Duncan McArthur

For the Canadian educator and politician, see Duncan McArthur (Canadian politician).

Duncan McArthur (1772 – April 29, 1839) was a military officer and a Federalist and National Republican politician from Ohio. He served as the 11th governor of Ohio.

Duncan McArthur
11th Governor of Ohio
In office December 18, 1830 – December 7, 1832
Preceded by	Allen Trimble
Succeeded by	Robert Lucas
Member of the U.S. House of Representatives from Ohio's 6th district
In office March 4, 1823 – March 3, 1825
Preceded by	John Sloane
Succeeded by	John Thomson
Member of the Ohio Senate from Ross, Franklin and Highland counties
In office 1805–1813 1821–1823
Preceded by	Abraham Claypool Joseph Kerr
Succeeded by	William Creighton, Sr. James Dunlap (1805–1813) David Crouse (1821–1823)
12th Speaker of the Ohio House of Representatives
In office December 1, 1817 – December 6, 1818
Preceded by	Thomas Kirker
Succeeded by	Joseph Richardson
Member of the Ohio House of Representatives from Ross and Franklin counties
In office 1804–1805 1815–1816 1817–1818
Personal details
Born	(1772-01-14)January 14, 1772 or (1772-06-14)June 14, 1772 Dutchess County, Province of New York, British America
Died	April 29, 1839 (aged 66–67) Chillicothe, Ohio, U.S.
Resting place	Grandview Cemetery
Political party	Federalist National Republican
Signature
Military service
Allegiance	United States
Branch/service	United States Army
Years of service	1812–1815
Rank	Brigadier general
Commands	Army of the Northwest
Battles/wars	War of 1812 Battle of Malcolm's Mills aka. McArthur's Raid

When first elected to state office as a representative, he was serving in the state militia during the War of 1812. He was later appointed as brigadier general in the U.S. Army. Shortly thereafter he was placed in charge of the Army of the Northwest, serving through 1817 and negotiating the Treaty of Fort Meigs of 1817 to ratify peace and land cessions with Native American tribes.

Biography

Sources vary as to McArthur's exact birthdate. It has been given as January 14, 1772,^[1][2] or June 14, 1772.^[3][4] He was born to Scottish immigrants in Dutchess County in the Province of New York,^[5] McArthur grew up in western Pennsylvania and later moved to Kentucky, where he was employed as an Indian ranger.^[6]

McArthur and his friend Alexander McGuffey volunteered in 1790 at Fort Pitt for expeditions against Native Americans during the Northwest Indian War,^[7] serving as a scout under Generals Josiah Harmar and Anthony Wayne.^[8] McArthur obtained a position with Nathaniel Massie in 1793, and worked with Massie on a surveying expedition in the Northwest Territory. In 1796, he worked with Massie to lay out the new town of Chillicothe, Ohio,^[6] which was to become the state capital in 1803. McArthur moved across the Ohio River in 1797 to Chillicothe, where he gained wealth by his land speculations in the Northwest Territory.

Career in the War of 1812

McArthur was elected to the United States House of Representatives from Ohio's 3rd congressional district while serving in the state militia during the War of 1812. He never qualified for office as he preferred to continue serving in the military.

Using deception in the First American Invasion of Canada

He was appointed colonel of Ohio volunteers and was second-in-command to General William Hull at Fort Detroit. In July 1812, General William Hull was at Fort Detroit as the British fortified a defensive position across the Detroit River in Windsor, Ontario.^[9] Hull decided to move the British to Fort Malden, further away from Detroit, so that he could seize the defenses in Windsor.^[10] To implement his plan, Hull resorted to deception, which began when his troops collected all the boats and canoes they could find.^[10] On 11 July 1812, Hull sent some boats down the river to Springwells, south of Detroit, in full view of the British.^[10] At the same time, the American regiment commanded by Duncan McArthur marched from Detroit to Springwells, also observed by the British.^[10]

With the British now anticipating an American crossing south of Detroit, a second American force moved north in the dark until they reached Bloody Run, a crossing point a mile and a half north of Fort Detroit and opposite the Ontario town of Sandwich.^[10] Finding no activity at Springwells, the British believed the Americans had already crossed the river and marched on Fort Malden.^[10] Assuming Fort Malden was vulnerable, the British troops in Sandwich marched south, and in the morning the Americans at Bloody Run crossed to Sandwich unopposed.^[10] After landing in Sandwich, the Americans then marched from Sandwich to Windsor and seized the British defensive works.^[10]

