Deaths along the Bangladesh–India border

Deaths along the Bangladesh–India border occur many times a year as result of people attempting to illegally cross into India from Bangladesh, for walking along the border, cross border firing and cattle smuggling.^[1] Bangladesh and India share a 4,096 kilometer (2,545 mile) border.^[2] To prevent smuggling and illegal migration from Bangladesh, the Indian Border Security Force exercises its controversial "Shoot-on-sight" policy. Under this policy, the BSF can shoot any person on sight with or without cause.^[3] A large portion of the victims are cattle traders and farmers with land near the border.^[4] Brad Adams, stated that, "Routinely shooting poor, unarmed villagers is not how the world's largest democracy should behave."^[3]

According to a report published by Human rights organisations, around 1,000 Bangladeshi civilians have been killed by Indian Border Security Force (BSF) in a period of 10 years (from 2001 to 2010).^[5][6] The report also states that Indian paramilitary forces routinely threaten, abuse arbitrarily detain and torture local Bangladeshi civilians living along the border and Bangladeshi border guards usually don't help the Bangladeshi civilians.^[5][6][7] Odhikar, a Bangladesh-based human right organization, allege that acts of rape and looting have also been perpetrated by BSF at the border areas.^[8]

Illegal migration

In some border areas, strong fences are installed by India

Indian Border Security Force (BSF) exercises its controversial 'Shoot-on-Sight' policy to stop illegal migration. The then-head of BSF, Raman Srivastava, states that 'people should not feel sorry for the victims as they were trying to illegally enter into India and therefore they are a legitimate target'.^[3] Killings along the Bangladesh-India border are routine and arbitrary. Around 1,000 people, mostly Bangladeshi nationals, have been killed by Indian border security forces over the period of 10 years (2001 to 2010).^[5] None of the Indian BSF personnel involved in killings along the border was ever prosecuted.^[3] Human Rights Watch (HRW) report states that BSF justifies killing by claiming that it was an act of self-defence or that the suspects were evading arrest.^[9][10] However, the reports filed by the BSF with the Indian police don't show recovery of any lethal weapon or explosives from the victim which justifies self-defense.^[10] Several survivors and eyewitnesses of BSF attacks allege that the BSF resort to indiscriminate shooting without issuing any warning.

Often, Indian border guards kill a person and leave his body near the fence or hang him in the camp to show the extent of power exercised by Border Security Force (BSF). Odhikar, a Bangladesh-based human right organisation, allege that Border Security Force (BSF) and Indian miscreants have also committed acts of rape against Bangladeshi women along the border.^[11]

Human Right Watch (HRW) reports that Indian Border Security Force (BSF), which has long record of severe human right abuses, is exempt from criminal prosecution, unless it is specifically ordered by the Indian government to undertake a prosecution in a particular case.^[10]

Killing of Felani Khatun

Main article: Killing of Felani Khatun

On 7 January 2011, a 15-year-old girl, Felani, was shot dead while illegally entering Bangladesh from India by the BSF in Phulbari Upazila, Kurigram.^[12] She had gotten stuck in the barbed wire when she was shot and she remained there for 5 hours until she bled to death.^[4] This resulted in protests in Bangladesh.^[13] In 2015, National Human Rights Commission of India asked the Indian government to pay INR 500,000 as compensation to her family.^[14][15]

Killing, abduction and torture

BSF routinely kills, abducts and tortures Bangladeshi citizens despite repeated pledge to stop using lethal weapons.^[16]

Indian nationals killed by Border Guards Bangladesh

Some Indian nationals were also reported to have been killed by Border Guards Bangladesh (BGB) on suspicion of being a smuggler. On 21 January 2012, Indian officials claimed that four BGB soldiers crossed into India and killed an Indian national. The soldiers were trying to drag the body of the Indian national when they were stopped by Indian locals who gathered at the site after hearing gun shots. The locals captured one BGB soldiers while the other three BGB soldiers managed to flee. The Bangladeshi officials claim that the slain Indian national was a smuggler, however, Indian officials claim that the slain Indian national was just a farmer.^[17]

On 7 April 2015, Indian officials reported that Border Guards Bangladesh (BGB) had crossed 10 kilometers in Indian territory and killed two Indian nationals. The body of one Indian national was taken back by Bangladesh. The incident created tensions between BSF and BGB. The Bangladeshi officials claimed that the killed Indian nationals were smugglers.^[18]

