- Ed Abbaticchio, baseball player
- Ben Abruzzo, balloonist
- Acerra brothers, baseball players
- Mike Adamle, gridiron football
- Joey Amalfitano, baseball player
- Joe Amato, dragster racer[1]
- Lou Ambers, boxer
- Alan Ameche, football player
- John Andretti, race car driver
- Mario Andretti, race car driver
- Michael Andretti, race car driver
- Sammy Angott, boxer
- Johnny Antonelli, baseball player
- Vito Antuofermo, boxer
- Eddie Arcaro, jockey
- Bob Aspromonte, baseball player[2]
- Ken Aspromonte, baseball player[3]
- Charles Atlas, bodybuilder
- Geno Auriemma, basketball coach
- Sal Bando, baseball player
- Ray Barbuti, middle-distance runner
- Tom Barrasso, hockey player
- Carmen Basilio, boxer
- Bat Battalino, boxer
- Mark Bavaro, football player
- Gary Beban, football quarterback
- Joe Bellino, football halfback
- Nino Benvenuti, boxing
- John Beradino, baseball player and actor
- Yogi Berra, baseball player
- Angelo Bertelli, football quarterback
- Missie Berteotti, golfer
- Dan Biasone, basketball executive
- Craig Biggio, baseball
- Matt Biondi, swimmer
- Ping Bodie, baseball player
- Brian Boitano, figure skater
- Nick Bollettieri, tennis coach
- Zeke Bonura, baseball player and thrower
- Mollie Ann Bracigliano, sports marketing
- Ralph Branca, baseball pitcher
- Lawrence Brignolia, marathon runner
- Gene Brito, football player
- Doug Bruno, basketball
- Tedy Bruschi, football player[4]
- Doug Buffone, football player
- Nick Buoniconti, football player
- John Calipari, basketball coach
- Dolph Camilli, baseball player
- Roy Campanella, baseball player
- Lou Campi, professional bowler
- Tony Canadeo, football player
- Tony Canzoneri, boxer
- Donna Caponi, LPGA golfer
- Gino Cappelletti, football player
- John Cappelletti, football player
- Jennifer Capriati, tennis player
- Gina Carano, MMA fighter
- Glenn Carano, football player
- Harry Caray, baseball commentator
- Frankie Carideo, football player
- Mary Carillo, tennis player
- Primo Carnera, boxer and wrestler
- Lou Carnesecca, basketball coach
- John Carpino, baseball executive
- Rick Casares, football player
- Santo Catanzaro, softball player
- Phil Cavarretta, baseball player
- Al Cervi, basketball player and coach
- Giorgio Chinaglia, soccer player
- Dino Ciccarelli, hockey player
- Jean Cione, women's baseball player
- Jerry Colangelo, basketball executive
- Rocky Colavito, baseball player
- Ned Colletti, baseball executive
- Frank Coltiletti, jockey
- Franco Columbu, bodybuilder
- Rocco B. Commisso, soccer player
- Tony Conigliaro, baseball player
- John Conti, football player
- Young Corbett III, boxer
- Jim Corno, broadcasting executive
- Chris Costa, curling champ of Brooklyn
- Fred Couples, golfer
- Jim Covert, football player
- Frank Crosetti, baseball shortstop
- Tony Cuccinello, baseball player
- Pete Cutino, water polo coach
- Bobby Czyz, boxer
- Constantine "Cus" D'Amato, boxing trainer
- Eddie DeBartolo, football owner
- Michael DeCicco, fencing coach
- Alexis DeJoria, racecar driver
- Vinny Del Negro, basketball coach
- Alex Delvecchio, hockey player
- Tony DeMarco, boxer
- Frank Demaree, baseball player
- Joe DeNucci, boxer
- Ralph DePalma, racecar driver
- Peter DePaolo, racecar driver
- Red DiBernardi, basketball player
- Buttercup Dickerson, first Italian in MLB
- Ernie DiGregorio, basketball player
- Dom DiMaggio, baseball player
- Joe DiMaggio, baseball player
- Vince DiMaggio, baseball player
- Angelo Dundee, boxing cornerman
- Johnny Dundee, boxer
- Lou Duva, boxing trainer
- Alfred Faragalli, bowler
- Dave Ferraro, bowler
- Buzz Fazio, bowler
- Vince Ferragamo, football quarterback
- Lou Ferrigno, bodybuilder
- Doug Ford, golfer
- Chet Forte, talk radio host
- Joe Fortunato, football player
- John Franco, baseball reliever
- Mike Fratello, basketball coach
- Linda Fratianne, figure skater
- Jim Fregosi, baseball player and manager
- Carl Furillo, baseball player
- Joe Fiorentino, martial arts
- Gary Gaetti, baseball player
- John Gagliardi, college football coach
- Chip Ganassi, racecar driver
- Joe Garagiola, baseball catcher
- Eleanor Garatti-Seville, swimmer
- Arturo Gatti, boxer
- Frankie Genaro, boxer
- Eddie Giacomin, hockey player
