No. | Date | Location | Winner | Score |
---|
1 | October 1, 1927 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 58–0 | 2 | November 4, 1933 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 20–7 | 3 | November 17, 1934 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 12–7 | 4 | October 25, 1935 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 39–0 | 5 | November 7, 1936 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 41–0 | 6 | October 9, 1937 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 33–0 | 7 | 1945 | ? | Valparaiso | 6–0 | 8 | November 16, 1946 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 25–0 | 9 | November 15, 1947 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 27–6 | 10 | September 22, 1951 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 41–7 | 11 | November 1, 1952 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 14–13 | 12 | October 31, 1953 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 32–20 | 13 | October 30, 1954 | Michigan City, IN | Valparaiso | 39–7 | 14 | October 29, 1955 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 24–14 | 15 | November 3, 1956 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 20–6 | 16 | October 19, 1957 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 27–0 | 17 | October 18, 1958 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 34–0 | 18 | October 17, 1959 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 10–7 | 19 | October 15, 1960 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 27–20 | 20 | November 4, 1961 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 14–2 | 21 | November 3, 1962 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 16–14 | 22 | November 2, 1963 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 20–12 | 23 | October 31, 1964 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 23–14 | 24 | October 9, 1965 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 23–21 | 25 | October 8, 1966 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 15–12 | 26 | October 7, 1967 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 21–7 | 27 | October 12, 1968 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 10–7 | 28 | November 8, 1969 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 38–20 | 29 | November 7, 1970 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 34–31 | 30 | November 6, 1971 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 48–12 | 31 | November 4, 1972 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 17–10 | 32 | October 13, 1973 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 12–6 | 33 | September 28, 1974 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 31–15 | 34 | October 11, 1975 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 38–9 | 35 | October 2, 1976 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 49–29 | 36 | October 1, 1977 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 14–7 | 37 | September 30, 1978 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 24–20 | 38 | September 29, 1979 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 25–22 | 39 | September 27, 1980 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 25–13 | 40 | October 3, 1981 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 16–0 | 41 | October 2, 1982 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 27–3 | 42 | October 1, 1983 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 41–35 |
No. | Date | Location | Winner | Score |
---|
43 | November 3, 1984 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 28–27 | 44 | November 2, 1985 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 26–15 | 45 | November 1, 1986 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 28–6 | 46 | November 7, 1987 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 29–22 | 47 | October 15, 1988 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 56–0 | 48 | October 14, 1989 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 31–0 | 49 | October 13, 1990 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 37–0 | 50 | October 19, 1991 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 22–2 | 51 | October 17, 1992 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 42–13 | 52 | October 9, 1993 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 10–0 | 53 | October 8, 1994 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 20–14 | 54 | October 7, 1995 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 44–42 | 55 | October 12, 1996 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 50–29 | 56 | October 18, 1997 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 19–17 | 57 | October 17, 1998 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 17–10 | 58 | October 9, 1999 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 38–20 | 59 | October 14, 2000 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 33–7 | 60 | October 6, 2001 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 38–21 | 61 | November 2, 2002 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 52–22 | 62 | November 8, 2003 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 25–21 | 63 | November 6, 2004 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 31–26 | 64 | October 15, 2005 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 34–21 | 65 | October 21, 2006 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 32–10 | 66 | October 13, 2007 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 42–37 | 67 | October 18, 2008 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 48–21 | 68 | October 17, 2009 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 23–14 | 69 | October 30, 2010 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 48–0 | 70 | October 15, 2011 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 42–14 | 71 | October 6, 2012 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 56–17 | 72 | November 9, 2013 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 72–12 | 73 | November 8, 2014 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 17–3 | 74 | November 7, 2015 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 42–21 | 75 | October 29, 2016 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 23–12 | 76 | November 11, 2017 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 36–28 | 77 | October 13, 2018 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 35–17 | 78 | November 16, 2019 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 24–21 | 79 | March 13, 2021 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 24–14 | 80 | March 27, 2021 | Valparaiso, IN | Valparaiso | 28–25 | 81 | November 13, 2021 | Indianapolis, IN | Valparaiso | 47–3 | 82 | October 15, 2022 | Valparaiso, IN | Butler | 26–25 | 83 | October 28, 2023 | Indianapolis, IN | Butler | 17–7 | Series: Butler leads 53–30 |
|