John Dury

Not to be confused with his grandfather John Durie.

John Dury^[1] (1596 in Edinburgh^[2] – 1680 in Kassel) was a Scottish Calvinist minister and an intellectual of the English Civil War period. He made efforts to re-unite the Calvinist and Lutheran wings of Protestantism, hoping to succeed when he moved to Kassel in 1661, but he did not accomplish this. He was also a preacher, pamphleteer, and writer.

Early life

He was the fourth son of the exiled Scottish presbyterian minister Robert Durie;^[3] John was brought up in the Netherlands, at Leiden, attending the university there.^[4] He was in Cologne, at the Walloon Church, 1624-6,^[5] and subsequently at Elbląg (Elbing). He was a close associate of Samuel Hartlib, a native of Elbląg, whom he met there, and shared his interest in education.^[6] According to Richard Popkin,^[7] another key influence was Joseph Mede, from whom Dury took a method of scriptural interpretation; this interpretation has been challenged by recent research claiming that Dury developed his "Scriptural Analysis" before meeting with the works of Mede.^[8] While at Elbing he translated an anti-trinitarian work of Samuel Przypkowski into English.^[9]

From 1628 Dury petitioned Gustavus Adolphus for help in the cause of Protestant unity.^[10] He spent much time from 1630 to 1661 wandering through Europe, working for ecclesiastical peace between Calvinists and Lutherans.^[11] Through an introduction from Hartlib, he also met Comenius, who spent some years in Elbing as well.

Up to 1633, Dury had Anglican support from George Abbot. In that year, Abbot died and was replaced by William Laud, with whom Dury had a much more difficult relationship;^[12] Christopher Hill^[13] states "Laud had no use for the efforts of Comenius, Dury and Hartlib to reunite Protestants". Dury was ordained in 1634, and went to Sweden, supported by 38 English Puritans.^[14] The networking of Dury and Hartlib in the 1630s brought them close to Oliver Cromwell, through Oliver St John (a relation by marriage, and friend) and the Godmanchester preacher Walter Welles, a neighbour.^[15]

Dury then travelled widely in northern Europe, and was tutor to Mary, Princess of Orange in the Hague.^[16] He had a long though unproductive meeting with René Descartes in 1635;^[17][18] also in the Netherlands he was an associate of Adam Boreel and Petrus Serrarius, and an influential figure.

In Civil War and Commonwealth England

At a key moment in English and European politics, Dury in August 1641 published Concerning the Work of Peace Ecclesiastical, urging Protestants to unite across national boundaries. This work was dedicated to his patron Sir Thomas Rowe, and had been written in 1638. In 1639 Viscount Mandeville was writing to Dury, in the context that the situation in particular of German Protestants was being mooted and linked to the possibility of the English and Scottish churches could organise or broker such a union.^[19]

In 1641, Dury and Comenius came to England; an invitation had been mooted in a sermon by John Gauden in 1641, at the start of the Long Parliament.^[20] The backers of the scheme to bring Comenius then included John Pym and Lord Brooke as well as Mandeville.^[19]

Dury gave a well-known sermon to the Parliament on 26 November 1645, Israels Call to March out of Babylon into Jerusalem.^[21] He was given an official appointment, as tutor to the younger children of Charles I;^[22] from 1646 these had been in the care of Algernon Percy, 10th Earl of Northumberland.

After the war in England had ended, he argued both for religious toleration, and for acceptance of the Parliamentarian regime. He incurred the displeasure of the Westminster Assembly, to which he belonged,^[23] for his part in the 1648 publication (with Hartlib and John Goodwin) in the translation of part the theological work Satanae Strategemata of Jacob Acontius on toleration.^[24] He called on the Ranter Abiezer Coppe to repent,^[25] and helped in drafting his recantation.^[26] He provided arguments in pamphlets of March and October 1649 for supporting the Rump Parliament.^[27] Hill^[28] places Dury with Anthony Ascham and Marchamont Nedham as propounding the theory that Parliament had legitimacy conferred by God because it held power de facto. Barbara Lewalski calls Dury's arguments 'Hobbesian'.^[29] Hill^[30] considers that the failure of Cromwell's plan to create a unified Protestant church in England of the 1650s put paid to Dury's ecumenical ideas.

