Anti-Rent War

The Anti-Rent War (also known as the Helderberg War) was a tenants' revolt in upstate New York between 1839 and 1845. The Anti-Renters declared their independence from the manor system run by patroons, resisting tax collectors and successfully demanding land reform. The conflict resulted in the passage of laws that made feudal tenures illegal and outlawed leases greater than 12 years.^[2]

Anti-Rent War
Poster announcing an Anti-Rent meeting in the town of Nassau, New York
Date 1839-1845 Location Hudson Valley, Upstate New York Result Abolition of feudal tenure
Belligerents
Tenants	Patroons State of New York
Commanders and leaders
Smith A. Boughton	Stephen Van Rensselaer William L. Marcy John Van Buren Gov. William H. Seward
Units involved
25,000 - 60,000[1] tenants	ㅤ

Events

The incident began with the death of Stephen Van Rensselaer III in 1839.^[3] Van Rensselaer, who was described as a "lenient and benevolent landowner" was the patroon of the region at the time.^[4] As a way to develop his vast landholdings, Van Rensselaer granted tenants lifetime leases at moderate prices.^[5]

During his life, when tenants were in financial constraints, he preferred to accept rent in the form of goods and services in lieu of cash, allow rents to accumulate, or accept partial payment rather than evict them.^[5] However, his leases also included a "quarter-sale" provision, which required tenants who sold their leases to pay Van Rensselaer one fourth of the sale price or one additional year's rent.^[5] The patroons owned all the land on which the tenants in the Hudson Valley lived, and used this feudal lease system to maintain control of the region.^[5]

When he died, his wealth had been reduced in the economic downturn known as the Panic of 1837,^[6] so Van Rensselaer's will directed his heirs to collect outstanding rents and quarter-sale payments to apply to his estate's debts.^[6] When the heirs attempted to collect, tenants who believed their debts would be forgiven at Van Renselaer's death could not pay the amounts demanded, could not secure a favorable payment schedule from the heirs, and could not obtain relief in the courts, so they revolted.^[5][6]

The first mass meeting of tenant farmers leading to the Anti-Rent War was held at the top of the Helderberg mountains in Berne, New York on July 4, 1839. They issued a declaration of independence, promising: "We will take up the ball of the Revolution where our fathers stopped it and roll it to the final consummation of freedom and independence of the masses."^[2] Among their tactics was the rent strike, with tenants refusing to pay on their leases unless Van Rensselaer's heirs and the other patroons agreed to a negotiated settlement.^[7]

In December 1839 the Anti-Renters repulsed a 500-man posse led by Albany County sheriff Michael Artcher and including William Marcy and John Van Buren. Governor William Seward threatened the rebels with 700 militiamen and obtained their surrender. However, an insurrection continued to smolder. Disguised "Calico Indians" resisted eviction, tax collection, and law enforcement, sometimes tarring and feathering their enemies.^[2][8]

The conflict gained the support of somewhere between 25,000 and 60,000 of the approximately 300,000 tenants in the patroon system.^[9][10] In January 1845, one hundred and fifty delegates from eleven counties assembled at St. Paul's Lutheran Church^[11] in Berne to call for political action to redress their grievances.^[12]

Results

The Anti-Rent War led to the creation of the Antirenter Party, which had a strong influence on New York State politics from 1846 to 1851.^[13] Newly elected governor Silas Wright moved in 1845 to stamp out the Calico Indians, and pushed for a law which outlawed disguises.^[8]

Trials of leaders of the revolt, charged with riot, conspiracy and robbery, were held in 1845 with Amasa J. Parker presiding. Attorneys included Ambrose L. Jordan, as leading counsel for the defense, and John Van Buren, the state attorney general, who personally conducted the prosecution. At the first trial, the jury came to no conclusion and Parker declared a mistrial.^[14] During a re-trial in September 1845, the two attorneys started a fistfight in open court. Both were sentenced by the presiding judge, John W. Edmonds, to "solitary confinement in the county jail for 24 hours." At the conclusion of the trial, one defendant, Smith A. Boughton, was sentenced to life imprisonment. After the election of John Young as governor with the support of the Anti-Renters, he pardoned Boughton.^[15]