Cross border firing

India-Bangladesh border clashes
Date 2001 – ongoing Location Bangladesh–India border Status Ongoing Decline in Bangladesh–India relations[19]
Belligerents
India	Bangladesh
Units involved
Border Security Force (BSF)	Border Guards Bangladesh (BGB)
Casualties and losses
India claim: 19 soldiers killed[20][21][22] 4,225 BSF personnel injured by smugglers[23]	Bangladesh claim: 6 soldiers killed[24][25][26] At least 1,923 Bangladeshi civilians were killed by the BSF between 2000 and 2023[27][11]

2001 border clash

2001 Bangladesh-Indian border clash
Part of Deaths along the Bangladesh–India border
Date 16 April 2008 - 20 April 2001 Location Bangladesh–India border Result Inconclusive
Belligerents
Bangladesh	India	cattle smuggler
Units involved
Border Guard Bangladesh	BSF 117th Battalion
Casualties and losses
	16 soldiers killed

From 16 to 20 April 2001, India and Bangladesh exchanged gunfire in a border clash. 16 BSF soldiers were killed in the clash.

2005 border clash

2005 Bangladesh-Indian border clash
Part of Deaths along the Bangladesh–India border
Date 16 April 2005 Location Bangladesh–India border Result Inconclusive
Belligerents
Bangladesh	India	cattle smuggler
Units involved
Border Guard Bangladesh	BSF 117th Battalion
Casualties and losses
2 civilians killed	2 soldiers killed

On 16 April 2005, India and Bangladesh border troops engaged in gunbattle that resulted in death of two Indian border soldiers and two Bangladeshi civilians.^[21] Bangladesh border guard stated that the bodies of Indian border soldier and an officer was lying inside Bangladeshi territory.^[21][28] Bangladeshi border guards claim that a platoon of Indian border guards along with some 100 Indian civilians entered into Bangladesh territory and resorted to looting in Hirapur village. Indian border guards and civilians intrusion in Bangladesh prompted Bangladesh border guards to retaliate.^[29] However, according to Indian military officials, Indian border guards had requested a flag meeting to secure the release of an Indian villager abducted earlier by Bangladesh border guards. Bangladesh border guards instead abducted BSF officer named Assistant Commandant Jiwan Kumar from the meeting and took him into Bangladesh where he was tortured and later killed.^[30]

2008 border clash

2008 Bangladesh-Indian border clash
Part of Deaths along the Bangladesh–India border
Date 18 July 2008 Location Bangladesh–India border Result Inconclusive
Belligerents
Bangladesh	India	cattle smuggler
Units involved
Border Guard Bangladesh	BSF 117th Battalion
Casualties and losses
2 killed	1 injured

On 18 July 2008, two Bangladesh border guards were killed by Border Security Force (BSF). Indian officials claim that the BSF soldiers were pursuing a cattle smuggler, when Bangladesh border guards started firing at them, which prompted BSF troops to retaliate. In the ensuing firefight, two Bangladeshi border guards were killed and one BSF soldier was injured. According to Indian military officials, Bangladesh border guards were present on the Indian side of the border.^[26] However, according to Bangladeshi officials, Bangladesh border guards were only conducting patrol along the border, when they were suddenly attacked by Indian BSF.^[26]

2013 border clash

2013 Bangladesh-Indian border clash
Part of Deaths along the Bangladesh–India border
Date 11 February 2013 Location Bangladesh–India border Result Inconclusive
Belligerents
Bangladesh	India	cattle smuggler
Units involved
Border Guard Bangladesh	BSF 117th Battalion
Casualties and losses
		2 killed

On 11 February 2013, Bangladeshi officials claim that Border Guard Bangladesh (BGB) killed two Indian nationals. According to Bangladeshi officials, the two Indian nationals were smugglers and they attacked a BGB patrol party, which prompted BGB to retaliate. Both the smugglers were killed and their bodies were taken back by BSF. Later on, BSF took positions and started firing on BGB, which lasted for thirty minutes.^[31]

2019 border clash

2019 Bangladesh-Indian border clash
Part of Deaths along the Bangladesh–India border
Date 18 October 2019 Location Bangladesh–India border Result Inconclusive
Belligerents
Bangladesh	India
Units involved
Border Guard Bangladesh	BSF 117th Battalion
Casualties and losses
	1 killed

In 2019, Bangladeshi border guards shot at BSF personnel. Bangladeshi officials claimed it was self defence. One BSF officer was killed in the clash.^[32]

