligerents
Emirate of Diriyah	Ottoman Empire Eyalet of Egypt
Commanders and leaders
Saud I # Abdallah I  Ghaliyya al-Badry † Sheikh Sulayman	Mahmud II Tusun Pasha † Muhammad Ali Ibrahim Pasha Ibrahim Agha † Isma'il Pasha Abu Jabal (WIA)
Casualties and losses
9,000 killed 6,000 wounded[1][page needed]	10,000–12,000[2][3] 4,000–5,000 in Al-Safra[2] 4,700 in Nejd[3]

Names

The war is also referred to by several other names, such as the "Ottoman-Wahhabi war",^[6][7][8] "Egyptian-Wahhabi war",^[9] "Egyptian-Saudi war",^[10] "Ottoman/Egyptian-Wahhabi war",^[11][12] etc.

Background

Although Muhammad Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab, the leader of the Wahhabi movement,^[13] had indirectly expressed critiques on the Ottoman dynasty in his letters, he had decided not to publicly challenge the legitimacy of the empire as a precautionary measure. Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab did not acknowledge their caliphate claims, an assertion made by Sultan Abdul Hamid I after Ottoman defeat in the 1770s Russo-Turkish War, to portray himself as the leader of Muslim world.^[14] However, this did not imply that Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab sought a conflict with Ottomans, as classical Wahhabi doctrines did not view the establishment of caliphate as a necessity upon individual Muslims. Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab was rather alarmed by the erosion of religious morality in neighboring Ottoman vilayets and found fault with the administrative functioning of the Ottoman empire, which he criticized for not properly enforcing Shari'ah (Islamic law) in its territories.^[15] The Wahhabis offered an alternative religious and political model to that of the Ottomans and they also claimed Islamic leadership on a different basis.^[16]

Political hostilities and distrust would eventually lead the Wahhabis and the Ottomans to declare mutual exchanges of Takfir (excommunication), many years after Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab's death.^[17] By the 1790s, the Muwahhidun had consolidated their rule over most regions of Central Arabia. The growing Wahhabi influence alarmed Ghaleb, the Sharif of Mecca, who responded by initiating warfare with the Saudis in 1793; until his surrender in 1803. Intending to form an armed coalition to defeat the Muwahhidun, he corresponded with the Ottoman authorities in Istanbul and sought to turn them hostile against his rivals by portraying them as disbelievers. Similar overtures were also made by the ruler of Baghdad. Such reports eventually succeeded in turning the Ottoman bureaucratic opinion significantly hostile against the Wahhabis. In 1797, Sulayman the Great, the Mamluk governor of Iraq, invaded Diriyah with around 15,000 troops in co-ordination with Ghalib and laid a one-month siege to Al-Ahsa. However, re-inforcements led by Saud ibn 'Abd al-Azeez would force the Ottomans to retreat. After three days of skirmish, Sulayman the Great and the Saudis came to a peace settlement which was to last for six years. However, the peace would be broken in 1801, when a caravan of pilgrims protected by a Saudi convoy was plundered near Hail; upon orders from the Mamluk administration in Baghdad. This attack would completely break down the already deteriorating Saudi-Ottoman diplomatic relations, and the Emirate of Dirʿiyya sent a large-scale expedition towards Iraq.^[18]

In 1802, 12,000 Wahhabis sacked Karbala in Iraq killing up to 5,000 people and plundering the Imam Husayn shrine.^[19] Saudi forces led by 'Abd al Aziz entered Mecca in 1803 after defeating Ghalib. The assassination in November 1803 of Saudi Emir 'Abd al-'Aziz during prayers in al-Dir'iyya by an Iraqi; was suspected of being orchestrated by the Mamluk governor of Baghdad, which greatly deteriorated the Saudi-Ottoman relations. Ghalib had worked hard to dampen the prospects of reconciliation between the Emirate of Diriyah and Ottoman Empire.^[20] In the ensuing conflict, the Wahhabis had controlled Mecca and Medina by 1805.^[19] The Saudi emir denounced the Ottoman sultan and called into question the validity of his claim to be caliph and guardian of the sanctuaries of the Hejaz.^[21] The Wahhabis also attacked Ottoman trade caravans which interrupted Ottoman finances.^[22]

