Guangzhou Uprising

For the Guangzhou Uprisings that occurred during the late Qing Dynasty, see First Guangzhou Uprising and Second Guangzhou Uprising.

The Guangzhou Uprising, Canton Uprising^[2] or Canton Riots of 1927 was a failed communist uprising in the city of Guangzhou (Canton) in southern China.

Guangzhou Uprising
Part of Chinese Civil War
Communist casualties
Date 11–13 December 1927[1] Location Guangzhou, Republic of China Result Government victory; the uprising is crushed but encourages further uprisings across China.
Belligerents
Chinese Communist Party "Soviet of Workers, Soldiers and Peasant Deputies"[2] Supported by:  Soviet Union Comintern	Republic of China
Commanders and leaders
Zhang Tailei † Ye Ting Ye Jianying Xu Xiangqian Heinz Neumann	Zhang Fakui
Units involved
Red Guard Communist cadet regiment	National Revolutionary Army (NRA)
Strength
20,000 armed workers and soldiers[2]	15,000 soldiers; later reinforced by 5 divisions[2]
Casualties and losses
5,700[2][3]	heavy[2]

Guangzhou Uprising
Traditional Chinese	廣州起義
Simplified Chinese	广州起义
Cantonese Yale	Gwóngjàu Héiyih
Transcriptions Standard Mandarin Hanyu Pinyin Gǔangzhōu Qǐyì Yue: Cantonese Yale Romanization Gwóngjàu Héiyih

Background

The Chinese Communist Party (CCP)'s Guangdong Provincial Committee had been preparing for an uprising in Guangzhou since September 1927. It originally planned to use a large group of communist-leaning soldiers who were heading into Guangdong after taking part in the failed Nanchang uprising. According to these plans, local workers and peasants were supposed to act as auxiliaries, while the soldiers would bear the brunt of the fighting. The troops from Nanchang were defeated at Shantou in early October, however, precluding any attempt to utilise them in the Guangzhou Uprising.^[4] CCP party head Qu Qiubai consequently decided that the communists had to persuade soldiers who were stationed in Guangdong to join their cause. Upon receiving orders from Joseph Stalin to launch the planned uprising in mid-December,^[5] over the course of November, a final plan for rebellion was worked out by the central party leadership and Guangdong secretary Zhang Tailei in Shanghai.^[6] Originally, the Chinese communist leadership opposed the plans, and made representations to the Soviet government to the effect that they had no chance at winning control of Guangzhou, but ultimately gave in to Soviet pressure.^[5] The CCP thought that fighting between the Kuomintang-aligned warlords Zhang Fakui and Li Jishen was imminent in Guangdong, potentially providing them with an opportunity to exploit the ensuing chaos by launching multiple simultaneous rebellions to seize power in the province.^[6]

Peasant insurgents were supposed to throw the countryside into chaos, while workers should take over the county seats, and a general strike would paralyze Guangzhou. A separate communist faction was to capture Hainan island, and an army from the Hailufeng Soviet attack Huizhou, and then advance against Guangzhou. In the end, however, the communists in Guangzhou did not follow this plan.^[7] The conflict between Zhang Fakui and Li Jishen already broke out on 27 November, with the former capturing Guangzhou from the latter in surprise attack. Thereafter, however, Zhang moved most of his troops out of the city to resist Li's counter-attacks. When the Guangdong Provincial Committee thus converged on 27 November, it concluded that the time was ideal for an insurrection in Guangzhou itself.^[8] It remains strongly disputed who exactly was responsible for the further course of events.^[9] The communists in Guangdong later claimed that their insurrection was based on the plans discussed with the party leadership, though historian Hsiao Tso-Liang argued that the former still acted completely autonomous and without the knowledge of the latter.^[8] Other historians consider this view too extreme, and have put forth evidence which suggests that the CCP's central leadership was informed about the ongoing events in Guangdong. Furthermore, it has been argued that Comintern agents who were present in the province might have decisively influenced the Guangdong Provincial Committee in its decisions about when and how to launch a rebellion.^[9]

