Ethnic Mennonite

The term ethnic Mennonite refers to Mennonites of Central European ancestry and culture who are considered to be members of a Mennonite ethnic or ethnoreligious group.^[1][2] The term is also used for aspects of their culture, such as language, dress, and Mennonite food.^[3]

History

The most prominent ethnic Mennonite groups are Russian Mennonites (German: Russland-Mennoniten), who formed as an ethnic group in Prussia and South Russia (now Ukraine), but who are mostly of Dutch (both Flemish, Frisian) and North German ancestry and speak Plautdietsch and Mennonites of Pennsylvania Dutch heritage who formed as an ethnic group in North America and who are of Swiss-German and South German ancestry.^[4]

For centuries, Mennonites almost exclusively married inside their churches, and moved through Europe and into North America in large groups, while maintaining their own language and religious practices. They emerged as distinct ethnic groups in Russia around 1789 and in North America around the 1730s. Many still speak those languages today: Pennsylvania German and Plautdietsch.^[5]

While missionary activities after 1950s, converted thousands to the Mennonite church in Africa, India, Indonesia and other places outside Europe and North America, these groups cannot be considered ethnic Mennonites as they do not share the same European heritage. In 2012, the Mennonite World Conference estimated that the majority of people attending Mennonite churches were not of Central European or Eastern European heritage anymore.^[6]

Some conservative strains of Mennonites, like the Old Order Mennonites and the Old Colony Mennonites have kept their languages, traditional customs and the practice of endogamy to this day, so that they are considered to be ethnic or ethnoreligious groups. The same is true for the Hutterites and the Amish who are Anabaptists like the Mennonites, but have never engaged in mission activities on a larger scale.

Since most religious Mennonites today do not belong to either Russian Mennonite or Pennsylvania Dutch heritage, discussions have arisen around what the Mennonite identity means. Some see the term "ethnic Mennonite" as unnecessary, believing that the only requirement needed to qualify someone as Mennonite is baptism as an adult into the Mennonite church.

That argument, however, fails to see a distinction between religious Mennonites and ethnic Mennonites, and denies the experience and identity of thousands of people in North America, Mexico, Belize, Paraguay, and elsewhere, who share a common Mennonite heritage.

While many ethnic Mennonites have assimilated into Western culture, and adopted English as their primary language, their heritage and their family names continue to distinguish them as ethnically Mennonites to other ethnic Mennonites, who are proud of their heritage and make a point of knowing who all their relatives are. This is affectionately referred to as the Mennonite Game.

Many ethnic Mennonites, would also consider themselves non-practicing, further demonstrating the need to distinguish between ethnic Mennonites and religious Mennonites, and highlighting the complications of ethnoreligious identity.^{[7][8][9][10][11]}

Literature

• Francis, E. K. "The Russian Mennonites: From Religious to Ethnic Group." American Journal of Sociology Vol. 54, No. 2 (Sep., 1948), pp. 101–107.
• Loewen, Royden. "The Poetics of Peoplehood: Ethnicity and Religion among Canada's Mennonites," in Paul Bramadat and David Seljak, Christianity and Ethnicity in Canada, University of Toronto Press, 2008.
• Redekop, John H. A People Apart: Ethnicity and the Mennonite Brethren, Hillsboro, KS: Kindred Press, 1987.

References

1. "Part I - Mormons as an Ethno-Religious Group - University Publishing Online". ebooks.cambridge.org. Archived from the original on 2020-05-16. Retrieved 2016-01-24.
2. Hammond, Phillip E. (2000). The Dynamics of Religious Organizations: The Extravasation of the Sacred and Other Essays. Oxford University Press. p. 59. ISBN 9780198297628. 1. Religion is the major foundation of ethnicity, examples include the Amish, Hutterites, Jews, and Mormons. Ethnicity in this pattern, so to speak, equals religion, and if the religious identity is denied, so is the ethnic identity. [Footnote: In actuality, of course, there can be exceptions, as the labels "jack Mormon," "banned Amish," or "cultural Jew" suggest.] Let us call this pattern "ethnic fusion."
   2. Religion may be one of several foundations of ethnicity, the others commonly being language and territorial origin; examples are the Greek or Russian Orthodox and the Dutch Reformed. Ethnicity in this pattern extends beyond religion in the sense that ethnic identification can be claimed without claiming the religious identification, but the reverse is rare. Let us call this pattern "ethnic religion."
   3. An ethnic group may be linked to a religious tradition, but other ethnic groups will be linked to it, too. Examples include Irish, Italian, and Polish Catholics; Danish, Norwegian, and Swedish Lutherans. Religion in this pattern extends beyond ethnicity, reversing the previous pattern, and religious identification can be claimed without claiming the ethnic identification. Let us call this pattern "religious ethnicity"
3. Voth, Norma Jost, "Mennonite Foods & Folkways from South Russia, Volumes I", pp. 35-55. Good Books, 1990. ISBN 0-934672-89-X
4. Staples, and, John R.; Toews, John B. Nestor Makhno and the Eichenfeld Massacre: A Civil War Tragedy in a Ukrainian Mennonite Village.
5. "Ethnicity". gameo.org.
6. "World Mennonite Membership Distribution". gameo.org.
7. "MWR : Stop using the term 'ethnic Mennonite'". mennoworld.org.
8. "A Response from an "Ethnic Mennonite" – "Stop using the term" - Abnormal Anabaptist". Abnormal Anabaptist. Archived from the original on 2016-05-28. Retrieved 2015-07-19.
9. "Mennonites or Ethnonites?". anabaptistly. 26 February 2013.
10. "The Mennonite Game" at Mennonite Historical Society of Canada.
11. "Just who are the 'Racial/Ethnic' Mennonites?". Young Anabaptist Radicals. 23 March 2007.