In response, the Ottoman sultan, Mahmud II, ordered Muhammad 'Ali, governor of Egypt, to attack the Wahhabi state in December 1807.^[21] Ali had embarked on an extensive modernisation program that included a significant expansion of Egypt's military forces. The Ottomans had grown increasingly wary of Ali's reign. ordering him to go to war with the Wahhabi state would serve their interests regardless as the destruction of either would be beneficial to them.^[22] Tensions between Ali and his troops also prompted him to send them to Arabia and fight against the Wahhabi movement where many would die.^[23] Events within Egypt delayed delayed the expedition until 1811.^[21]

Campaigns

Muhammad Ali was ordered to crush the Saudi state as early as December 1807 by Sultan Mustafa IV, however internal strife within Egypt prevented him from giving his full attention to the Wahhabis. The Ottoman troops were not able to recapture the holy cities until 1811.^[21]

Map of the first Saudi state with Egypt

In 1811, the Ottomans landed in Yanbu and took over the city after a bloodless confrontation in the Battle of Yanbu where all Saudi forces surrendered.^[24] The Ottoman troops then moved south to attempt a recapture of Medina, however the Ottomans were decisively defeated at the Battle of Al-Safra in 1812. 5,000 Ottoman troops were killed by the Saudis who successfully defended the area. The Ottomans were forced to retreat back to Yanbu.^[3] Muhammad Ali Pasha sent 20,000 troops to help Tusun Pasha recapture Medina. The Ottomans successfully captured the city after the Battle of Medina in November 1812.^[25][26] This combined force captured from the Saudi forces the city of Jeddah, In January 1813, Ottoman troops captured Mecca.^[27]

In 1815, one of the main rebels, Bakhroush bin Alass of Zahran tribe, was killed and beheaded by Muhammad Ali forces in Al Qunfudhah.^[28] In the spring of 1815, Ottoman forces inflicted large-scale defeat upon the Saudis, forcing them to conclude a peace treaty. Under the terms of treaty, the Saudis had to let go of Hijaz. Abdullah ibn Saud was forced to acknowledge himself as the vassal of the Ottoman Empire and obey the Turkish Sultan unquestionably. However, neither Muhammad Ali nor the Ottoman Sultan had confirmed the treaty.^[29]

A route-map of Ibrahim Pasha's Campaign into Dir'iyya

Suspicious of Abdullah, the Wahhabi Emir, the Ottomans resumed the war in 1816, with the assistance of French military instructors. The Egyptian troops were led by Muhammad Ali's elder son, Ibrahim Pasha, and penetrated into the heart of Central Arabia, besieging the chief centres of Qasim and Najd. Waging a war of extermination between 1816 and 1818, the invading armies pillaged various towns and villages, forcing the inhabitants to flee and seek refuge in remote regions and oases. By 1817, the armies had overrun Rass, Buraida and Unayza.^[29] Saudi armies put up a fierce resistance at Al-Rass where they withstood a siege of 3 months. Faced with the advance of Egyptian Ottomans, Abdullah, the Saudi Emir retreated to Diriya.^[30][31]

The Ottomans began the Najd Expedition in 1818, involving a series of military conflicts. En route to Dariyya, the Ottoman armies executed everyone over ten years age in Dhurma. Ibrahim's forces would march towards Diriyya during the early months of 1818, easily routing Saudi resistances and arrive at the capital by April 1818. The Siege of Diriyah would last until September 1818, with the Ottoman forces waiting for Saudi supplies to run out.^[30] On 11 September 1818, Abdullah Ibn Saud would sue for peace, offering his surrender, in exchange for sparing Diriyya. However, Al Diriyya would be razed to ground under orders of Ibrahim Pasha.^[32][33]

It was not until September 1818 that the Wahhabi state ended with the surrendering of its leaders and the head of the Wahhabi state, Abdullah bin Saud, who was sent to Istanbul to be executed.^[21] Thus, the Emirate of Diriyah formally ended with the surrendering of its leaders and the head of the Wahhabi state, Abdullah bin Saud, was taken captive and sent to Istanbul. In December, Emir Abdullah ibn Saud was executed with the public display of his corpse, upon the orders of the Ottoman Sultan.^[32][30]

