Meniscoessus

Meniscoessus is a genus of extinct multituberculates from the Upper Cretaceous Period that lived in North America.

Meniscoessus Temporal range: Late Cretaceous PreꞒ Ꞓ O S D C P T J K Pg N
Meniscoessus skull in the Rocky Mountain Dinosaur Resource Center, Woodland Park, Colorado
Scientific classification
Domain:	Eukaryota
Kingdom:	Animalia
Phylum:	Chordata
Class:	Mammalia
Order:	†Multituberculata
Family:	†Cimolomyidae
Genus:	†Meniscoessus Cope, 1882
Species
†M. collomensis †M. conquistus †M. ferox †M. intermedius †M. major †M. robustus †M. seminoensis

It is a member of the order Multituberculata, belonging to the suborder Cimolodonta and family Cimolomyidae. The multituberculates were primitive, rodent-like mammals occupying the modern rodent ecological niche. They were significant for having diverged early in mammalian evolution, co-existing with dinosaurs for ~100 million years, surviving through the Cretaceous–Paleogene extinction event and lasting until the end of the Paleogene, likely having been replaced by true rodents.^[1][2][3][4]

Meniscoessus lived during the Santonian, Campanian and Maastrichtian ages of the Upper Cretaceous. This was a period of significant diversification of multiturbiculates, and evidence that contradicts the popular misconception that mammals were unable to thrive due to being outcompeted by the dinosaurs.^[5][6][7] They are useful as index fossils for the Judithian, Edmontonian, and Lancian faunal stages.^[8] Like most early mammals, Meniscoessus fossils mainly consist of teeth. Zofia Kielan-Jaworowska and Jørn Hurum considered them to be the "best known" members of the Cimolomyidae.^[9]

Taxonomy

History

The genus Meniscoessus was named by Edward Drinker Cope in 1882.^[10] Members of this genus have been previously classified under the following genus names: Cimolomys (partly); Dipriodon ; Halodon; Oracodon; Moeniscoessus; Selenacodon (partly); and Tripriodon. As Osborn pointed out in 1891, a number of erroneous discoveries had been made as a result of analyzing different teeth of the same animal, different individuals of the same species, and violating the principle of priority due to workers ignoring previously published discoveries.^[11]

There may have been confusion with some teeth described as belonging to small carnivorous dinosaurs. ^{[citation needed]} These were further christened Dipriodon, Tripriodon, and others, including Triprotodon.^{[citation needed]} Close similarities were then noticed with an already established dinosaur genus, Paronychodon (Cope 1876), also based on teeth from the Laramie Formation. ^{[citation needed]} Over time, an impressive school of names was synonymized under P. However, this is now considered a nomen dubium.

M. robustus tooth

Species

• Meniscoessus collomensis – Named by Jason A. Lillegraven in 1987. Fossil remains were first found in Upper Cretaceous strata of the Williams Fork Formation in Colorado.^[12] It appears useful as an index fossil for the Edmontonian faunal stage.^[13][14] It weighed an estimated 0.7 kilograms (1.5 lb).^[15]
• Meniscoessus conquistus – Named by Edward Drinker Cope in 1882. Remains were found in Maastrichtian strata of Colorado and St. Mary River Formation of Canada. Cope thought it "was about the size of the Australian bandicoot." ^[16] M.conquistus is the type species of the genus Meniscoessus.^[17]

• Meniscoessus ferox – Named by Richard C. Fox in 1971. Remains were found in Campanian strata of the Upper Milk River Formation of Alberta, Canada. The holotype, collected in 1968, is in the University of Alberta collection.^[18]
• Meniscoessus intermedius – Named by Richard C. Fox in 1976. Remains were first found in Campanian and Maastrichtian strata of the Oldman Formation of Alberta and New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming.^[19] It is estimated to have weighed about 500 grams (18 oz), as much as a large rat. They are the oldest member of the genus; their first appearance in the fossil record was 86 Million Years ago, during the Santonian age.^[20]
• Meniscoessus major – Named by Loris Shano Russell in the 1930s. It is also known as Cimolomys major (Russell 1936). ^{[citation needed]} Fossils of this species have been found in Campanian and Maastrichtian aged strata, from 79-69 Million years ago. The body mass of this species is estimated at 0.5 kilograms (1.1 lb).^[21] The holotype is in Alberta.

