Norfolk Island convict mutinies

Norfolk Island convict mutinies were a series of armed uprisings by convicts on the penal colony of Norfolk Island, Australia. All were unsuccessful.

1826 rebellion

1826 convict rebellion
Date 25 September 1826 Location Norfolk Island Result Unsuccessful escape attempt
Belligerents
Convict insurgents	British Army
Commanders and leaders
"Black" John Goff	Vance Young Donaldson
Strength
over 50
Casualties and losses
3 convicts hanged	1 soldier killed

The first convict rebellion took place in September 1826.

It was led by "Black" John Goff. He arranged for two convict decoys to make an escape attempt; they were followed by several soldiers. While this happened, fifty convicts seized and bound their overseers, robbed the stores for provisions and put three boats to sea. One soldier was killed, bayoneted to death, while others were wounded.

The convicts sailed to Phillip Island where they were eventually re-captured, although some eluded the authorities for up to six months.^[1][2]

The ringleaders – Goff, William Moore and Edward Watson – were tried and hanged in Sydney in 1827. The Chief Justice said when passing sentence on John Goff:

You... have detailed to the Court a long complaint of the hardships you have undergone, of your love of liberty, and of the degree of violence which you thought yourself justified in using to obtain it. By your own statement your whole life has been one career of crime... It is within the recollection of this Court, how near you were, at no distant period, to have been consigned to the grave, and happy would it have been for you had your career then terminated without the additional crime of the blood of a fellow creature being added to the list... With respect to the general harsh treatment of which you complain on Norfolk Island, what are men sent there for? It is within the knowledge of the Court that they are never sent except for crimes of the deepest dye; and is it then to be supposed that they are sent there to be indulged, to be fed with the fruits of the earth and that they are not to work in chains? No, the object in sending men there is not only as a punishment for their past crimes, but to serve as a terror to others; and so far from it being a reproach, as you have stated it, it is a wise project of the Government in instituting that settlement for the punishment of the twice and thrice convicted felon, as a place of terror to evil doers, and in order to repress the mass of crime with which the Colony unhappily abounds.^[3]

Capture of Wellington

Capture of Wellington
Date 21 December 1826 Location Norfolk Island Result Mutiny successful though later captured
Belligerents
Convict insurgents
Commanders and leaders
John Walton
Strength
66 convicts
Casualties and losses
2 killed[4] 5 executed

On 21 December 1826, the ship Wellington was seized by the 66 convicts it was taking to Norfolk Island.^[5] Twenty of the ship's crew and soldiers were kept prisoners. Soldiers had kept firing through the bulk head into the hold until it became apparent that crew members were in danger of being injured.

The convict Walton appointed himself captain of the vessel, Douglas as first mate and "Flash Jack" Edwards as second mate and Clay as steward. A gale sprang up and the sailors were asked to help work on the ship. They refused at first but changed their mind with the consent of the captain.^[6][7]

Re-capture

Wellington then sailed to the Bay of Islands in New Zealand, where they were recaptured by a whaler, The Sisters under the command of Captain Duke.^[8]

Due to their merciful treatment of the captured ship's guards and crew, only five of the prisoners were executed, although 23 were condemned to hang.^{[9][10][11][12]}

1827 uprising

1827 Uprising
Date October 1827 Location Norfolk Island Result Unsuccessful uprising
Belligerents
Convict insurgents	British Army
Commanders and leaders
Patrick Clynch	Thomas Wright

There was an attempted uprising in 1827 with an attempt made on the life of new commandant Thomas Wright by Patrick Clynch.

Clynch was later captured and then shot.^[13][14]

Wright was later arrested for ordering Clynch's murder and put on trial.^[15][16][17] He was acquitted.

1830 escape

1830 Escape
Date 19 June 1830 Location Norfolk Island Result Unsuccessful escape
Belligerents
Convict insurgents	British Army
Commanders and leaders
	Lt Borough
Strength
11 convicts
Casualties and losses
11 convicts drowned (presumed)

In 1830 there was a successful escape of eleven convicts from the island on a newly constructed whaleboat. They went to Phillip Island, where they robbed a visiting botanist, Mr. Cunningham of provisions.^[18]

Lt Borough took charge of a boat and took off after the felons but was forced to turn back as darkness began to fall and the rough seas.