The British Empire welcomed Ibrahim Pasha's siege of Diriyah with the goal of promoting trade interests in the region. Captain George Forster Sadleir, an officer of the British Army in India was dispatched from Bombay to consult with Ibrahim Pasha in Dariyya.^[34]

Aftermath

Painting of Abdullah bin Saud

George Forster Sadleir left a record on the aftermath of the former capital of the First Saudi state:

"The site of Deriah is in a deep ravine north-west of Munfooah, about ten miles distant. It is now in ruins, and the inhabitants who were spared, or escaped from the slaughter, have principally sought shelter here ... Munfooah ... was surrounded with a wall and ditch which the Pacha ordered to be razed .... Riad is not so well peopled .... The inhabitants were at that time in a more wretched state than at any prior period since the establishment of the power of the Wahabees. Their walls, the chief security for their property, had been razed ... The year's crop had been consumed by the Turkish force"^[35]

Saudi ruler 'Abdullah ibn Saud was transported first to Cairo and then to Istanbul, wherein he was beheaded alongside several other Wahhabi Imams.^[36] Other than 'Abdullah, most of the political leaders were treated well but the Ottomans were far harsher with the religious leaders that inspired the Wahhabi movement, executing Sūlayman ibn 'Abd Allah Aal-Shaykh and other religious notables, as they were thought to be uncompromising in their beliefs and therefore a much bigger threat than political leaders. The executions were also motivated by Ottoman resentment of Wahhabist views.^[21]

After the Destruction of Diriyya, Ibrahim Pasha rounded up the prominent survivors of the Saudi family and the scholarly Al ash-Sheikh many of whom were deported to Egypt. As per Ottoman estimates, over 250 members related to the Saudi family and 32 members related to the Al ash-Sheikh were exiled. Ottomans were far harsher with the religious leaders that inspired the Wahhabi movement, than with the members of the Saudi family. Prominent scholars such as the Qadi of Dir'iyya, Sulayman ibn 'Abd Allah (the grandson of Muhammad ibn Abdul-Wahhaab) were tortured, forced to listen to guitar (knowing the Najdi prescriptions and customs that prohibited music) and executed by a firing-squad. Other ulema such as Abd Allah ibn Muhammad Aal Al-Shaikh and his nephew Abd al Rahman ibn Hasan Aal Al-Shaikh would be exiled to Egypt. (the latter would return to Najd in 1825, to revive and lead the Wahhabi movement). Some other Qadis and scholars were hunted down and executed. Abd al Aziz ibn Hamad al Mu'ammar managed to settle in Bahrain, where the ruler welcomed him. Few scholars managed to escape to the remote Southern corners of Arabia. The executions reflected the deep Ottoman resentment of Wahhabi movement and also how seriously they viewed its threat. Altogether, the Najdis lost about two dozen scholars and men from the ulema families in the aftermath of the invasion. However, the suppression of Wahhabites in Central Arabia ultimately proved to be a failed campaign.^[37][21]

Later, Ibrahim Pasha and his troops went on to conquer Qatif and el-Hasa. Remnants of Saudi fortifications were demolished across Najd. Emir's relatives and important Wahhabi leaders were made captives and sent to Egypt. In December 1819, Ibrahim Pasha returned to Egypt after formally incorporating Hejaz into the Ottoman Empire. However, they were unable to totally subdue the opposition forces and Central Arabia became a region of permanent Wahhabi uprisings.^[29] In the 1820s, Prince Turki ibn 'Abd Allah ibn Muhammed ibn Saud, gathering growing support from tribes and groups that opposed the Turkish occupation, would lay Siege to Riyadh in 1823. By August 1824, Saudi forces would capture Riyadh in a Second Siege, thus establishing the Second Saudi State with Riyadh as its capital.^[38]