In 1652 he translated John Milton's Eikonoklastes into French as Eikonoklastēs, ou, Réponse au livre intitulé Eikon basilikē. In 1655 Milton quoted from letters of Dury in his Pro se defensio contra Alexandrum Morum.^[31]

In 1654 he was sent as a diplomat by Oliver Cromwell to Germany, the Netherlands and Switzerland.^[32][33] In 1652/3 he had travelled with Bulstrode Whitelocke to Sweden.^[34]

He also worked with Whitelocke as a deputy librarian, from 1649, of the collection going back to Jane Lumley. His book of 1650 on librarianship, sometimes said to be the first such work, came out of his experience in this post.^[35]

Jews and Hebraists

Dury met Manasseh ben Israel in 1644, and heard from him an account of Antonio de Montesinos's alleged discovery of the Ten Tribes in America.^[36] Dury wrote in favour of a Hartlib Circle project, for a College of Jewish Studies.^[37] Parliament was lobbied for funds. The proposed faculty were Johann Stephanus Rittangel, Christian Ravius and Menasseh ben Israel.^[38]

In 1649 Dury addressed a further inquiry to Manasseh on the subject of the Ten Tribes, which resulted in the publication of The Hope of Israel. In 1650 appeared Thomas Thorowgood's Jewes in America; Dury read it in manuscript, and contributed to later editions.^[36] He included information on the Karaites, in whom he had a particular interest, from Rittangel.^[39][40]

Dury is considered to have been one of those around Cromwell influencing the decision to allow Jews to enter England officially (they were expelled by Edward I).^[41] He was the cautious author of a pamphlet of 1656, A Case of Conscience: Whether It Be Lawful to Admit Jews into a Christian Commonwealth, in it he laid down certain conditions that Jews must fulfil in order to be admitted (no blasphemy or proselytism etc).^[42] To a question put to him by Hartlib, as to the general lawfulness of their admission, Dury replied in the affirmative; but from the point of view of expediency, he considered that circumstances as to a particular time and place might render their admission unwise.^[43]

Irenicism and millenarianism

Dury's long ecumenical efforts have earned him a name as an irenicist.^[44] This territory he shared, to an extent, with his contemporary Hugo Grotius. Dury made contact with Grotius through his follower Samson Johnson (1603–1661).^[45] That relationship soured, since Dury had a hand in Johnson's dismissal as chaplain to Elizabeth, Queen of Bohemia, suspected of Socinianism.^[46] According to historian Hugh Trevor-Roper,

Dury, like Grotius, was an idealist, but their ideals were not quite the same. He wished to achieve not reunion for the peace of the Church but union of all Protestants for the holy war: in particular union of Lutherans and Calvinists.^[47]

Dury’s irenicism and philosemitism can be understood as interrelated aspects of an expansionist Protestant cause focussed on Britain, Ireland, continental Europe, and the Atlantic world. In this understanding, the Portuguese Jews (and American Indians) appear as victims of Spanish Catholicism in desperate need of Protestant help.^[48]

Richard Popkin and Jefferey Jue have argued that Dury was a millenarian. His millenarian views are said to have pointed to 1655 as apocalyptic.^[49] Against that view it has been argued that Dury warned readers about attempts to predict the onset of the Millennium. In his preface to the millenarian tract Clavis Apocalyptica Dury seems to come out against the idea of a political millenarianism and to defend a more "moral" interpretation of millenarianism.^[50]

Position in the Hartlib Circle

Main article: Hartlib Circle

Pansophism and alchemy

Alchemy was within the interests of the Hartlibian group,^[51] and both Dury and his wife were involved. In 1649 they were quizzing Worsley on distillation.^[52] In the first half of 1651 Dury was a witness to George Starkey, in an apparent transmutation,^[53] and then recommended Starkey to Moriaen.^[54]

Family

In 1645 he married Dorothy Moore (née King), an Irish Puritan widow.^[55] Dorothy Durie (sic), daughter of Sir John King and Catherine Drury, was a noted writer on education and the role of women in the church.^[56] The match was arranged by Dorothy's niece, Katherine Jones, Viscountess Ranelagh (1615–1691),^[57] daughter of Richard Boyle, 1st Earl of Cork, and wife of Arthur Jones, 2nd Viscount Ranelagh.^[58] To be precise on the somewhat tenuous relationship, Arthur Moore, Dorothy's first husband, and Frances Jones née Moore, mother of Arthur Jones, were brother and sister, both children of Garret Moore, 1st Viscount Moore.^[59] By this marriage Dury was connected to Robert Boyle, brother of Lady Ranelagh.

