1949 VFA season

The 1949 Victorian Football Association season was the 68th season of the Australian rules football competition. The premiership was won by the Williamstown Football Club, which defeated Oakleigh by three points in the Grand Final on 1 October. It was the fifth premiership won by the club.

1949 VFA premiership season
Williamstown FC, premiers
Teams	12
Premiers	Williamstown 5th premiership
Minor premiers	Williamstown 4th minor premiership
← 1948 1950 →

During the season, the Association agreed to join the Australian National Football Council, effective from the 1950 season, ending a decade of division in Victorian football. Consequently, it was the final season in which the throw-pass was legal in the Association.

Australian National Football Council affiliation

Main article: Australian rules football schism (1938–1949)

Background

During the 1940s, unity of football control within Victoria had been a topic of regular discussion. The two football bodies in Victoria had been divided since 1938, when the Association broke away from Australian National Football Council. In the following decade, the Association had introduced a number of rule changes, most notably legalising throwing of the football in general play, while the ANFC-affiliated Victorian Football League was bound by the national rules; and, there was no player transfer agreement between the two bodies, allowing players to switch codes without a clearance.^[1][2]

By standing alone, the Association's throw-pass innovation and aggressive recruiting of League stars substantially boosted its attendances during the 1940s. However, the schism was problematic for Australian rules football as a whole: the poaching of players from one body by the other was undermining public opinion, giving other sports the opportunity to attract disenchanted fans; and, the lack of a consistent code of rules made it more difficult to spread the game to other parts of the country.^[3] The VFL, VFA and ANFC all believed that the sport would benefit from unified control in Victoria, and there were regular discussions between the VFA and VFL during the early 1940s seeking amalgamation; none were successful.^[4] In the late 1940s, the VFA began looking at obtaining a seat on the ANFC as a means of unifying football control while maintaining its independence.

1949 player transfer reciprocity agreement

No arrangement for affiliation to the ANFC was reached for the 1949 season, but in March the VFA and VFL reached a separate bilateral agreement to recognise the validity of each other's clearances, effective from the start of the 1949 season. The new agreement meant that League players were not legally permitted to play in the Association without a clearance from their League clubs, or vice versa; prior to the agreement, players who switched competitions without a clearance received a suspension which was binding only in his former competition.^[5]

By the end of the season, both the League and the Association had agreed to lift any active suspensions which players had received for switching codes without a clearance.^[6]

Affiliation with the ANFC

The Association formally agreed to affiliate with the ANFC in August 1949. Under the terms of the affiliation:^[6][7]

• The Association was to play under the ANFC's standard code of rules. This meant that it was forced to abandon the throw-pass and other rule changes it had introduced since 1938.
• The Association received a seat on the council, which had full rights except that it could not vote on council matters. According to the ANFC constitution, there could be only one voting delegate on the council from each state; Victoria's voting delegate was from the VFL, precluding the VFA from receiving a vote. However, the Association delegate had full rights to raise motions and put forward its views relating to other motions – a privilege not enjoyed by any other affiliated non-voting member of the ANFC. The lack of a vote had been the Association's major sticking point against affiliation in the past, and was the reason why an offer to affiliate in 1948 was rejected.^[8]
• The Association could send a representative team to play interstate matches or national carnivals.
• The Association could share the benefits of programs such as advertising, development programs, etc.
• The Association was not required to pay a levy to the ANFC.

The motion to affiliate was passed on 8 August 1949 by a majority of 18–7. Delegates representing Oakleigh, Williamstown and Yarraville voted against the motion.^[6] The Association remained affiliated with the ANFC until it was expelled in March 1970 for playing League players without an endorsed clearance.^[9]

Premiership

The home-and-home season was played over twenty-one matches, before the top four clubs contested a finals series under the Page–McIntyre system to determine the premiers for the season.

Ladder

1949 VFA ladder

Pos	Team	Pld	W	L	D	PF	PA	PP	Pts
1	Williamstown (P)	21	16	5	0	2037	1664	122.4	64
2	Oakleigh	21	15	6	0	2320	1703	136.2	60
3	Brighton	21	15	6	0	2116	1920	110.2	60
4	Coburg	21	13	7	1	2003	1894	105.8	54
5	Brunswick	21	12	8	1	1972	1708	115.5	50
6	Camberwell	21	12	9	0	1871	1892	98.9	48
7	Port Melbourne	21	11	10	0	1866	1780	104.8	44
8	Prahran	21	8	13	0	2111	2076	101.7	32
9	Preston	21	8	13	0	1904	2128	89.5	32
10	Northcote	21	6	14	1	1683	1948	86.4	26
11	Sandringham	21	6	14	1	1747	2225	78.5	26
12	Yarraville	21	2	19	0	1840	2532	72.7	8

Source: ^[10]
Rules for classification: 1) points; 2) percentage; 3) number of points for.
(P) Premiers

Finals

	Semifinals
Saturday, 10 September	Brighton 14.15 (99)	def.	Coburg 11.8 (74)	St Kilda Cricket Ground (crowd: 14,000)	[11]
Saturday, 17 September	Williamstown 14.13 (97)	def.	Oakleigh 13.14 (92)	St Kilda Cricket Ground (crowd: 23,000)	[12]

