List of pre-fame band departures

While many notable bands go through several lineup changes throughout their careers, this list of artists who left right before their bands became famous only lists members who quit or were fired from a band shortly before the band achieved mainstream commercial success.

Artists who were only meant to be temporary stand-ins in their bands should not be included in this list. The bands the listed artists left must be notable, can be from any genre of music, and include vocal groups whose members do not play instruments. Because these artists left before their former bands' mainstream breakthrough, they should not be considered part of their former bands' "classic" lineups.

Notable examples

Ex-Beatles drummer Pete Best in 2006. Best was fired from the Beatles a year before "Beatlemania" started.

Of these "nearly-men",^[1] drummer Pete Best, who was fired from the Beatles in 1962,^[2] just a year before "Beatlemania" started, has been cited as the best-known archetype.^[3][4][5][6] Best has since become "famous for not being famous".^[7]

Jason Everman left two bands that went on to become famous: he was fired from Nirvana in 1989 and Soundgarden in 1990. According to The New York Times, Everman "wasn't just Pete Best ... He was Pete Best twice."^[8]

Some of these artists eventually went on to find mainstream success in another band or as a soloist. For example, Metallica's original lead guitarist, Dave Mustaine, formed his own thrash metal band Megadeth in 1983 after he was fired from his former band. While Metallica went on to achieve massive commercial success, Mustaine's Megadeth also enjoyed commercial success,^[9][10] selling 50 million records worldwide.^[11]

Alphabetic list

Dave Mustaine in 2010. Mustaine formed the successful Megadeth after being fired from Metallica.

Mark Wahlberg in 2012. Wahlberg became a famous actor, singer and model after he quit New Kids on the Block.

Heidi Range in 2006. Range quit Atomic Kitten shortly before the release of their debut single and later joined another girl group, the Sugababes.

Artists are listed alphabetically by their surname, followed by the band they left, their former role in the band, the year they left, and the year their former band achieved mainstream success. Additional comments on the way the artist left (fired or quit) and their replacement, if any, may be added at the end. All entries are referenced with reliable sources.

This is a dynamic list and may never be able to satisfy particular standards for completeness. You can help by adding missing items with reliable sources.