Cattle smuggling

In Bangladesh, Indian cattle can become legal through a small tax to the government, while India bans all export of cattle. This has become a flash-point issue in the border. The cattle trade according to an estimate in the Christian Science Monitor is close to one billion dollars.^[33] A Bangladeshi cattle smuggler was killed in March 2014 in the border near Satkhira Sadar upazila by the BSF.^[34] In January 2016, a Bangladeshi cattle smuggler was allegedly tortured to death by members of the BSF Bhurungamari Upazila, Kurigram District.^[35] The same month another Bangladesh national was killed by BSF in Sapahar Upazila, Naogaon District.^[36] In April 2016, a Bangladeshi cattle trader was shot in Kurigram District.^[37] In June 2016, two Bangladeshi smugglers were killed by the BSF in Gomostapur Upazila, Chapainawabganj.^[38] In August 2016, a Bangladeshi smuggler was shot dead in the border region in Moheshpur upazila of Jhenidah.^[39] In January 2017, a cattle smuggler was allegedly tortured to death by the BSF in Damurhuda Upazila in Chuadanga District.^[40]

Farmlands near the border

A teenager was killed and three others were injured in a shooting conducted by BSF in Chuadanga when they went to pick mangos from a tree near the border in May 2016. The BSF suspended 7 of its personnel over the incident.^[41]

Bangladeshi casualties

From 2001 to 2010, Human right organisations state that around 1,000 Bangladeshi civilians have been killed by Border Security Force (BSF).^[5][6] From 2012 to 2016, around 146 Bangladeshi civilians were killed by BSF and Indian civilians according to Bangladesh Home Minister, Asaduzzaman Khan Kamal.^[42] The Daily Star, a Bangladeshi newspaper, reports that from 2010 to 2016, on average, 40 Bangladeshi nationals were killed at the border every year.^[43]

Year	Killed	Injured	Abducted	Missing	Rape	Snatching	Push in	Other	Total	Source
1972	15								15	[44][45][46]
1973	20								20	[44][45][46]
1974	23								23	[44][45][46]
1975	11								11	[44][45][46]
1976	16								16	[44][45][46]
1977	27								27	[44][45][46]
1978	12								12	[44][45][46]
1979	22								22	[44][45][46]
1980	18								18	[44][45][46]
1981	12								12	[44][45][46]
1982	19								19	[44][45][46]
1983	16								16	[44][45][46]
1984	23								23	[44][45][46]
1985	27								27	[44][45][46]
1986	30								30	[44][45][46]
1987	17								17	[44][45][46]
1988	13								13	[44][45][46]
1989	17								17	[44][45][46]
1990	18								18	[44][45][46]
1991	15								15	[44][45][46]
1992	16								16	[44][45][46]
1993	23								23	[44][45][46]
1994	39								39	[44][45][46]
1995	36								36	[44][45][46]
1996	31								31	[44][45][46][47]
1997	33								33	[44][45][46][47]
1998	37								37	[44][45][46][47]
1999	38								38	[48][49][44][45][46][47]
2000	31	17	106	0	2	13	0	0	169	[50][51][52][47]
2001	84	29	55	0	1	10	0	0	179	[50][51][52]
2002	94	42	118	30	0	12	0	0	296	[50][51][52]
2003	27	41	120	7	2	8	0	0	205	[50][51][52]
2004	72	30	73	0	0	5	0	0	180	[50][51][52]
2005	88	53	78	14	3	4	0	0	240	[50][51][52]
2006	155	121	160	32	2	9	0	0	479	[50][51][52]
2007	118	82	92	9	3	5	198	0	507	[50][51][52]
2008	61	46	81	0	0	3	20	0	211	[50][53]
2009	98	77	25	13	1	1	90	3	308	[50][48][49][44]
2010	74	72	43	2	0	1	5	0	197	[50][48][49][44]
2011	31	62	23	0	0	0	0	9	125	[50][48][49][44]
2012	38	100	74	1	0	9	0	16	238	[50][48][49][44]
2013	29	79	127	0	1	77	41	0	354	[50][48][49][44]
2014	35	68	99	2	0	0	0	5	209	[50][48][49][44]
2015	44	60	27	1	0	0	0	0	132	[50][48][49][44]
2016	29	36	22	0	0	0	0	0	87	[50][48][49][44]
2017	25	39	28	0	0	0	0	0	92	[50][48][49][44]
2018	11	24	16	0	0	0	0	0	51	[50][48][49][44]
2019	41	40	34	0	0	0	0	0	115	[50][54]
2020	51	27	7	0	0	0	0	1	86	[50][48][49][44]
2021	17	12	0	0	1	0	0	1	31	[55]
2022	18	21	0	0	0	0	0	0	39	[56]
2023	28	28	0	0	0	0	0	0	56	[11]
Grand Total	1923	1206	1408	111	16	157	354	35	5154