Their daughter Dora Katherina Dury (1654–77) was Henry Oldenburg's second wife. Dorothy also had two sons by her first husband. ^[60]

Works

• Analysis Demonstrativa
• Paraenesin
• Answer to the Lutherans
• De pace inter evangelicos procuranda sententiæ quatuor quarum tres a reverendis Dominis episcopis (1638) with Thomas Morton, John Davenant, Joseph Hall
• A Briefe Relation of That Which Hath Been Lately Attempted to Procure Ecclesiasticall Peace Amongst Protestants (1641)
• A summary discourse concerning the work of peace ecclesiasticall (1641)
• Consultatio theologica super negotio pacis ecclesiasticæ promovendo (1641)
• Good counsells for the peace of reformed churches (1641) with John Davenant, Thomas Morton, Joseph Hall and James Ussher
• A motion tending to the publick good of this age and of posteritie (1642)^[61]
• An epistolary discourse (1644)
• A model of church-government (1647)
• Considerations tending to the happy Accomplishment of Englands Reformation in Church and State (1647) with Samuel Hartlib
• The Reformed School (1648), edited by H. M. Knox (1958)
• Considerations Concerning the Present Engagement^[62] (1649)
• A Seasonable Discourse^[63] (1649)
• The Reformed Librarie-Keeper (1650) Online text at Project Gutenberg
• The unchanged, constant, and single-hearted Peace-maker drawn forth into the world (1650)
• Objections Against the Taking of The Engagement Answered (1650)
• Jvst re-proposals to humble proposals (1650)
• The Reformed Spiritual Husbandman (1652)^[64]
• A summarie platform of the heads of a body of practicall divinity which the ministers of the Protestant churches abroad have sued for, and which is farther enlarged in a treatise intituled, An earnest plea for gospel-communion (1654)
• A Brief Answer to Some of the Objections and Demurs Made Against the Coming in and Inhabiting of the Jews in this Common-wealth: With a Plea on Their Behalf, Or Some Arguments to Prove it Not Only Lawful, But the Duty of Those Whom it Concerns to Give Them Their Liberty and Protection (they Living Peaceably) in this Nation (1656)
• A Declaration of John Dury, to make known the Truth of his Way and Deportment in all these Times of Trouble (1660)
• Irenicorum Tractatuum Prodromus (1662)
• Extractum ex harmonia confessionum oblatum ecclesiis reformatis ut examinetur antequam opus ipsum Lutheranis offeratur (1671)
• Touchant l'intelligence de l'Apocalypse par l'Apocalypse même (1674)
• Le Vrai Chrestien (1676)