- A. Bartlett Giamatti, MLB commissioner
- Joey Giardello, boxer
- Joe Girardi, baseball player and manager
- Margaret Gisolo, child baseball player
- Andy Granatelli, CEO of STP
- Cammi Granato, hockey player
- Rocky Graziano, boxer
- Vincenzo Greco, 2016 WSOP Main event 797th
- Agnes Iori-Robertson, basketball player
- Tom Izzo, basketball coach
- Ed Kelly, basketball player and superintendent
- Fidel La Barba, boxer
- Daryle Lamonica, football player
- Lou Lamoriello, hockey executive
- Jake LaMotta, boxer
- Tony La Russa, baseball player and manager
- Tommy Lasorda, baseball player and manager
- Hank Lauricella, college football player
- Dante Lavelli, football player
- Tony Lazzeri, baseball player
- Jean Lenti-Ponsetto, college sports executive
- Frank Lentine, softball player
- Marty Liquori, track athlete
- Lou Little, football player
- Ernie Lombardi, baseball player
- Vince Lombardi, football coach
- Dr. Donna Lopiano, women sports
- Larry Lucchino, MLB owner
- Mike Lucci, football player
- Hank Luisetti, basketball player
- Sal Maglie, baseball player
- Paulie Malignaggi, boxer
- Lenny Mancini, boxer
- Ray Mancini, boxer
- Gus Mancuso, baseball player
- Sammy Mandell, boxer
- Mike Manganello, jockey
- Greg Mannino, Paralympic skier
- Gino Marchetti, football player
- Rocky Marciano, boxer
- Ed Marinaro, football player
- Dan Marino, football player
- Hank Marino, bowler
- John Mariucci, hockey player
- Penny Marshall, film director
- Billy Martin, baseball player
- Art Martori, wrestling executive
- Mario Massa, bocce
- Rollie Massimino, basketball coach
- Linda Mastandrea, Paralympic athlete
- Joey Maxim, boxer
- Phil Mickelson, golfer
- Mike Modano, hockey player
- Joe Montana, football player
- Willie Mosconi, billiard player
- George Musso, football player
- Johnny Musso, football player
- Mary Lou Palermo, roller derby
- Steve Palermo, baseball umpire
- John Panelli, football player
- Babe Parilli, football player
- Dan Pastorini, football player
- Joe Paterno, football coach
- Generoso Pavese, fencer
- Vinny Pazienza, boxer
- Vincent Pazzetti, football player
- Stefano Pelinga, billiards player
- Willie Pep, boxer
- Joe Pepitone, baseball player
- Cavino Michelli Petillo, racing driver
- Johnny Petraglia, bowler
- Joe Petrali, motorcycle racer
- Rico Petrocelli, baseball player
- Harry Pezzullo, golf player
- Mike Piazza, baseball player
- Brian Piccolo, football player
- Ralph "Babe" Pinelli, baseball player
- Gene Pingatore, basketball coach
- Scott Pioli, football executive
- Tom Pistone, racecar driver
- Rick Pitino, basketball coach
- Angelo Pizzo, screenwriter
- Angelo Poffo, wrestler
- Vic Raschi, baseball player
- Mark Recchi, hockey player
- Lindy Remigino, track athlete
- Mary Lou Retton, gymnastics
- Dave Righetti, baseball player and coach
- Mike Rizzo, baseball executive
- Phil Rizzuto, baseball player
- Andy Robustelli, football player
- Robin Romeo, bowler
- Nat Rosasco, golfer
- Giuseppe Rossi, soccer player
- Richard Ruffalo, Paralympic athlete
- Angela Ruggiero, hockey player
- Tony Sacco, sports official
- Alicia Sacramone, gymnast
- Joan Salvato Wulff, fly fisher
- Carmen Salvino, bowler
- Bruno Sammartino, wrestler
- Ron Santo, baseball player
- Joey Saputo, soccer executive
- Gene Sarazen, golfer
- Randy Savage, wrestler
- Mike Scioscia, baseball manager
- Louis Scripa, Jr., sports endurance
- Ralph Serpico, college football player
- Jimmy Smith, bowler
- John Smith, wrestler
- John Smoltz, baseball player
- Sean P. Stellato, sports business
- Sonny Vaccaro, basketball scout
- Bobby Valentine, baseball manager
- Jim Valvano, basketball coach
- Andy Varipapa, bowler
- Ken Venturi, golfer
- The Venturini Family, racecar drivers
- Dick Vermeil, football coach
- Phil Villapiano, football player
- Frank Viola, baseball player
- Dick Vitale, sports announcer
- Vito Valentinetti, baseball player
"Joe Amato". National Italian American Sports Hall of Fame. Retrieved 15 June 2020. "Bob Aspromonte". National Italian American Sports Hall of Fame. Retrieved 15 June 2020. "Ken Aspromonte". National Italian American Sports Hall of Fame. Retrieved 15 June 2020. "Tedy Bruschi". National Italian American Sports Hall of Fame. Retrieved 15 June 2020.