The 1904 College Football All-America team is composed of various organizations that chose College Football All-America Teams that season. The organizations that chose the teams included Collier's Weekly selected by Walter Camp.
Yale's Tom Shevlin was a four-time All-American
Ends
- Tom Shevlin, Yale (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; CW-1; NYS-1; NYT; NYH; PR; NYET; PNA; PI)
- Frederick A. Speik, Chicago (CW-1)
- Ralph Glaze, Dartmouth (WC-3; CW-2; NYH; NYET)
- Garfield Weede, Penn (WC-2; NYS-1; PNA-1)
- Chester T. Neal, Yale (NYS-2; NYT; PI)
- Thomas W. Hammond, Army (NYS-2; PR)
- Alexander Garfield Gillespie, Army (WC-2)
- Claude Rothgeb, Illinois (WC-3; FL)
- Russ, Brown (CW-2)
- James Bush, Wisconsin (FL)
Tackles
- James Hogan, Yale (WC-1; CW-1; NYS-1; NYH; PR; NYET; PNA-1; PI; FL)
- James Cooney, Princeton (WC-1; CW-1; NYS-1; NYT; NYH; PR; NYET; PI)
- Joe Curtis, Michigan (WC-2; FL)
- James Bloomer, Yale (CW-2; NYS-2; NYT; PNA-1; FL [sub])
- Tom Thorp, Columbia (WC-2; CW-2; NYS-2)
- Thomas Alexander Butkiewicz, Penn (WC-3)
- Thomas B. Doe, Army (WC-3)
Centers
- Arthur Tipton, Army (WC-1; CW-1; NYS-1; NYH; PR)
- Clint Roraback, Yale (WC-2; NYS-2; NYT; NYET; PNA-1; PI)
- Robert Torrey, Penn (WC-3; CW-2)
- John M. Haselwood, Illinois (FL)
Halfbacks
- Daniel Hurley, Harvard (WC-1; CW-1; NYS-1; NYT; PR; PNA-1; PI)
- Willie Heston, Michigan (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; NYET; FL)
- Lydig Hoyt, Yale (WC-3; CW-2 [fb]; NYS-1; NYH; PR)
- Jack Owsley, Yale (NYS-2)
- Marshall Reynolds, Penn (WC-2; NYS-2; NYT; PNA-1)
- W. E. Metzenthin, Columbia (NYH)
- Jack Hubbard, Amherst (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-2; CW-2)
- James Vaughn, Dartmouth (WC-3)
- W. C. Leavenworth, Yale (PI)
- Frederick A. Prince, Army (CW-2)
- Walter L. Foulke, Princeton (FL [sub])
NCAA recognized selectors for 1904
Other selectors
Bold = Consensus All-American[9]
- 1 – First-team selection
- 2 – Second-team selection
- 3 – Third-team selection
"Camp's Idea Of Football Stars: Yale Coach Puts Two Western Men in His Selection". The Daily Review (Decatur, IL). December 28, 1904.
"Camp's 1904 All America Football Team". Capital Times. November 24, 1904.
"Western Stars Are Not Named: No Eastern Paper Gives Westerner Place on All-Americans". Atlanta Constitution. December 5, 1904.
"In the Sporting World". Oshkosh Daily Northwestern. December 3, 1904.
"Football Critics Picking All-American Aggregations". Colorado Springs Weekly Gazette. December 15, 1904.
"Football Award Winners" (PDF). National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). 2016. p. 6. Retrieved October 21, 2017.