John Van Steenburgh and Edward O'Connor were sentenced to death by hanging for their involvement in the shooting of Undersheriff Osman Steele, an incident that took place at Moses Earle's farm in Andes, New York during a sheriff's sale after Earle was unable to pay his rent.^[16] The incident occurred on August 7, 1845, and the rent was to be paid by auctioning off Earle's livestock, which included six cows and eight pigs.^[17] The day following the murder, a panel of judges met every day for a month, except on Sundays. A state of insurrection was declared by the governor for the county, and 248 people were rounded up and jailed in a makeshift jail.^[18] Earle and two others were sentenced to life in prison.^[16] Several others received lesser prison sentences.^[16] Governor Young later commuted the death sentences to life in prison.^[16] At least seven men including Earle were sent to Dannemora just as the prison opened in 1845.^[19]

The New York Constitution of 1846 added provisions for tenants' rights, abolishing feudal tenures and outlawing leases lasting longer than twelve years.^[2][8] The remaining manors dissolved quickly as the patroons sold off the lands.^[2]

People involved

• Smith A. Boughton, Anti-Rent leader
• John W. Edmonds, judge who presided at Anti-Rent leader trials
• Ambrose L. Jordan, defense counsel at trials of Anti-Rent leaders.
• William Marcy, participated in posse to end Anti-Renter insurrection.
• Edward O'Connor, Anti-Renter who was convicted for murdering Undersheriff Osman Steele. He was sentenced to death, which was later commuted to life in prison.
• Amasa J. Parker, judge who presided at trials of Anti-Rent leaders,
• William Seward, governor at start of Anti-Rent rebellion who took steps to end it.
• John I. Slingerland, state legislator and U.S. Congressman, was an advocate for the tenants during the Anti-Rent War.^[20]
• John Van Buren, took part in posse that attempted to end Anti-Renter insurrection, prosecutor at trials of Anti-Renter leaders.
• Lawrence Van Deusen, president of the Anti-Rent Association of Albany County, New York.^[21]
• Stephen Van Rensselaer IV, heir to the Manor of Rensselaerswyck. His efforts to collect past due rents and refusal to negotiate with Anti-Renters was the primary cause of the dispute.
• John Van Steenburgh, Anti-Renter who was convicted for murdering Undersheriff Osman Steele. He was sentenced to death, which was later commuted to life in prison.
• Silas Wright, A Democrat who was governor prior to John Young, his efforts to end the Anti-Rent rebellion led to the election of Young, who was the nominee of the Whig Party.
• John Young, governor following the trials of the Anti-Rent leaders, he granted a pardon to Smith Boughton and commutations to other participants.

See also

• Anya Seton's novel Dragonwyck (1944) is set during the Anti-Rent War.^[22]
• 1918-20 New York City rent strikes
• 1907 New York City Rent Strike
• List of incidents of civil unrest in the United States
• Manor of Rensselaerswyck, for further information on how the following years convinced landed proprietors to sell out their interests
• Andes, New York