The convicts that took to sea and were never heard of again – it is presumed they all drowned.^[14]

1834 rebellion

1834 Convict Rebellion
Date 15 January 1834 Location Norfolk Island Result Rebellion crushed
Belligerents
Convict insurgents	British Army
Commanders and leaders
	Captain Foster Fyans
Strength
over 100
Casualties and losses
6 dead 13 convicts executed	1 soldier dead 1 guard dead

In January 1834 a serious insurrection occurred on Norfolk Island, involving over a hundred convicts who made a series of concerted attacks against their guards, with the ultimate aim of taking control of the island and effecting an escape by the next Government vessel to arrive with supplies.^[19][20][21]

On the morning 15 January 1834 about 30 men, following a pre-arranged plan by pretending sickness, fell out of various of the Camp and Longridge gangs and went to the hospital. They entered the hospital and secured those there by locking them in a room, and then proceeded to break off their irons. From the hospital the mutineers waited for the gaol-gang to be turned out for work under an armed guard. As this occurred the insurrectionists rushed from the hospital behind the gaol and attacked the rear rank of the guard. After a short struggle during which two or three muskets were wrested from the soldiers, six of the mutineers were killed or wounded and the guard “succeeded in dispersing and finally in securing them”.^[22][23][24]

The trial of those charged as "principals and accessories" of the insurrection commenced on 12 July 1834 before Justice William Burton.^[22][23] At the conclusion of the trial on July 22, thirteen men were convicted of mutiny and sentenced to death.^[24]

On 10 September 1834 two clerics and the New South Wales hangman left Sydney for Norfolk Island aboard the brig Governor Phillip, to carry out the executions of the thirteen convicted mutineers. Seven of the men were hanged on Monday, September 22, and the remaining six the following day.^[25][26]

• Robert Douglas - 22 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Henry Drummond - 22 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• James Bell - 22 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Joseph Butler - 22 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Robert Glennie - 22 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Walter Burke - 22 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Joseph Snell - 22 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• William McCulloch - 23 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Michael Andrews - 23 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• William Groves - 23 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Thomas Freshwater - 23 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Henry Knowles - 23 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny
• Robert Ryan - 23 September 1834 - Hanged for mutiny

1842 rebellion

On the morning of 21 June 1842, a convict work party aboard the Governor Phillip at Cascade were let out to start unloading the launch of the brig, as they had to make way for a ship that had arrived from Sydney. After seeing that only a serjeant and two soldiers were on deck, the convicts overpowered them and held the Governor Phillip for roughly half an hour before the soldiers trapped below deck were able to retake the brig. Five mutineers and one soldier were killed in the affray, and another two soldiers were severely wounded. Three of the soldiers that were initially confined below deck were also scalded badly when the convicts poured boiling hot water through gaps in a hatch that they had bolted shut.^[27]

At trial, one of the convicts was released for saving a soldier who had been thrown over aboard. Five other convicts were put to death, one of whom received a reprieve and was instead transported for life. The other four convicts were hanged in November 1840. The Australian reported, "We heard several of those employed about the gaol remark that they had never witnessed men come to the scaffold so firm, yet in so resigned and devotional a state of mine."^[28]

1846 rebellion

1846 Convict Rebellion
Date 1 July 1846 Location Norfolk Island Result Rebellion crushed
Belligerents
Convict insurgents	British Army
Commanders and leaders
William "Jackey Jackey" Westwood	Joseph Childs
Strength
1,600[29]
Casualties and losses
12 convicts executed[30]	4 officials killed

Main article: Cooking pot uprising

There was a final rebellion of convicts in 1846. It was led by William "Jackey Jackey" Westwood, a bushranger who had recently been sent to Norfolk Island. He was known as the "Gentleman Bushranger".^[31]

Joseph Childs took over the running of Norfolk Island in 1844, ushering in a far harsher regime than his predecessor. He greatly reduced prisoners' privileges and in May 1846 ordered prisoners to hand in their tins and knives and other utensils. In response, Westwood led an uprising of convicts which resulted in an overseer and three constables being killed. However, the mutiny was suppressed by the colony's military.^[32][33]

Westwood was sentenced to death with 11 others and was executed on 13 October 1846.^{[29][34][35][36]}

The governance of Joseph Childs was blamed for causing the mutiny. He was replaced by John Price.^[30]

