Operation Gideon

This article is about the 1948 operation. For other uses, see Operation Gideon (disambiguation).

Operation Gideon^[1] was a Haganah offensive launched in the closing days of the British Mandate in Palestine, as part of the 1947–48 Civil War in Mandatory Palestine. Its objectives were to capture Beisan (Beit She'an), clear the surrounding villages and Bedouin camps and block one of the possible entry routes for Transjordanian forces. It was part of Plan Dalet. The operation was carried out by the Golani brigade between 10–15 May 1948. Avraham Yoffe commanded the battalion that captured Beisan.^[2] The 1947 UN Partition Plan allocated Beisan and most of its district to the proposed Jewish state.^[3][4] It is possible that Irgun units were involved in parts of the operation.^[5] Following the operation, the town formally surrendered with most of its residents fleeing. ^[6] Most Arab Christians relocated to Nazareth. A ma'abarah (refugee camp) inhabited mainly by North African immigrants was also erected in Beit She'an, and it later became a development town.

Background

Beisan was a predominantly Muslim town in the centre of a fertile valley running into the River Jordan. The area has significant Ancient Egyptian, Greek, Samaritan, Jewish and Roman archeological remains.^{[7][8][9][10]} It was on the main road from 'Afula and Tiberias which was one of the ancient routes between Damascus and Egypt. During the British mandate a number of Jewish villages were established in the valley. By the end of the Second World War, Jews owned a third of the lands in the Beisan valley.^[11] The Beisan lands were awarded to the Jews under the 1947 UN Partition plan.^[11]

Operation

On the night of 10/11 May troops from the Golani brigade captured two villages close to Baysan and immediately commenced blowing up houses. The following night they launched a mortar bombardment on Baysan. Commander Yoffe telephoned local leaders in the town and threatened to level the town. The next day the town formally surrendered with most of its residents fleeing. Between 700 and 1,500 of those who remained in the town were expelled across the River Jordan on 14/15 May. There were left around 250 people, mainly Christians and they were trucked to Nazareth on 28 May.^[12]

Aftermath

Yosef Weitz of the JNF claimed he had David Ben-Gurion's approval for a program of systematic destruction of villages. But it appears that Ben Gurion was concerned by the destruction of Baysan. On 16 June he cabled Golani headquarters: "Ask Avraham Yoffe is it true that he burned the town of Beit Shean in whole or in part, and on whose instructions did he do this?"^[13]
This appears to have been as a result of Agriculture Minister, Aharon Zisling, raising the issue at the Provisional Government's Cabinet meeting on the same day: "destruction during battle ... is one thing. But a month later in cold blood, out of political calculation is another thing altogether. This course will not reduce the number of Arabs who will return to the Land of Israel. It will increase the number of our enemies."^[14]
On 20 June Minority Affairs Minister, Bechor Shitrit^[15] also raised the issue of destruction of villages.

Most Arab Christians relocated to Nazareth. During the 1950s a ma'abarah (refugee camp) inhabited mainly by North African immigrants was erected in Beit She'an, and it later became a development town.

Arab communities captured during Operation Gideon

Name	Date	Defending forces	Brigade	Population
Al-Ashrafiyya	10 May 1948	villagers fled	Golani brigade	230
Farwana	10 May 1948	villagers fled 'to Transjordan'	Golani brigade[16]	330
Baysan	12 May 1948	Arab Liberation Army 'contingents'[17]	Golani brigade	5,180 inc. 430 Christians
Al-Sakhina	12 May 1948	n/a	Golani brigade	820 inc. 290 Jews
Al-Hamidiyya	12 May 1948	n/a	Golani brigade	320 inc. 100 Jews
Sirin	12 May 1948	n/a	Golani	810
Al-Ghazzawiyya	20 May 1948	n/a	Golani brigade 4th battalion	1,640 inc. 620 Jews
Al-Fatur	20 May 1948	n/a	n/a	110
Arab al-Safa	20 May 1948	n/a	Golani brigade	650
Kawkab al-Hawa	21 May 1948	n/a	Golani brigade 3rd battalion	300
Al-Samiriyya	27 May 1948	n/a	Golani brigade 4th battalion	250
Danna	28 May 1948	n/a	Golani brigade	190

Other Arab communities in Baysan district, 1948

Name	Date	Defending forces	Brigade	Population
'Arab al-'Arida	n/a	n/a	n/a	330 inc 180 Jews
'Arab al-Bawati	n/a	n/a	n/a	520
Al-Bira	n/a	n/a	n/a	260
Al-Hamra ('Arab al-Hamra)	n/a	n/a	n/a	730
Jabbul	7 June 1948	n/a	Barak	420 inc. 170 Jews (Beyt Yosef)
Kafra	n/a	n/a	n/a	430
Al-Khunayzir	n/a	n/a	n/a	260
Masil al-Jil	n/a	n/a	n/a	100
Al-Murassas	n/a	n/a	n/a	460
Tall al-Shawk	n/a	n/a	n/a	120
Umm 'Ajra	n/a	n/a	n/a	260
Zab'a	n/a	n/a	n/a	170

See also

• Depopulated Palestinian locations in Israel

References

1. 'Gideon' is the name used for this operation by 'All that remains'. Morris does not name the operation but describes it in detail. pages 106-107.
2. Morris page 334.
3. prepared in December 1945 and January 1946 for the information of the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry. (1991). A Survey of Palestine: Prepared in December, 1945 and January, 1946 for the Information of the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry. Vol. 1. Institute for Palestine Studies. pp. 12–13. ISBN 0-88728-211-3.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
4. Land Ownership of Palestine—Map prepared by the government of the British Mandate of Palestine on the instructions of the UN Ad Hoc Committee on the Palestine Question (Map). United Nations. Archived from the original on 2008-10-29. Retrieved 2008-10-20.
5. 'All that remains', page 44. From a 14 May Irgun announcement that they had taken five villages in the North.
6. Morris, page 106/107.
7. Steimatzky's Palestine Guide, Jerusalem, 1942. pages 195-197. "If the garden of Eden is in Palestine then its gate is at Beit Shean." Quoting 'the sages of Israel'.
8. The New encyclopedia of archaeological excavations in the Holy Land: Volume 1, p.224
9. Samaritan Synagogue Uncovered near Beit She'an. CBN News, September 21, 2010
10. 'Israel and the Occupied Territories' The Rough Guide, 1989. ISBN 0-7471-0105-1. Page 284.
11. State lands and rural development in mandatory Palestine, 1920-1948 By Warwick P. N. Tyler. p. 78
12. Morris, page 106/107. His sources are: 'Ilan Va'shelah Derekh Hakravot Shel Hativat Golani' (Tree and Sword, the route of battle of the Golani Brigade) Tel Aviv 1951. 'Hashomer Hatzair Archives, Aharon Cohen Papers.'
13. Morris, page 161 and page 334.
14. Morris, Page 162
15. Morris's spelling, page 162.
16. Morris Page 106. 'Haganah sappers began to blow up the village houses.'
17. Morris Page 106

Bibliography

• Walid Khalidi, All That Remains, ISBN 0-88728-224-5. Uses 1945 census for population figures.
• Benny Morris, The Birth of the Palestinian refugee problem, 1947–1949,ISBN 0-521-33028-9.