Following the fall of Emirate of Dirʿiyya, the British empire launched their Persian Gulf campaign of 1819. A formidable force consisting of 2,800 British soldiers and 3 warships fought the Qasimi tribesmen allied to Dir'iyya. Their city Ras al Khaimah was demolished in 1819. The General Maritime treaty was concluded in 1820 with the local chieftains, which would eventually transform them into a protectorate of Trucial States; heralding a century of British supremacy in the Gulf.^[39]

This war had formed the basic hatred of the Wahhabi movement amongst the Ottomans, and continues to influence modern Turkey wherein many Turkish Islamic preachers consider Wahhabism to be un-Islamic. The Saudis, who would form the nation a century later, considered it as the first struggle for independence from the Ottoman Empire, and continued to view Turkey with suspicion. The current state of Saudi-Turkey relations are still influenced by this hostile past. To the present day, both Saudi and Turkish nationalist writers accuse each other of engaging in systematic campaigns to rewrite history.^{[40][41][42][43][44]}

See also

• Fitnat al-Wahhabiyya
• Hadith of Najd
• List of wars involving Saudi Arabia
• Nejd Expedition
• Saudi Arabia–Turkey relations
• Khawarij

References

1. Vasiliev, Alexei (2000). The History of Saudi Arabia. NYU Press. ISBN 978-0-8147-8809-7. Retrieved 21 February 2017.
2. Othman bin Bishr, Glory in the History of Najd, p. 418
3. The era of Muhammad Ali. Abd al Rahman al Rafai. p. 127
4. Sources:

   • James Wynbrandt (2010). A Brief History of Saudi Arabia. Infobase Publishing. p. 351. ISBN 978-0-8160-7876-9. Wahhabi war
   • Franzén, Johan (2021). Pride and Power: A Modern History of Iraq. London, UK: Hurst publishers. p. 507. ISBN 9781787383951.
   • Hurgronje, Dr. C. Snoucke (1917). The Revolt in Arabia (PDF). New York, USA: G. P. Putnam's Sons. p. 22. LCCN 17007479.
   • Lyall, Jason (2020). "Appendix I". Divided Armies: Inequality and Battlefield Performance in Modern War. Princeton, New Jersey, USA: Princeton University Press. p. 436. ISBN 9780691192437.
5. Sources:

   • John Victor Tolan; Gilles Veinstein; Henry Laurens (2013). Europe and the Islamic World: A History. Princeton University Press. p. 277. ISBN 978-0-691-14705-5. The Ottoman-Saudi War...
   • Commins, David (2006). The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia. London: I.B Tauris. p. 46. ISBN 1-84511-080-3.
   • McNabb, James Brian (2017). "1: Napoleon's Egyptian campaign and the Decline of the Ottoman empire". A Military History of the Modern Middle East. California, USA: ABC-CLIO. p. 31. ISBN 978-1-4408-2963-5.
6. Meredith Reid Sarkees; Frank Wayman (2010). Resort to War: 1816 - 2007. Sage. p. 198. ISBN 978-0-87289-434-1.
7. Richard Engel (2016). Two Decades in the Middle East. Simon and Schuster. p. 40. ISBN 978-1-4516-3512-6. The Ottomans pushed back with the 1811–18 Ottoman Wahhabi War, led by the Ottoman's viceroy in Egypt.
8. Valerie Anishchenkova (2020). Modern Saudi Arabia. ABC-CLIO. p. 42. ISBN 978-1-4408-5705-8. Although the Ottomans were able to defeat the First Saudi State in the Ottoman-Wahhabi War (1811–1818), the House of Al Saud was able to restore its rule in Central and Eastern Arabia in a short time.
9. James Wynbrandt (2010). A Brief History of Saudi Arabia. Infobase Publishing. p. 352. ISBN 978-0-8160-7876-9. Egyptian-Wahhabi war
10. John Victor Tolan; Gilles Veinstein; Henry Laurens (2013). Europe and the Islamic World: A History. Princeton University Press. p. 454. ISBN 978-0-691-14705-5. Egyptian Saudi War (1811–1818)
11. Spahic Omer (2024). Non-Muslims in Makkah and Madinah (1503-1853). Kuala Lumpur: International Islamic University Malaysia (IIUM) Press. p. 190. ISBN 9789674913397. The episode was followed by the Ottoman/Egyptian-Wahhabi war that lasted from 1811 to 1818 and which resulted in the victory of the former.
12. Emine Ö. Evered (2012). Empire and Education under the Ottomans: Politics, Reform and Resistance from the Tanzimat to the Young Turks. Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 5. ISBN 978-0-85773-260-6.
13. "Wahhabism". Oxford Bibliographies. Oxford University Press. Archived from the original on 19 November 2012. Wahhabism properly refers to the 18th-century revival and reform movement begun in the region of Najd, in what is today Saudi Arabia, by Islamic religious and legal scholar Muhammad Ibn ʿAbd al-Wahhab.
14. Crawford, Michael (2014). "Chapter 8: Wahhabism, Saudi States, and Foreign Powers; Wahhabi View of the Ottomans". Makers of the Muslim World: Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab. London: One World Publishers. pp. 94–96. ISBN 978-1-78074-589-3. Nor did he acknowledge the Ottoman caliphate. The Ottomans asserted this status only after territorial losses to the Russians in the 1770s. They sought to compensate for growing political and military debilitation by claiming spiritual ascendancy over Muslims everywhere.
15. Crawford, Michael (2014). "Chapter 8: Wahhabism, Saudi States, and Foreign Powers; Wahhabi View of the Ottomans". Makers of the Muslim World: Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab. London: One World Publishers. pp. 94–96. ISBN 978-1-78074-589-3. Claims that in defying the sultan the Saudi imam intended to supplant the caliph were unfounded. Classical Wahhabism never accepted the need for a universal caliphate, let alone advocated it or claimed it on behalf of the Saudis or the Arabs more generally. It was part of established Sunni thought that the legitimacy of the caliphate derived from enforcement of the shari'a. In his repudiation of the theological stance of the Ottomans and his uninhibited criticism of religious conditions in Ottoman provinces, Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab made it plain that God's law remained unenforced there
16. Crawford, Michael (2014). "Chapter 8: Wahhabism, Saudi States, and Foreign Powers; Wahhabi View of the Ottomans". Makers of the Muslim World: Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab. London: One World Publishers. pp. 94–96. ISBN 978-1-78074-589-3.
17. Crawford, Michael (2014). "Chapter 8: Wahhabism, Saudi States, and Foreign Powers; Wahhabi View of the Ottomans". Makers of the Muslim World: Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab. London: One World Publishers. p. 96. ISBN 978-1-78074-589-3.
18. Lewis Burckhardt, John (1831). "Materials for a History of the Wahabys". Notes on the Bedouins and Wahabys Vol.II. London: Henry Colburn and Richard Bentley. pp. 180–186.
19. Bowen, Wayne H. (2008). The History of Saudi Arabia. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. p. 153. ISBN 978-0-313-34012-3. OCLC 166388162.
20. Crawford, Michael (2014). "Chapter 8: Wahhabism, Saudi states, and Foreign Powers". Makers of the Muslim World: Ibn 'Abd al-Wahhab. London: One World Publishers. pp. 90–92. ISBN 978-1-78074-589-3.