	Preliminary Final
Saturday, 24 September	Oakleigh 14.16 (100)	def.	Brighton 12.13 (85)	St Kilda Cricket Ground (crowd: 22,000)	[13]

	1949 VFA Grand Final
Saturday, 1 October	Williamstown	def.	Oakleigh	St Kilda Cricket Ground (crowd: 40,000)	[14][15]
	1.2 (8) 2.2 (14) 7.3 (45) 10.5 (65)	Q1 Q2 Q3 Final	2.3 (15) 5.9 (39) 6.12 (48) 8.14 (62)	Umpires: Wright
Todd 5, Walker 3, Abberton, Bernard, Molyneux		Goals	Smeaton 2, Watson 2, Edward, Finn, Scott, Wenn
Simpson (ankle), Walker (cramp)		Injuries	Baxter (thigh), Rawlings (thigh)

Awards

• The leading goalkicker for the season was Keith Warburton (Brighton), who kicked 90 goals in the home-and-home season and 101 goals overall.^[10][14]
• The J. J. Liston Trophy was won by Jack Blackman (Preston), who polled 58 votes. He narrowly beat Roy Harper (Sandringham), who was second with 56 votes.^[16]
• Port Melbourne won the seconds premiership, after defeating Williamstown in the Grand Final Replay. In the Grand Final, played as a curtain raiser to the firsts Grand Final, Williamstown 9.15 (69) had led Port Melbourne 4.8 (32) at three-quarter time, before Port Melbourne came back to draw the game at 9.17 (71) apiece.^[14] Port Melbourne 12.25 (97) defeated Williamstown 11.8 (74) in the Replay on 8 October at Olympic Park.^[17]

Notable events

• Squire Reid, who had been president of the Association since 1947,^[18] died from illness on 29 July.^[19] Former Camberwell player and president Dr Frank Hartnett was elected president of the Association in his place in August;^[20] Hartnett served as president until February 1951.^[21]
• In the final round of home-and-away matches, Sandringham 8.11 (59) trailed Camberwell 16.14 (110) by 51 points at three-quarter time, before kicking nine goals to zero to win the game by seven points, 17.17 (119) d. 16.16 (112).^[22][23]

See also

• List of VFA/VFL Premiers

References

1. Rover (16 April 1938). "Crowds will be attracted by new rules". The Argus. Melbourne. p. 22.
2. Percy Taylor (16 February 1938). "Football experiments". The Argus. Melbourne. p. 24.
3. "VFA asked to forgo "throw pass"". The Argus. Melbourne. 7 December 1948. p. 16.
4. "One football control body – VFA again to approach VFL". The Argus. Melbourne. 16 June 1945. p. 7.
5. "VFL–VFA clearances reciprocal". The Argus. Melbourne. 30 March 1949. p. 23.
6. "Association joins ANFC". The Argus. Melbourne. 9 August 1949. p. 20.
7. "Privileges but not voting power". The Argus. Melbourne. 28 June 1949. p. 16.
8. "ANFC-VFA negotiations will continue". The Argus. Melbourne. 17 February 1949. p. 20.
9. David Eastman (2013). "VFA – 1970 -1989: the post-ANFC era". Hard Ball Get. Archived from the original on 3 March 2014. Retrieved 27 February 2014.
10. Jack Oates (5 September 1949). "Brighton, Coburg will be stronger for semi-final". The Sun News-Pictorial. Melbourne. p. 24.
11. Jack Oates (12 September 1949). "Brighton crushes Coburg but needs to improve". The Sun News-Pictorial. Melbourne. p. 24.
12. Jack Oates (19 September 1949). "Williamstown, with 16 men, in great "time-on" win". The Sun News-Pictorial. Melbourne. p. 24.
13. Jack Oates (26 September 1949). "Oakleigh needs to improve for Grand Final". The Sun News-Pictorial. Melbourne. p. 24.
14. Jack Oates (3 October 1949). "Williamstown's lucky win in see-saw finish". The Sun News-Pictorial. Melbourne. p. 24.
15. Geoff Clancy (3 October 1949). "Accuracy, stamina won for W'town (sic)". The Argus. Melbourne. p. 15.
16. Jack Oates (7 September 1949). "Jack Blackman wins Liston Trophy". The Sun News-Pictorial. Melbourne. p. 28.
17. Geoff Clancy (10 October 1949). "Port takes seconds' Grand Final". The Argus. Melbourne. p. 15.
18. "Town's brilliant win over Coburg". Williamstown Chronicle. Williamstown, VIC. 5 August 1949. p. 8.
19. "Obituary: Mr S. H. Reid". The Argus. Melbourne. 30 July 1949. p. 5.
20. "Dr F. Hartnett is new VFA president". The Argus. Melbourne. 30 August 1949. p. 20.
21. Jack Dunn (20 February 1951). "Dr. Hartnett votes his V.F.A. office away". The Argus. Melbourne.
22. "1949 VFA Premiership Season". AustralianFootball.com. Retrieved 6 June 2022.
23. Brendan Rhodes (8 May 2022). "VFL Rd7: Dolphins produce a Saturday night stunner". Australian Football League. Retrieved 6 June 2022.