References

1. Huston, Reeve (2000). "The Parties and "The People": The New York Anti-Rent Wars and the Contours of Jacksonian Politics". Journal of the Early Republic. 20 (2): 241–271. doi:10.2307/3124703. ISSN 0275-1275. JSTOR 3124703.
2. Miller (1967), pp. 66–69.
3. Knewitz, Simone (2021). The Politics of Private Property. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books. p. 42. ISBN 978-1-7936-2376-8 – via Google Books.
4. Persico, Joseph E. (October 1974). "Feudal Lords On Yankee Soil". American Heritage. Rockville, MD: American Heritage Publishing Company.
5. Persico.
6. Knewitz, p. 42.
7. Wills, Matthew (2020-09-01). "Rural Rent Wars of the 1840s". JSTOR Daily. Retrieved 2023-07-24.
8. Thomas Summerhill, "Anti-Rent Wars (New York)", in Encyclopedia of U.S. Labor and Working-class History Vol. 1, ed. Eric Arnesen; Routledge, 2007; ISBN 978-0-415-96826-3; pp. 118–119.
9. Huston, Reeve (2000). "The Parties and "The People": The New York Anti-Rent Wars and the Contours of Jacksonian Politics". Journal of the Early Republic. 20 (2): 241–271. doi:10.2307/3124703. ISSN 0275-1275. JSTOR 3124703.
10. Levine, David (2015-07-30). "History of America's Other Revolution: The Anti-Rent Wars". Hudson Valley Magazine. Retrieved 2023-07-24.
11. Berne, NY: history, archived from the original on November 5, 2011, retrieved April 15, 2016
12. Christman, Henry (June 1978). Tin Horns and Calico, a Decisive Episode in the Emergence of Democracy. ISBN 0-685-61130-2.
13. Michael Holt, The Rise and Fall of the American Whig Party: Jacksonian Politics and the Onset of the Civil War, NY: Oxford U Press, 1999, 240-42, 299,591-91,647,655-56.
14. Bradbury, Anna Rossman (1908). History of the City of Hudson, New York. Hudson, NY: Record Printing and Publishing. p. 147.
15. Adams, Arthur G. (2003). The Hudson Through the Years. New York, NY: Fordham University Press. p. 243. ISBN 978-0-8232-1676-5.
16. "Biography, Osman N. Steele". Officer Down Memorial Page. Fairfax, VA: ODMP.org. Retrieved December 7, 2019.
17. Kabat, Jennifer (2024). The Eighth Moon: A Memoir of Belonging and Rebellion. Minneapolis: Milkweed Editions. pp. 3–5, 17. ISBN 9781639550685.
18. Kabat, Jennifer (2024). The Eighth Moon: A Memoir of Belonging and Rebellion. Minneapolis: Milkweed Editions. p. 213. ISBN 9781639550685.
19. Kabat, Jennifer (2024). The Eighth Moon: A Memoir of Belonging and Rebellion. Minneapolis: Milkweed Editions. p. 240. ISBN 9781639550685.
20. McCurdy, Charles W. (2001). The Anti-Rent Era in New York Law and Politics, 1839-1865. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press. p. 315. ISBN 978-0-8078-2590-7.
21. Charles W. McCurdy (2001). Anti-Rent Era in New York Law and Politics, 1839-1865. University of North Carolina Press. p. 205. ISBN 9780807825907. It was a bittersweet occasion for Lawrence Van Deusen, president of the Anti-Rent Association of Albany County. Van Deusen took pride in the unity and staying power of his fellow tenants since 1839, when Stephen Van Rensselaer IV ...
22. Seton, Anya (1944), Dragonwyck (novel)

Further reading

• Christman, Henry (1961) [1945]. Tin Horns and Calico: A Decisive Episode in the Emergence of American Democracy. New York, NY: Collier Books – via HathiTrust.
• Ford, Eric (June 2002), "New York's Anti-rent War 1845–1846", Contemporary Review.
• Kubik, Dorothy (1997), A Free Soil — A Free People: The Anti-Rent War in Delaware County, New York, Purple Mountain Press, ISBN 0-935796-86-X.
• McCurdy, Charles W (2001), The Anti-Rent Era in New York Law and Politics, 1839–1865, Univ of North Carolina Press, ISBN 0-8078-2590-5.
• Miller, Douglas T. (1967) Jacksonian Aristocracy: Class and Democracy in New York, 1830–1860. New York: Oxford University Press.
• Huston, Reeve (2004), "Popular Movements and Party Rule: The New York Anti-Rent Wars and the Jacksonian Political Order", in Pasley, Jeffrey L; Robertson, Andrew W; Waldstreicher, David (eds.), Beyond the founders: new approaches to the political history of the early American republic, Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, pp. 355–86.
• Huston, Reeve (2000). Land and Freedom: Rural Society, Popular Protest, and Party Politics in Antebellum New York. Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-195-13600-5.
• Ellis, David M. (1944). "Land Tenure and Tenancy in the Hudson Valley, 1790-1860". Agricultural History. 18 (2): 75–82. ISSN 0002-1482. JSTOR 3739598.
• Mayham, Albert Champlin (1906). The anti-rent war on Blenheim Hill : an episode of the 40's : a history of the struggle between landlord and tenant growing out of the patroon system in the eastern part of New York. Cornell University Library. Jefferson, N.Y. : F.L. Frazee.