Artist	Band the artist left	Role	Year the artist left	Year of band's commercial breakthrough	Notes	Ref
George Baldi	Boyz II Men	Vocalist	1988	1991	Quit
Syd Barrett	Pink Floyd	Guitarist, vocalist	1968	1973	Fired and replaced by David Gilmour	[12]
Tina Barrett	Mis-Teeq (then known as Face2Face)	Vocalist	1998	2001	Left to join S Club 7 who also gained success, scoring 11 top 10 singles.	[13][14]
Pete Best	The Beatles	Drummer	1962	1963	Fired and replaced by Ringo Starr	[2]: 2  [5]
Josh Brainard	Slipknot	Guitarist	1998	1999	Replaced by Jim Root. Recorded for some tracks of Slipknot but left the band before the album's release.	[15]
Elbridge Bryant	The Temptations	Vocalist	1963	1964	Fired and replaced by David Ruffin	[16]: 12
Tanya Candler	Kittie	Bassist	1999	2000	Played on debut album Spit and appeared on the cover of its original release, but quit Kittie two months before its release. She was replaced by Talena Atfield, who appears on the cover of all reissues of the album since 2000.
Maddy Chan	Steps	Vocalist	1997	1997	Quit and replaced by Claire Richards and Faye Tozer	[17][18]
Chad Channing	Nirvana	Drummer	1990	1991	Quit and replaced by Dave Grohl	[9][3]
Tony Chapman	The Rolling Stones	Drummer	1962	1963	Quit and replaced by Charlie Watts	[2]: 4  [5]
Simon Colley	Duran Duran	Bassist	1979	1981	Quit and replaced by John Taylor, who was already a member of the band, switching from guitar to bass guitar.
Anders Colsefni	Slipknot	Vocalist, percussionist	1997	1999	Replaced as vocalist by Corey Taylor and switched to percussion, then left the band and was replaced by Greg Welts.	[19]
Jason Cropper	Weezer	Guitarist	1993	1994	Fired and replaced by Brian Bell	[20]
Alan Curtis	Duran Duran	Guitarist	1980	1981	Quit and replaced by Andy Taylor
John Curulewski	Styx	Guitarist	1975	1975	Left and replaced by Tommy Shaw
Támar Davis	Destiny's Child (then known as Girl's Tyme)	Vocalist	1993	1997	Fired and replaced by LeToya Luckett	[21][22][23]
Bob Debank	Coast to Coast	Guitarist	1979	1980	Quit
Stephen Duffy	Duran Duran	Vocalist/bassist/ drummer	1979	1981	Quit and replaced by Andy Wickett	[3][5]
Jason Everman	Nirvana	Guitarist	1989	1991	Fired	[8]
	Soundgarden	Bassist	1990	1992	Fired and replaced by Ben Shepherd
Frank Farrell	Supertramp	Bassist	1970	1972	Left and replaced by Dougie Thompson
Jason Galasso	NSYNC	Vocalist	1995	1997	Quit and replaced by Lance Bass	[24]
Pete Garner	The Stone Roses	Bassist	1987	1989	Quit and replaced by Mani	[5]
Michael Garrett	Westlife	Vocalist	1998	1999	Fired and replaced by Nicky Byrne and Brian McFadden	[25]
Terry Glaze	Pantera	Vocalist	1986	1990	Quit and replaced by Phil Anselmo
Peter Griesar	Dave Matthews Band	Keyboardist	1993	1994	Quit	[26]
Mike Grose	Queen	Bassist	1970	1974	Quit, replaced by Barry Mitchell, then Doug Bogie, then John Deacon	[27]
Tracii Guns	Guns N' Roses	Guitarist	1985	1987	Quit and replaced by Slash	[5] [16]: 5
Dale Hibbert	The Smiths	Bassist	1982	1983	Fired and replaced by Andy Rourke	[28][29]
Kim Hill	Black Eyed Peas	Vocalist	2000	2003	Quit and later replaced by Fergie
Doug Hopkins	Gin Blossoms	Guitarist	1992	1993	Fired and replaced by Scott Johnson	[2]: 2  [30]
Crystal Jones	TLC	Vocalist	1991	1992	Fired and replaced by Rozonda Thomas	[31]
Jeff Jones	Rush	Vocalist, bassist	1968	1974	Left and replaced by Geddy Lee
Graham Keighron	Westlife	Vocalist	1998	1999	Fired and replaced by Nicky Byrne and Brian McFadden	[25]
John Kiffmeyer	Green Day	Drummer	1990	1994	Replaced while at college by Tré Cool
Stella Kim	Girls' Generation	Vocalist	2007	2007	Quit	[32]
Abigail Kis	Spice Girls (then known as Touch)	Vocalist	1994	1996	Quit and replaced by Emma Bunton	[33]
Bob Klose	Pink Floyd	Guitarist	1965	1967	Quit	[34]
Derrick Lacey	Westlife	Vocalist	1998	1999	Fired and replaced by Nicky Byrne and Brian McFadden	[25]