See also

• Folklore of Norfolk Island

References

1. Robert Macklin, Dark Paradise: Norfolk Island – isolation, savagery, mystery and murder Hachette UK, 30 Jul 2013 accessed 3 July 2014
2. "INSURRECTION AT NORFOLK ISLAND". The Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser. National Library of Australia. 6 April 1827. p. 2. Retrieved 4 July 2014.
3. "Supreme Court". The Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser. National Library of Australia. 24 September 1827. p. 2. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
4. "POSTSCRIPT EXTRAORDINARY". The Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser. National Library of Australia. 10 February 1827. p. 2. Retrieved 4 July 2014.
5. "PIRATICAL SEIZURE OF THE BRIG WELLINGTON". The Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser. NSW: National Library of Australia. 16 February 1827. p. 2. Retrieved 30 June 2014.
6. "Further Particulars of the Piratical Seizure and re-capture of the Brig Wellington". The Monitor. Sydney: National Library of Australia. 17 February 1827. p. 5. Retrieved 4 July 2014.
7. "Supreme Criminal Court". The Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser. NSW: National Library of Australia. 21 February 1827. p. 2. Retrieved 4 July 2014.
8. "PIRACY BY PRISONERS AND RE-CAPTURE". The Australian. Sydney: National Library of Australia. 10 February 1827. p. 3. Retrieved 4 July 2014.
9. R. v. Walton et al. 1827 NSWSupC 7 accessed 30 June 2014
10. R. v. Flanagan et al. 1827 NSWKR 1; 1827 NSWSupC 8 accessed 30 June 2014
11. Liberty or Life!: The Convict Pirates of the Wellington by Erin Ihde, Dark Matter 101 20 Dec 2009 accessed 30 June 2014
12. "CRIMINAL COURT.—(Monday.)". The Australian. Sydney: National Library of Australia. 1 March 1827. p. 3. Retrieved 4 July 2014.
13. "DOMESTIC INTELLIGENCE". The Sydney Monitor. National Library of Australia. 8 June 1829. p. 2. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
14. "Early Australian History". Bathurst Free Press and Mining Journal. NSW: National Library of Australia. 20 April 1889. p. 4. Retrieved 4 July 2014.
15. "IMPORTANT TRIAL". The Sydney Monitor. National Library of Australia. 17 October 1829. p. 1 Edition: AFTERNOON. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
16. "THE SYDNEY MONITOR". The Sydney Monitor. National Library of Australia. 17 October 1829. p. 2 Edition: AFTERNOON. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
17. "THE RIGHT HONOURABLE SIR GEORGE MURRAY, K. C. B. G. C. B. HIS MAJESTY'S PRINCIPAL SECRETARY OF STATE FOR THE COLONIES, &C. &C. &C". The Sydney Monitor. NSW: National Library of Australia. 24 April 1830. p. 4 Edition: AFTERNOON. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
18. "NORFOLK ISLAND". The Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser. NSW: National Library of Australia. 30 October 1830. p. 2. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
19. William Westbrooke Burton (1840), The State of Religion and Education in New South Wales, London: J. Cross, pages 255-261.
20. R. v. Douglas and others [1834] NSWSupC 81 at Decisions of the Superior Courts of New South Wales, 1788-1899 at Macquarie Uni Faculty of Law accessed 30 June 2014
21. Mutiny and Serious Loss of Life at Norfolk Island, Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser, 4 March 1834, page 2.
22. Norfolk Island, Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser, 13 September 1834, page 1.
23. Norfolk Island, Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser, 20 September 1834, page 1.
24. Norfolk Island, Sydney Gazette and New South Wales Advertiser, 27 September 1834, page 1.
25. Ray & Richard Beckett (1980), Hangman: The Life and Times of Alexander Green, Public Executioner to the Colony of New South Wales, West Melbourne: Nelson, ISBN 0170052613, pages 108-110.
26. Ship News, Sydney Herald, 16 October 1834, page 3.
27. Brackin, Helen (18 June 2019). "Media Release: interesting items from the collection" (PDF). Norfolk Island Regional Council. Retrieved 29 July 2020.
28. Milne, Sue; Plater, David. "'The quality of mercy is not strained': the Norfolk Island mutineers and the exercise of the death penalty in colonial Australia 1824–1860" (PDF). (2012) Australia & New Zealand Law & History E-Journal, Refereed Paper No 1.
29. "The Norfolk Island mutiny was led by The Gentleman Bushranger". The Argus. Melbourne: National Library of Australia. 19 January 1957. p. 14. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
30. Barry, John V. "Price, John Giles (1808–1857", Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, published in hardcopy 1967, accessed online 6 October 2020.
31. ""JACKEY-JACKEY."". Bathurst Free Press and Mining Journal. NSW: National Library of Australia. 20 October 1891. p. 4. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
32. "NORFOLK ISLAND". The South Australian. Adelaide: National Library of Australia. 4 December 1846. p. 7. Retrieved 30 June 2014.
33. "NORFOLK ISLAND". The Moreton Bay Courier. Brisbane: National Library of Australia. 14 November 1846. p. 4. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
34. Martha Rutledge, 'Westwood, William (1820–1846)', Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University published in hardcopy 2005, accessed online 3 July 2014.
35. "NORFOLK ISLAND". The Courier. Hobart, Tas.: National Library of Australia. 28 October 1846. p. 3. Retrieved 3 July 2014.
36. "NORFOLK ISLAND". The Australian. Sydney: National Library of Australia. 14 November 1846. p. 3. Retrieved 3 July 2014.