Impact

The death of Bangladeshi nationals along the Bangladesh–India border has adversely affected the Bangladesh–India relations.^[29][57] The Daily Star described the issue as one that is "highly emotive" in Bangladesh.^[43] On the border death, Bangladesh Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina said it was a matter of "grave concern" to her.^[58] The border deaths have also been criticized by numerous human rights organisations.^[59]

See also

• 2001 Bangladesh–India border clashes
• Migrant deaths along the Mexico–United States border

References

1. "India: New Killings, Torture at Bangladeshi Border". Human Rights Watch. 25 July 2011. Retrieved 20 June 2016.
2. "Border Management: Dilemma of Guarding the India-Bangladesh Border". IDSA. January 2004.
3. Adams, Brad (23 January 2011). "India's shoot-to-kill policy on the Bangladesh border". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 20 June 2016.
4. "Felani, the BSF and the elusive zero target". The Daily Star. 12 January 2017. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
5. "BSF kills 1000 Bangladeshis in 10yrs". BDNews24. 13 December 2012. Retrieved 4 September 2024.
6. "'1,000 killed in a decade along Bangladesh border'". The Hindu. 10 December 2010.
7. "Bangladesh anger over India torture video". BBC News. 19 January 2012. Retrieved 4 September 2024.
8. "Indian Border Security Force (BSF) and Indian miscreants kill 607 Bangladeshis in 7 years". Odhikar. Archived from the original on 29 May 2014. Retrieved 5 December 2019.
9. Abrar, C. R. (19 August 2022). "Don't 'criminals' have the right to access justice?". The Daily Star. Retrieved 2 April 2024.
10. Ganguly, Meenakshi (9 December 2010). ""Trigger Happy"". Human Rights Watch.
11. "BANGLADESH ANNUAL HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT 2023" (PDF). Odhikar. Odhikar. 4 January 2024 [4 January, 2024]. Retrieved 2024-04-02.
12. "Felani killing: Justice denied, border killings continue". The Daily Star. 7 January 2016. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
13. "No One Killed Felani". The Daily Star. 5 July 2015. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
14. "Indian govt asked to pay Rs 5 lakh to Felani's family". The Daily Star. 31 August 2015. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
15. "One death, many questions". The Daily Star. 1 May 2011. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
16. "| BANGLADESH: Annual Human Rights Report 2023Odhikar". Retrieved 2 April 2024.
17. "Bangla border guards kill Indian; local capture BGB constable". Times of India. 21 January 2012.
18. "Bangladesh Border Guard infiltrates 10 kms into Bengal; kills two Indian nationals, drags body into Bangladesh". The Economic Times. 9 April 2015.
19. "Impact of CAA on Bangladesh: Despite Dhaka's efforts, anti-India sentiment on the rise among its citizens". First Post. 18 December 2019.
20. "Barbaric killing of BSF jawans puts India-Bangladesh relations under severe strain". India Today. 7 May 2001.
21. "Four killed in BD-India border clash". Dawn. 18 April 2005.
22. "Bangladesh troops kill Indian guard in fishing row at border". Times of India. 18 October 2019.
23. "Cattle in the way: India, Bangladesh trade smuggling charges". Times of India. 20 July 2020. BSF data indicates that 937, 1274 and 2014 BSF jawans were injured in 2017, 2018 and 2019 respectively.
24. "BGB member killed in BSF firing at Benapole border". The Business Standard. Retrieved 23 January 2024.
25. Habib, Haroon (12 May 2001). "A brush with Bangladesh". Frontline. Archived from the original on 13 June 2011. Retrieved 12 July 2009.{{cite magazine}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
26. "Bangladesh guards die in India border clash". Irish Times. 18 July 2008. Retrieved 1 October 2024.
27. "Bangladesh sees highest border deaths in 10 years". Dhaka Tribune. 22 December 2022. Retrieved 6 February 2024.