Duncan McArthur’s deep penetration raid into Thames

It was July 13, 1812. The American militia and regulars were conducting paramilitary operations in their invasion of Canada. American intelligence claimed they found a group of enemy Indian fighters. American militia commander Duncan McArthur with one hundred American militiamen went in pursuit. The American militia chased the enemy fighters and fell upon their rear. The enemy Indian fighters dispersed into the woods and escaped. Duncan McArthur was about to return, when Captain Smith of the Detroit dragoons overtook him with orders to push forward into enemy territory to the settlements on the Thames in search of provisions. McArthur obeyed and penetrated as far as the Moravian towns, sixty miles from its mouth. There was a house McArthur encountered in his raid in Thames. The owner had fled, but the house was guarded by a file of British soldiers. The group of British soldiers were captured, disarmed, and paroled. McArthur and his militia raiding force seized the boats along the stream and loaded them with enemy supplies they commandeered. On July 17, 1812, McArthur and his militia raiding force returned to an American base camp with about 200 barrels of flour, 400 blankets, and a quite large quantity of military stores. These were chiefly public property, collected for the British troops at Malden and yet American commander Hull gave a receipt for the whole, public and private.^[11][12]

Engagement at bridge near Fort Malden

On July 19, 1812. American Colonel Duncan McArthur with a recon force combined with 150 Ohio infantry troops under Colonel Lewis Cass are near the bridge leading to Fort Malden. Two British artillery guns fire on the Americans and take out an American cannon. Cass and his fellow Americans capture two British troops after they cross the bridge. All the Americans withdraw with their prisoners safely.^[13]

Surrender of Detroit

He and Colonel Lewis Cass were not present at Detroit when Hull surrendered and were greatly angered to hear that Hull had included both of them in the capitulation. When a British officer notified him of the surrender, McArthur is said to have torn off his epaulettes and broke his sword in a fit of rage, although historians note similar stories were told about other officers as well.^[14] The British paroled him and McArthur returned to Ohio.

Enlisting in the U.S. Army

He was appointed a brigadier general in the U.S. Army. Shortly thereafter he was placed in charge of the Army of the Northwest following Harrison's resignation.^[15]

Duncan McArthur’s raid

Main article: Battle of Malcolm's Mills

Duncan McArthur conducted a cavalry raid deep into Thames Valley. Duncan's objective was to devastate the settlement's food supplies which was mainly flour. Duncan and 700 riflemen mounted on horses conducted their raid in October. Duncan and his mounted riflemen inflicted massive damage on infrastructure, burned many flour mills, surprised Canadian militia in separate engagements, and took provisions. McArthur's mounted riflemen raided multiple population centers. McArthur's raiders killed 18 Canadian militiamen, wounded 9 militiamen, and captured 126 Canadian militia soldiers. McArthur avoided contact with the main British army. After completing his raid, McArthur and his mounted riflemen withdrew back to American lines safely. The American raiders suffered only 1 killed and 6 wounded.^{[16][17][18][19]}

End of War of 1812

McArthur did not face much action any further, but he was engaged in negotiating treaties with the Indians. In 1817, he was one of two commissioners (along with Lewis Cass) who negotiated the Treaty of Fort Meigs, which was signed September 29 of that year with several Native American tribes.

Serving in the House of Representatives

McArthur served intermittently thereafter in the Ohio House of Representatives and Ohio State Senate. He was elected and served a single term from 1823 to 1825 in the United States House of Representatives before winning election to the governorship in 1830. McArthur served a single term and did not seek re-election.

Death

McArthur was buried in Grandview Cemetery, Chillicothe, Ross County, Ohio, US.^[20] The trust established in his will later became the subject of litigation that went before the U.S. Supreme Court in McArthur v. Scott.

Legacy

The small village of McArthur, Ohio, the seat of Vinton County, is named for him.

McArthur founded the city of Greenfield, Ohio in 1799. Greenfield is located at N39 21.11958 W83 22.96284 (GPS coordinates), about 21 miles due west of Chillicothe. State Route 28, which runs between Greenfield and Chillicothe, in 1973 was named as General Duncan McArthur Highway per act of the 113th Ohio General Assembly.