James Lilja	The Offspring	Drummer	1987	1994	Quit and replaced by Ron Welty
Jonathan Lippmann	98 Degrees	Vocalist	1996	1998	Quit and replaced by Drew Lachey	[35][36]
Bob Livingson	Santana	Drummer	1968	1969	Quit and replaced by Michael Shrieve	[37]
Robin Lynn Macy	Dixie Chicks	Guitarist	1992	1995	Quit	[38]
Barbara Martin	The Supremes	Vocalist	1962	1964	Quit	[39]: 2
Ron McGovney	Metallica	Bassist	1982	1986	Quit and replaced by Cliff Burton	[40]
Zena McNally	Mis-Teeq	Vocalist	2001	2001	Quit
Alan Mills	Coast to Coast	Vocalist	1980	1980	Quit and replaced by Sandy Fontaine
Lianne Morgan	Spice Girls (then known as Touch)	Vocalist	1994	1996	Quit and replaced by Melanie C	[41]
Dave Mustaine	Metallica	Guitarist	1983	1986	Fired and replaced by Kirk Hammett	[5] [16]: 4
Marc Nelson	Boyz II Men	Vocalist	1989	1991	Quit	[16]: 13
Derek O'Brien	Steps	Vocalist	1997	1997	Quit and replaced by Lee Latchford-Evans	[17][18]
Henry Padovani	The Police	Guitarist	1977	1979	Fired and replaced by Andy Summers	[42][43]
So-yeon Park	Girls' Generation	Vocalist	2007	2007	Quit	[44]
Matt Pelissier	My Chemical Romance	Drummer	2004	2004	Fired and replaced by Bob Bryar
Anthony Phillips	Genesis	Guitarist	1970	1972	Quit and replaced by Steve Hackett	[2]: 6
Justin Quinn	Another Level	Vocalist	1997	1998	Left and became a solo UK garage singer known as JJ, appearing on two top 10 hits by DJ Luck & MC Neat in 2000.	[45]
Niall Quinn	The Cranberries	Vocalist	1990	1993	Quit and replaced by Dolores O'Riordan	[43]
Heidi Range	Atomic Kitten	Vocalist	1999	1999	Quit and replaced by Natasha Hamilton, Range would later find success with Sugababes.	[46]
Scott Raynor	Blink-182	Drummer	1998	1999	Fired and replaced by Travis Barker	[47][12]
Richie Rock	Boyzone	Vocalist	1994	1994	Fired and replaced by Mikey Graham	[48][49]
John Rutsey	Rush	Drummer	1974	1974	Left and replaced by Neil Peart	[50]
Chris Salih	Twenty One Pilots	Drummer	2011	2015	Quit and replaced by Josh Dun	[51]
Doug Sandom	The Who	Drummer	1964	1965	Fired and replaced by Keith Moon	[52]
Kate Schellenbach	Beastie Boys	Drummer	1984	1986		[53]
Jon Shoats	Boyz II Men	Vocalist	1988	1991	Quit
Eric Stefani	No Doubt	Keyboardist	1994	1995	Quit	[2]: 7  [42]
Michelle Stephenson	Spice Girls	Vocalist	1994	1996	Quit and replaced by Abigail Kis, prior to Emma Bunton	[33][54][55]
Mitch Stevens	Steps	Vocalist	1997	1997	Quit and replaced by Claire Richards and Faye Tozer	[17][18]
Ian Stewart	The Rolling Stones	Keyboardist	1963	1963	Fired, but retained as studio and touring member	[43]
Scott Sundquist	Soundgarden	Drummer	1985	1992	Quit to spend time with his family and replaced by Matt Cameron
Stuart Sutcliffe	The Beatles	Bassist, vocalist	1961	1963	Quit to pursue a career as a painter
Nikki Taylor	Destiny's Child (then known as Girl's Tyme)	Vocalist	1993	1997	Fired and replaced by LeToya Luckett	[21][22][23]
Nina Taylor	Destiny's Child (then known as Girl's Tyme)	Vocalist	1993	1997	Fired and replaced by LeToya Luckett	[21][22][23]
Jeff Thomas	Duran Duran	Vocalist	1980	1981	Quit and replaced by Simon Le Bon
Nick Thomas	Twenty One Pilots	Bassist	2011	2015	Quit	[56]
Mark Wahlberg	New Kids on the Block	Vocalist	1985	1988	Quit and replaced by Joey McIntyre	[57]
Marguerite Walker	Boyz II Men	Vocalist	1988	1991	Quit
Mark Walton	Boyzone	Vocalist	1994	1994	Quit	[48][49]
Greg "Cuddles" Welts	Slipknot	Percussionist	1998	1999	Replaced by Chris Fehn
Andy Wickett	Duran Duran	Vocalist	1980	1981	Quit and replaced by Jeff Thomas, prior to Simon Le Bon	[58]
Hye-rim Woo	Miss A	Vocalist	2010	2010	Left and joined Wonder Girls instead	[59][60]
Hiro Yamamoto	Soundgarden	Bassist	1989	1992	Quit and replaced by Jason Everman	[61]
Annette Zilinskas	The Bangles	Bassist	1983	1986	Quit and replaced by Michael Steele; Zilinskas later rejoined the band in 2018.