28. "2 BSF men killed in Saturday's clash with BDR, bodies handed over". BDNews24. 16 April 2005. Archived from the original on 9 December 2019. Retrieved 9 December 2019.
29. Khan, Shahedul Anam. "Clashes on our borders". The Daily Star.
30. Paul, Manash (17 April 2005). "BDR tortures, kills BSF officer". Times of India.
31. "BGB kills 2 Indians". BDNews24. 11 February 2013. Archived from the original on 9 December 2019. Retrieved 9 December 2019.
32. "BSF jawan killed in firing by Bangla border guards; BGB says action in 'self defence'". Onmanorama. Retrieved 3 May 2024.
33. "LOSS on both sides". The Daily Star. 2015-08-26. Retrieved 2017-04-17.
34. "Bangladeshi 'tortured to death' by BSF in Satkhira". The Daily Star. 2014-08-31. Retrieved 2017-04-17.
35. "BSF tortures Bangladeshi to death". The Daily Star. 2016-01-19. Retrieved 2017-04-17.
36. "BSF kills 1 at Naogaon border". The Daily Star. 2016-01-24. Retrieved 2017-04-17.
37. "Bangladeshi shot dead by BSF in Kurigram". The Daily Star. 2016-04-18. Retrieved 2017-04-17.
38. "2 Bangladeshis shot dead by BSF along C'nawabganj border". The Daily Star. 2016-06-20. Retrieved 2017-04-17.
39. "Bangladeshi shot dead by BSF in Jhenidah". The Daily Star. 2016-08-05. Retrieved 2017-04-17.
40. "Bangladeshi killed by BSF along Chuadanga border". The Daily Star. 2017-01-07. Retrieved 2017-04-17.
41. "7 BSF men suspended for killing teen". The Daily Star. 15 May 2016. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
42. "146 Bangladeshis killed by BSF, Indian civilians in past 4 yrs, says home minister". BDNews24. 25 April 2016. Archived from the original on 28 January 2021. Retrieved 9 December 2019.
43. "Killing, harbouring, kayaking and dog training". The Daily Star. 28 February 2017. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
44. "294 Bangladeshis killed by BSF along border in 10yrs: Home Minister". The Dhaka Tribune. 11 July 2019. Retrieved 30 May 2019.
45. "1,391 Bangladeshis killed by Indians". The Independent. 23 February 2017. Retrieved 8 January 2021.
46. "Border killings by BSF continued in 2017: ASK". The Daily Observer. 1 January 2018. Retrieved 23 January 2021.
47. Cover report at Shaptahik 2000, 13 January 2001.
48. "294 Bangladeshis killed by BSF in last 10yrs: Home minister". The Daily Star. 11 July 2019. Retrieved 30 May 2019.
49. "Kamal: 294 Bangladeshis killed by BSF in 10yrs". The Dhaka Tribune. 11 July 2019. Retrieved 30 May 2019.
50. "IHuman Rights Violation by Indian Border Security Force (BSF) against Bangladeshi Citizens" (PDF). Odhikar. 7 January 2021. Archived from the original (PDF) on 12 January 2021. Retrieved 10 January 2021.
51. "India-Bangladesh border killing". South Asia Journal. 3 December 2017. Retrieved 30 May 2020.
52. "Indian Border Security Force (BSF) and Indian miscreants kill 607 Bangladeshis in 7 years". Odhikar. 31 December 2006. Retrieved 30 May 2020.
53. "India says 59 killed over last six months on Bangladesh border". Reuters. 24 August 2008. Archived from the original on 26 October 2008. Retrieved 29 May 2020.
54. "Threefold rise in border killing in 2019". The Dhaka Tribune. 11 July 2019. Retrieved 30 May 2019.
55. "Human Rights Violation by Indian Border Security Force (BSF) against Bangladeshi Citizens: 2000 - 2021" (PDF). odhikar.org/. Odhikar. 20 February 2022. Retrieved 20 February 2023.
56. "ANNUAL HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT 2022 BANGLADESH" (PDF). odhikar.org/. Odhikar. 1 January 2022. Retrieved 20 February 2023.
57. "BD–India border issues". The Daily Star. 26 August 2014. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
58. "Deaths along border matter of grave concern: PM". The Daily Star. 20 December 2016. Retrieved 17 April 2017.
59. "Securing rights at the border area". The Daily Star. 3 February 2015. Retrieved 17 April 2017.