Notes

1. John Durie or Durye, Johannes Duraeus, Johannes Dureus, Johann Dureus, Jean Duré.
2. "Durie timeline". Archived from the original on 29 September 2007. Retrieved 31 October 2021.
3. "Durie, Robert" . Dictionary of National Biography. London: Smith, Elder & Co. 1885–1900.
4. Turnbull, 1947, p. 127. In a letter to Hartlib he writes that he was brought up in Leiden and attended the French College there.
5. J. T. Young (1998), Faith, Alchemy and Natural Philosophy: Johann Moriaen, Reformed Intelligencer, and the Hartlib Circle, p.11.
6. Hugh Trevor-Roper, Three Foreigners, p.251 in Religion, the Reformation, and Social Change; online PDF Archived 13 December 2006 at the Wayback Machine.
7. Popkin, The Pimlico History of Western Philosophy/Columbia History (1998/9), p. 334.
8. Léchot, Un christianisme sans partialité (2011), p. 417-419.
9. "Reformation in Belarus". Belreform.org. Archived from the original on 24 October 2021. Retrieved 31 October 2021.
10. "Hartlib Circle Catalogue Number 66". Mhs.ox.ac.uk. Archived from the original on 31 October 2021. Retrieved 31 October 2021.
11. Turnbull, 1947, pp.132-291.
12. Hugh Trevor-Roper, Archbishop Laud (1962 edition), pp. 264–9.
13. A Nation of Change and Novelty (1990), p. 83.
14. Christopher Hill, Intellectual Origins of the English Revolution (1965), p. 100. Hill lists among Dury's English supporters Richard Holdsworth (p.100), John Stoughton (p.101), John Pym (p. 107); Thomas Goodwin, Philip Nye and Henry Burton (p.308).
15. PDF Archived 20 April 2017 at the Wayback Machine, p.4; John Morrill, The Nature of the English Revolution (1993), p. 138 – Welles had studied in Leiden.
16. Concise Dictionary of National Biography
17. Jonathan Israel, The Dutch Republic (1995) p.589; see also Popkin, p. 334.
18. Jonathan Israel, The Radical Enlightenment (2001) p.204, speaking of 30 years later, describes Dury as anti-Cartesian and a correspondent of Johann Heinrich Heidegger.
19. John Adamson, The Noble Revolt (2007), p. 361.
20. Hill, Intellectual Origins, p. 104.
21. Christopher Hill, The English Bible and the Seventeenth-Century Revolution (1993), p. 111.
22. Hill, Intellectual Origins, p. 102.
23. "A List of the Members of the Westminster Assembly". Archived from the original on 8 November 2008. Retrieved 31 October 2021.
24. Hill, Intellectual Origins, p. 102; Hill, Milton, p. 289.
25. Christopher Hill, The Experience of Defeat (1984), p. 42.
26. Hill, A Nation of Change, p. 201.
27. Richard Tuck, Philosophy and Government 1572–1651 (1993), pp. 257–259.
28. Christopher Hill, A Turbulent, Seditious, and Factious People (1988), p. 314; also Hill, Experience p. 101.
29. The Life of John Milton (2000) p. 249; Hill, Intellectual Consequences p. 21 endorses the idea that these theorists anticipated Thomas Hobbes.
30. Some Intellectual Consequences of the English Revolution (1980), p. 73.
31. Barbara Lewalski, The Life of John Milton (2000), p. 324.
32. Trevor-Roper, Three Foreigners, p.283.
33. "OwenCoresp1". Archived from the original on 12 May 2007. Retrieved 15 May 2007., letter 19 To Evangelical Churches, given as March 1654, with signatories.
34. Hill, Intellectual Origins, p. 103.
35. Hill, Intellectual Origins, p. 215.
36. "See Tudor Parfitt, The Lost Tribes of Israel". 2002. pp. 74–7. Archived from the original on 29 September 2007. Retrieved 15 May 2007.
37. Young, p.43. The first college for Jewish studies (1984), Richard Henry Popkin.
38. Marsha Keith Schuchard (January 2002). Restoring the temple of vision: cabalistic freemasonry and Stuart culture. BRILL. p. 457. ISBN 978-90-04-12489-9. Retrieved 11 March 2013.
39. Johannes Van Den Berg; Jan De Bruijn (1999). Religious Currents and Cross-Currents: Essays on Early Modern Protestantism and the Protestant Enlightenment. BRILL. p. 48. ISBN 978-90-04-11474-6. Retrieved 11 March 2013.
40. Mordecai L. Wilensky, Thomas Barlow's and John Dury's Attitude Towards the Readmission of the Jews to England, The Jewish Quarterly Review, New Ser., Vol. 50, No. 3 (Jan. 1960), pp. 256–268.
41. Hill, Intellectual Origins, p. 102-3.
42. Scult, Mel (1978). Millennial Expectations and Jewish Liberties: A Study of the Efforts to Convert the Jews in Britain, Up to the Mid Nineteenth Century. Brill Archive. pps.26-27.
43. "DURY, JOHN". Jewishencyclopedia.com. Archived from the original on 31 October 2021. Retrieved 31 October 2021.
44. S. Mandelbrote, John Dury and the practice of Irenicism, in Religious change in Europe 1650–1914: Essays for John McManners, ed. N. Aston, 41–58. (Oxford, 1997); A. Milton, The Unchanged Peacemaker? John Dury and the politics of Irenicism in England, 1628–1643 in Samuel Hartlib and Universal Reformation: studies in intellectual communication, ed. M. Greengrass, M. Leslie, and T. Raylor, 95–117. (Cambridge 1994).
45. "Note" (PDF). Igitur-archive.library.uu.nl. p. 81. Archived (PDF) from the original on 3 February 2007. Retrieved 15 May 2007.
46. Hugh Trevor-Roper, From Counter-Reformation to Glorious Revolution (1992) pp.71–2.
47. Hugh Trevor-Roper, From Counter-Reformation to Glorious Revolution (1992) p.68.
48. Fradkin, Jeremy, (April 2017). Protestant Unity and Anti-Catholicism: The Irenicism and Philo-Semitism of John Dury in Context Archived 12 March 2018 at the Wayback Machine. Journal of British Studies, 56(2), pps. 273-294. doi:10.1017/jbr.2017.2
49. Parfitt, p.80.
50. Gibson, The Apocalyptic Thought of John Dury: A Reassessment, Journal of Ecclesiastical History, Volume 60, No. 3, July 2009 pp.1–15; see the more careful interpretation of Léchot, Un christianisme sans partialité (2011), p., p. 447-454.
51. Young, p. 161.
52. William R. Newman and Lawrence M. Principe (2002), Alchemy Tried in the Fire, p. 244.
53. Young p. 229.
54. Newman and Principe, p. 246.
55. Pal, Carol Republic of Women Cambridge University Press 2012 p.133
56. "Durie [née King], Dorothy (c. 1613–1664), writer on education | Oxford Dictionary of National Biography". Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (online ed.). Oxford University Press. 2004. doi:10.1093/ref:odnb/55437. Retrieved 18 March 2020. (Subscription or UK public library membership required.)
57. Pal (2012) p.133
58. Christopher Hill, Milton and the English Revolution (1977), p. 146; Hill there also confirm the Lycidas connection.
59. Cokayne, G.E. Complete Peerage reprinted in 6 volumes Gloucester 2000 Vol. VIII p.543
60. Hill, Milton, p. 215.
61. Suggested the setting-up of a public lectureship on Scriptural learning; Hill p.237.
62. See Hill English Bible, pp.191–2.
63. A Seasonable Discourse ... 1. What the Grounds and Method of our Reformation ought to be in Religion and Learning. 2. How, even in these times of distraction, the Work may be advanced: By the Knowledge of Orientall tongues and Jewish mysteries; By an agency for advancement of universall learning.
64. Mainly by Hartlib, PDF extract Archived 29 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine.