21. Elizabeth Sirriyeh, Salafies, "Unbelievers and the Problems of Exclusivism". Bulletin (British Society for Middle Eastern Studies), Vol. 16, No. 2. (1989), pp. 123–132. (Text online at JSTOR)
22. Afaf Lutfi al-Sayyid-Marsot. A History of Egypt From the Islamic Conquest to the Present. New York: Cambridge UP, 2007.
23. Fahmy, K. (2012). Mehmed Ali: From Ottoman Governor to Ruler of Egypt. Oneworld Publications. p. 30. ISBN 978-1-78074-211-3.
24. "Saudi Arabia – Daily life and social customs | Britannica". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 15 May 2022.
25. David Commins (30 March 2009). The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia. I.B.Tauris. p. 42. ISBN 978-0-85773-135-7.
26. Ira M. Lapidus (22 August 2002). A History of Islamic Societies. Cambridge University Press. p. 572. ISBN 978-0-521-77933-3.
27. Kiselev Kirill Alexandrovich. "ЕГИПЕТ И ГОСУДАРСТВО ВАХХАБИТОВ: "ВОЙНА В ПУСТЫНЕ" (1811-1818 гг.)" [Egypt and the Wahhabi State: the "war in the desert" (1811-1818)] (in Russian). Archived from the original on 5 December 2014. Retrieved 5 April 2015.
28. Giovanni Finati (1830). Narrative of the Life and Adventures of Giovanni Finati, Native of Ferrara: Who, Under the Assumed Name of Mahomet, Made the Campaigns Against the Wahabees for the Recovery of Mecca and Medina; and Since Acted as Interpreter to European Travellers in Some Parts Least Visited of Asia and Africa. J. Murray.
29. Borisovich Lutsky, Vladimir (1969). "Chapter VI. The Egyptian Conquest of Arabia". Modern History of the Arab Countries. Moscow: Progress Publishers, USSR Academy of Sciences, Institute of the Peoples of Asia. ISBN 0-7147-0110-6.
30. Commins, David (2006). The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia. London: I.B Tauris. p. 37. ISBN 1-84511-080-3.
31. Simons, Geoff (1998). Saudi Arabia: The Shape of a Client Feudalism. London: MacMillan Press Ltd. p. 153. ISBN 978-1-349-26728-6.
32. M Zarabazo, Jamal Al-Din (2005). The Life, Teachings and Influence of Muhammad ibn Abul-Wahhaab. Riyadh: The Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Endowments, Dawah and Guidance, The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. pp. 54–55. ISBN 9960-29-500-1.
33. Commins, David (2006). The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia. London: I.B Tauris. pp. 37–39. ISBN 1-84511-080-3.
34. Simons, Geoff (1998). Saudi Arabia: The Shape of a Client Feudalism. London: MacMillian Press. p. 153. ISBN 978-1-349-26728-6. The British in India had welcomed Ibrahim Pasha's siege of Diriyah: if the 'predatory habits' of the Wahhabists could be extirpated from the Arabian peninsula, so much the better for British trade in the region. It was for this reason that Captain George Forster Sadleir, an officer of the British Army in India (HM 47th regiment), was sent from Bombay to consult Ibrahim Pasha in Diriyah.
35. Simons, Geoff (1998). Saudi Arabia: The Shape of a Client Feudalism. London: MacMillian Press. pp. 153–154. ISBN 978-1-349-26728-6.
36. Al-Rasheed, Kersten, Shterin, Madawi, Carol, Marat; Al-Rasheed, Madawi (2015). "5: The Wahhabis and the Ottoman Caliphate: The Memory of Historical Antagonism". Demystifying the Caliphate: Historical Memory and Contemporary Contexts. New York: Oxford University Press. p. 122. ISBN 978-0-19-932795-9. The Wahhabi leader, Abdullah Ibn Sa'ud, was defeated and transported first to Cairo then to Istanbul, where together with several Wahhabi imams he was beheaded{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
37. Commins, David (2006). The Wahhabi Mission and Saudi Arabia. London: I.B Tauris. pp. 37–38, 40, 42–43. ISBN 1-84511-080-3.
38. Simons, Geoff (1998). Saudi Arabia: The Shape of a Client Feudalism. London: MacMillian Press. p. 157. ISBN 978-1-349-26728-6.
39. Parry, Jonathan (2022). "3: The Wahhabi, the Qawasim, and British Sea Power in the Gulf". Promised Lands: The British and the Ottoman Middle East. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. pp. 100–101. ISBN 978-0-691-18189-9.
40. "Turkophobia is behind the Saudi-washing of Ottoman history". TRT World. 5 September 2019.
41. "Saudi's MBC launching new drama series 'exposing Ottoman tyranny'". Ahval.
42. AL-TORIFI, TALAL (23 July 2020). "Turks defrauding history with Ottoman monuments narrative". Arab News. Archived from the original on 23 July 2020.
43. Al-Torifi, Talal (21 July 2020). "Turkey repeating Ottoman Empire's crimes against Arabs". Arab News. Archived from the original on 5 January 2021.
44. Al-Sulami, Mohammed (24 March 2021). "Book by Saudi author unravels Ottoman atrocities in Madinah". Arab News. Archived from the original on 23 April 2021.