References

1. Lister, David (8 April 2011). "David Lister: The lucrative business of being a nearly-man of rock music". The Independent. Retrieved 20 April 2017.
2. Pous, Terri (22 August 2012). "Gone Too Soon? Artists Who Left Bands Before their Prime". TIME.

   • p. 1.
   • p. 2.
   • p. 3.
   • p. 4.
   • p. 5.
   • p. 6.
   • p. 7.
   • p. 8.
3. "The nearly men of pop music: I'm (not) with the band". The Independent. 9 August 2005. Retrieved 20 April 2017.
4. Runtagh, Jordan (9 August 2013). "Pete Best Syndrome: 10 Dudes Who Left Big Bands To Wallow In Obscurity". VH1. Retrieved 21 April 2017.
5. Horton, Matthew (29 July 2015). "Bad Timing – 31 Musicians Who Quit Bands Right Before They Became Famous". NME. Retrieved 18 April 2017.
6. Perry, Andrew (28 September 2006). "Beatles behaving badly: what John and I got up to, by the drummer who was booted out". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 20 April 2017.
7. Dover, Robert M. Cook (10 May 2008). "Ex-Beatles drummer Pete Best rocks on". fosters.com. Retrieved 18 April 2017.
8. Tarver, Clay (2 July 2013). "The Rock 'n' Roll Casualty Who Became a War Hero". The New York Times. Retrieved 20 April 2017.
9. Alexandra, Rae (17 January 2013). "Almost Famous: Five Musicians Who Left Before Their Bands Blew Up". SF Weekly. Archived from the original on 20 April 2017. Retrieved 20 April 2017.
10. Willman, Chris (10 July 2013). "Almost Famous: Musicians Who Just Missed Their Shot". Yahoo! Music. Retrieved 21 April 2017.
11. McPhate, Christian (July 11, 2013). "Megadeth Bassist Dave Ellefson on the Metal Aging Process". Dallas Observer. Archived from the original on November 12, 2014. Retrieved November 23, 2013.
12. Rutan, Ayron (25 July 2022). "Rockers Who Were Replaced Before Their Band Got Famous". Loudwire. Retrieved 7 June 2023.
13. Kelly, Emma (December 12, 2020). "S Club 7's Tina on that red carpet dress: 'I thought, Where's the rest of it?'".
14. Byrnes, Lana (March 4, 2021). "Tina Barett was in Mis-Teeq before S Club 7 and nobody knew". OK! Magazine.
15. Crampton, Mark (2001). Barcode Killers: The Slipknot Story in Words and Pictures. UK: Chrome Dreams. p. 35. ISBN 1-84240-126-2.
16. Porter, Joseph (21 August 2015). "People Who Left a Band Right Before Fame Hit". guff.com. Retrieved 20 April 2017.^{[permanent dead link]}
17. "The Original Steps". generationsteps.co.uk. Archived from the original on 25 May 2014.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
18. "Steps Reunion on Sky Living HD - Here the band reveal how they got together at the first audition - Sky Living HD". Skyliving.sky.com.
19. Arnopp, Jason (2001). Slipknot: Inside the Sickness, Behind the Masks. UK: Ebury. pp. 71–74. ISBN 0-09-187933-7.
20. Valania, Johnathan (7 May 2016). "PHAWKER.COM – Curated News, Gossip, Concert Reviews, Fearless Political Commentary, Interviews….Plus, the Usual Sex, Drugs and Rock n' Roll » Blog Archive » EXCERPT: The Complete Oral History Of Weezer". Magnet Magazine. Archived from the original on 7 May 2016. Retrieved 17 February 2019.
21. Beyonce: All New. E! Online.
22. "Beyoncé Knowles: Biography". People. Archived from the original on April 26, 2007. Retrieved April 13, 2008.
23. Kaufman, Gil (June 13, 2005). "Destiny's Child's Long Road To Fame (The Song Isn't Called 'Survivor' For Nothing)". MTV News. Archived from the original on June 24, 2011. Retrieved April 13, 2008.
24. "A History Of *NSYNC's Breakup, According To Bandmates Not Named Justin Timberlake". HuffPost. 30 April 2018. Retrieved 14 February 2019.
25. "Where Are They Now? : Westlife". OutLoud!Culture. June 16, 2018.
26. "Interview with Peter Griesar". Nancies. Retrieved 30 May 2019.
27. Blake, Mark (2010). Is This The Real Life? The Untold Story of Queen. Arum Press. p. 94. ISBN 978-1-84513-713-7.
28. Rogan, Johnny (22 December 2015). "Boy, Interrupted: Memoir Of A Former Smith by Dale Hibbert: a top pop memoir". The Irish Times. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
29. "How we made: Andy Rourke and Mike Joyce on the Smiths' first gig". The Guardian. 23 January 2012. Retrieved 28 February 2022.
30. "6 Musicians Who Left Bands Right Before They Got Famous". CollegeHumor. 5 August 2009.
31. "39 Things You Didn't Know About TLC". Capital XTRA. Retrieved 18 April 2017.
32. Luo, Benny (September 29, 2016). "Former SNSD Trainee Reveals the Distorted Reality of Beauty in K-Pop". NextShark. Retrieved December 14, 2021.
33. Tonks, Owen (June 7, 2021). "Emma Bunton 'won place in Spice Girls thanks to platform shoes' as she was too short". Metro UK. Retrieved December 18, 2021.
34. "Pink Floyd: Official Facebook site". Facebook. Retrieved 24 January 2018.
35. Huff, Richard (May 28, 2009). "Ex-98 Degrees singer Drew Lachey set to host HGTV $250,000 Challenge". Daily News. Retrieved January 21, 2011.
36. "Pop group delivers lyrical food for thought". Toledo Blade. July 14, 2001.
37. "Live at the Fillmore 1968". AllMusic. Retrieved 1 February 2022.
38. "Big Twang". 2005. Archived from the original on 2005-03-09.
39. Keppler, Nick (12 January 2017). "10 Musicians Who Left Famous Bands (Before They Got Famous)". Myspace. {{cite web}}: Missing or empty |url= (help)