References

• J. Minton Batten (1944) John Dury, Advocate of Christian Reunion, Chicago, University of Chicago Press
• G. H. Turnbull (1947) Hartlib, Dury, and Comenius: Gleaning from Hartlib's Papers, London, University Press of Liverpool (Hodder & Stoughton)
• Thomas H. H. Rae (1998) John Dury and the Royal Road to Piety
• Pierre-Olivier Léchot (2011) Un christianisme "sans partialité". Irénisme et méthode chez John Dury (v.1600–1680)
• Pierre-Olivier Léchot (2011/2012) "Between Ramism, Socinianism and Enthusiasm. The Intellectual Context of John Dury's Analysis Demonstrativa Sacrae Scripturae", Acta Comeniana. International Review of Comenius Studies and Early Modern Intellectual History , 25, 2011/12, p. 93-123.

External links

• Works by John Dury at Project Gutenberg
• Works by or about John Dury at the Internet Archive
• Works by John Dury at Post-Reformation Digital Library
• Biography of John Dury
• Bibliography containing many Dury titles
• Friedrich Wilhelm Bautz (1975). "Durie (Dury, Duraeus), John". In Bautz, Friedrich Wilhelm (ed.). Biographisch-Bibliographisches Kirchenlexikon (BBKL) (in German). Vol. 1. Hamm: Bautz. cols. 1433–1434. ISBN 3-88309-013-1.