Carolyn Marvin

Carolyn Marvin is a professor and author that specializes in communication, culture and media, political communication, and technology and society. Marvin is currently the Frances Yates Emeritus Professor of Communication at the University of Pennsylvania's Annenberg School for Communication.^[1] Marvin is the author of two major publications, When Old Technologies Were New^[2] and Blood Sacrifice and the Nation: Totem Rituals and the American Flag.^[3]

Marvin in 2006

Research and reviews

Marvin published When Old Technologies Were New in 1988.^[2] The book discusses topics such as communications, media, and the history of telecommunications as Marvin explores how early technologies impacted society, culture, and modern day communications.^[2]

The book did receive some critiques from academic sources. Richard Rudolph from the University of Massachusetts Boston praises Marvin's work overall but notes her use of stories rather than analysis at times as well as his thoughts on what other information could have been included about societal changes.^[4] Brain Winston of Pennsylvania State University writes that Marvin makes many interesting points about denying technological determinist vision and how the spread of electricity created a divide between those who had and could control electricity and those who could not.^[5] He also critiques the first chapter of the book saying that it does not make claims as important as the rest of the work and points out that he feels more evidence might be seen as being needed.^[5] A review by Kenneth Lipartito in the Journal of Social History discusses Marvin's book and poses strengths such as her textual analysis but also her weaknesses in sources and how many of them are potentially biased as trade journals and unclear as to their notability or reach.^[6] Susan Smulyan praises Marvin's historical analysis and the potential interest to historians and communication and media scholars alike in her review in the University of Chicago Press's peer reviewed journal Isis.^[7] David Nye, an associate professor at the University of Copenhagen, commends Marvin's work overall in his review in the journal Technology and Culture and compliments the thoroughness of her research and the connections she poses between communication, technology, and society.^[8]

Marvin's other book, Blood Sacrifice and the Nation: Totem Rituals and the American Flag, also received reviews and criticism. William Swatos, a scholar of religious studies, critiques Marvin and her co-author David Ingle for their belief in totemism and writes that their work is less analysis than just writing.^[9] Though the book did receive criticism, it also received praise. Heidi Hamilton of Augustana College (now Augustana University) praises Marvin and Ingle's work in the journal, Rhetoric and Public Affairs, for using the lens of totemism to view the militarism and violence in America.^[10]

References

1. "Carolyn Marvin, Ph.D." www.asc.upenn.edu. Retrieved 2021-10-03.
2. Marvin, Carolyn (1988). When old technologies were new : thinking about electric communication in the late nineteenth century. New York: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-802138-4. OCLC 84145564.
3. Marvin, Carolyn (1999). Blood sacrifice and the nation : totem rituals and the American flag. David W. Ingle. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-62345-6. OCLC 37310700.
4. Rudolph, Richard (1989). "Marvin, When old technologies were new (Book Review)". Journal of American History. 75 (4): 1348–1349. doi:10.2307/1908721. JSTOR 1908721.
5. Winston, B (1989). "Book Review: When old technologies were new: Thinking about communication in the late nineteenth century". Journal of Communication. 39 (2): 144–146.
6. Lipartito, K. (1 July 1989). "When Old Technologies Were New: Thinking About Communications in the Late Nineteenth Century. By Carolyn Marvin (New York: Oxford University Press, 1988. 269 pp.)". Journal of Social History. 22 (4): 785–786. doi:10.1353/jsh/22.4.785. ISSN 0022-4529.
7. Smulyan, Susan (March 1989). "When Old Technologies Were New: Thinking about Communications in the Late Nineteenth Century . Carolyn Marvin". Isis. 80 (1): 170–171. doi:10.1086/354985. ISSN 0021-1753.
8. Nye, David E.; Marvin, Carolyn (October 1989). "When Old Technologies Were New: Thinking about Electric Communication in the Late Nineteenth Century". Technology and Culture. 30 (4): 1045. doi:10.2307/3106211. JSTOR 3106211.
9. Swatos, Jr., William H. (28 March 2007). "Review of From Civil to Political Religion by Marcella Cristi, Blood Sacrifice and the Nation by Carolyn Marvin and David W. Ingle and Perspectives on Civil Religion by Gerald Parsons". Implicit Religion. 7 (2): 193–198. doi:10.1558/imre.v7i2.193.
10. Hamilton, Heidi Ehernberger (2001). "Blood Sacrifice and the Nation: Totem Rituals and the American Flag (review)". Rhetoric & Public Affairs. 4 (1): 173–175. doi:10.1353/rap.2001.0007. ISSN 1534-5238. S2CID 191504228.