Regardless of who was responsible for the decision, the Guangdong Committee began to prepare its uprising in earnest from 27 November. A Revolutionary Military Council was appointed with Ye Ting as commander-in-chief and Zhang Tailei as chairman.^[8] Sometime in early December, Comintern agent Heinz Neumann arrived in Guangdong, joining the local communists. According to CCP leader Zhang Guotao, Neumann came to wield great influence on the committee and took a leading role in the rebellion; others believe that he was just a messenger for Stalin.^[9] The core fighting force of the rebellion consisted of an ad-hoc "Red Guard" formed by 2,000 armed workers, and a communist-infiltrated cadet regiment of 1,200 soldiers.^[10]

History

On 11 December 1927, the political leadership of the CCP ordered about 20,000 communist-leaning soldiers and armed workers to organize a "Red Guard"^[11] and take over Guangzhou.^[2] The uprising occurred despite the strong objections of communist military commanders such as Ye Ting, Ye Jianying and Xu Xiangqian,^{[citation needed]} as the communists were badly armed - just 2,000 of the insurgents had rifles.^[11] Nevertheless, rebel forces captured most of the city within hours using the element of surprise, despite a huge numerical and technical advantage held by government troops. The communist leaders officially renamed the city's political structure the "Soviet of Workers, Soldiers and Peasant Deputies"^[2] or "Guangzhou Soviet".^{[citation needed]} After this initial success for the communists, however, the 15,000 National Revolutionary Army (NRA) troops in the area moved into the city and started to push back the insurgents. After five more NRA divisions arrived in Guangzhou, the uprising was quickly crushed. The insurgents suffered heavy casualties, while the survivors had to flee the city or go into hiding.^[2] The Comintern, especially Neumann, were later blamed for insisting that the communists had to hold onto Guangzhou at all cost.^[9] Zhang Tailei, the leading Red Guard organizer, was killed in an ambush as he returned from a meeting. The takeover dissolved by the early morning of December 13, 1927.

In the resulting purges, many young communists were executed and the Guangzhou Soviet became known as the "Canton Commune",^[11] "Guangzhou Commune" or "Paris Commune of the East"; it lasted only a short time at the cost of more than 5,700 communists dead and an equal number missing. Around 8 p.m. on 13 December, the Soviet consulate in Guangzhou was surrounded and all its personnel were arrested. In the accident the consulate diplomats Ukolov, Ivanov and others were killed.^[3] Ye Ting, the military commander, was scapegoated, purged and blamed for the failure, despite the fact that the obvious disadvantages of the communist force was the main cause of the defeat, as Ye Ting and other military commanders had correctly pointed out. Enraged by his unjustified treatment, Ye Ting left China and went into exile in Europe, not returning until nearly a decade later.

Despite being the third failed uprising of 1927, and reducing the morale of the communists, ^[11] it encouraged further uprisings across China.

See also

• Outline of the Chinese Civil War
• Shanghai Massacre

References

1. Hsiao 1967, p. 65.
2. Jowett 2014, p. 27.
3. "广州起义失败后苏联外交官为何惨遭处决并暴尸示众？_手机凤凰网". ihistory.ifeng.com. Retrieved 2018-08-27.
4. Hsiao 1967, pp. 65–66.
5. Brandt 1958, p. 162.
6. Hsiao 1967, p. 66.
7. Hsiao 1967, pp. 66–67.
8. Hsiao 1967, p. 67.
9. Tsin 2002, p. 234 (note 153).
10. Hsiao 1967, pp. 67–68.
11. Jowett 2013, p. 167.

Bibliography

• Brandt, Conrad (1958). Stalin's Failure in China: 1924–1927. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press.
• Dirlik, Arif (1 October 1997), "Narrativizing Revolution: The Guangzhou Uprising (11–13 December 1927) in Workers' Perspective", Modern China
• Hsiao, Tso-Liang (April–June 1967). "Chinese Communism and the Canton Soviet of 1927". The China Quarterly (30): 49–78. JSTOR 651862.
• Jowett, Philip S. (2013). China's Wars. Rousing the Dragon 1894–1949. Atglen, Pennsylvania: Schiffer Publishing. ISBN 978-1782004073.
• Jowett, Philip S. (2014). The Armies of Warlord China 1911–1928. Atglen, Pennsylvania: Schiffer Publishing. ISBN 978-0764343452.
• Tsin, Michael T. W. (2002). Nation, Governance, and Modernity in China: Canton, 1900–1927. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press.