    • p. 1.
    • p. 2.
    • p. 3.
    • p. 4.
    • p. 5.
    • p. 6.
40. "Ron McGovney Interview 1997". 15 January 1997. Archived from the original on 2003-11-07.
41. "Spice Girl singer Lianne Morgan's battle with condition that means she cannot speak". Wales Online. June 17, 2012.
42. Bignell, Paul (7 July 2012). "Almost famous: Other members of bands who fell by the wayside". The Independent. Retrieved 20 April 2017.
43. Power, Ed (11 June 2007). "I coulda been a contender". Irish Independent. Retrieved 21 April 2017.
44. (in Korean)함은정, "티아라 소연 "소녀시대 탈퇴 후 가장 힘들었다"(인터뷰). Starnews. April 13, 2010. Retrieved June 21, 2011.
45. "Asino & Laurent Wery feat. Justin Quinn releases Embrace | FrontView Magazine".
46. Earp, Catherine (22 February 2013). "Ten Things About... Atomic Kitten". Digital Spy. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
47. "10 Artists Who Left or Got Fired Just Before Their Band Became Famous". Paste. 17 January 2023. Retrieved 7 June 2023.
48. Kindon, Frances (October 13, 2020). "What happened to Boyzone's forgotten members - heroin, murderous ex and billionaire". Mirror. Retrieved December 16, 2021.
49. BOYZONE HISTORY
50. Elliott, Paul (3 February 2016). "The History Of Rush by Geddy Lee & Alex Lifeson: The Early Years". Louder. Retrieved 20 July 2021.
51. Salih, Chris (May 9, 2011). "Member Change: Chris' Farewell". Facebook. Retrieved August 22, 2016.
52. Marsh, Dave; Bernard, James (1 November 1994). "Expelled: 25 People Who Quit or Were Fired Before Their Groups Became Famous". New Book of Rock Lists. Simon and Schuster. p. 265. ISBN 978-0671787004.
53. Zwickel, Jonathan A. (4 January 2011). Beastie Boys: A Musical Biography. ABC-CLIO. p. 19. ISBN 978-0313365584.
54. Silverman, Stephen M. (24 April 1998). "Meet the 'Raw' Spice Girl". People.com. Retrieved 18 April 2017.
55. Adams, Cameron (11 June 2016). "Twenty years ago this month the Spice Girls were weeks away from stardom — where are they now?". News.com.au. Retrieved 18 April 2017.
56. Thomas, Nick (June 3, 2011). "Nick Thomas' Farewell". Facebook. Retrieved August 22, 2016.
57. "5 Things You Didn't Know About Mark Wahlberg". Glamour. 6 January 2010. Retrieved 6 January 2010.
58. Jackson, Lorne (25 May 2009). "Andy Wickett: the Duran Duran star who never was". Birmingham Post. Retrieved 20 April 2017.
59. "Chinese Wonder Girls show off their dance skills". 6Theory Media, LLC. January 22, 2010. Archived from the original on October 30, 2013. Retrieved November 6, 2013.
60. JYP ENTERTAINMENT OFFICIAL ANNOUNCEMENT Archived July 2, 2010, at the Wayback Machine
61. "Hiro Yamamoto: Founding Member of Soundgarden & Original Bass Player". feelnumb.com. 25 April 2011. Archived from the original on 17 April 2019. Retrieved 12 December 2020.