M. robustus skull

• Meniscoessus robustus – Named by Othniel Charles Marsh in 1889. Fossils have been found from Campanian to Maastrichtian strata of Wyoming, Montana, South Dakota and Alberta. There are controversial examples from one site in Alberta that may either be late Cretaceous(Lancian faunal stage) or early Paleocene(Puercan).^[22] Marsh thought that these organisms ranged from "rat" to "squirrel" to "rabbit" in size when they had lived.^[23] The weight of this species is estimated to have been about 1.2 kilograms (2.6 lb).^[24] Marsh claimed discoveries of several new taxa in his 1889 work, but Osborn believed that many were synonymous with what is now M. robustus.^[25]
• Meniscoessus seminoensis – Named by Jaelyn J. Eberle and Jason A. Lillegraven in 1998. Remains were found in the Lancian faunal stage of the Maastrichtian strata of the Ferris Formation in Wyoming. A 3.5 centimetres (1.4 in) lower jaw fragment was found near the Seminoe Mountains, for which the species was named. It has a close resemblance to M. robustus, with the new species distinguished by its characteristic 4th premolar (P4).^[26][27] It was estimated to have a body mass of 1.5 kilograms (3.3 lb)^[28]

Several other names have been in circulation, such as Meniscoessus bustus, and Meniscoessus coelatus. The first is probably a variant of M. robustus, while the latter seems to have been connected with dinosaur teeth. ^{[citation needed]}

Notes

1. Weil
2. Prothero, 2006, pp 55-61, 157
3. Benton 2015, pp 330,337-338
4. Wilson et al, 2012
5. Benton, 2015, pg 338
6. Carroll, 1988, pg 419
7. Wilson et al, 2012, pg 459
8. Cifelli et al, 2004
9. Kielan-Jaworowska and Hurum, 2001, pg 408
10. Cope, 1882, pg 830
11. Osborn, 1891, pg 597-598
12. Lillegraven, 1987
13. Wilson et al, 2010, pg 499
14. Cifelli et al, 2004, pg 28 and Table 2.2
15. Wilson et al, 2012, Supplemental Table 5
16. Cope, 1882, pg 831
17. Paleobiology Database, Meniscoessus
18. Fox, 1971
19. Fox, 1976
20. Wilson et al, 2012, Supplemental Table 5
21. Wilson et al, 2012, Supplemental Table 5
22. Cifelli et al 2004, pp 35-36: discussion of dispute
23. Marsh 1889, pp 85-89
24. Wilson et al, 2012, Supplemental Table 5
25. Osborn, 1891, pg 607
26. Eberle and Lillegraven, 1998, pp. 33-35
27. Carroll, 1988, 417-418: Carroll notes that the premolars and specialized dentition in multituberculates are particularly significant
28. Wilson et al, 2012, Supplemental Table 5

References

• "Meniscoessus". The Paleobiology Database. Retrieved 18 January 2024.
• Benton, Michael J. (2015). Vertebrate Palaeontology, 4th Edition. Wiley Blackwell. ISBN 9781118406847.
• Carroll, Robert I. (1988). Vertebrate Paleontology and Evolution. W.H.Freeman and Company. ISBN 0-716-71822-7.

• Cifelli, Richard; Eberle, Jaelyn; Lofgren, Donald; Lillegraven, J.; Clemens, William (2004). "Mammalian Biochronology of the Latest Cretaceous in North America". Retrieved 20 January 2024.

• Cope, E.D. (1882). "Mammalia in the Laramie Formation". American Naturalist. 16 (10): 830–831.

• Dykes, Trevor. "Mesozoic Mammals; 'basal' Cimolodonta, Cimolomyidae, Boffiidae and Kogaionidae, an internet directory". Archived from the original on 17 December 2012. Retrieved 18 January 2024.

• Eberle, J.J.; Lillegraven, J.A. (1998). "A new important record of earliest Cenozoic mammalian history: geologic setting, Multituberculata, and Peradectia". Rocky Mountain Geology. 33 (1): 3–47.

• Fox, R.C. (1971). "Early Campanian multituberculates (Mammalia: Allotheria) from the upper Milk River Formation, Alberta". Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences. 8 (9): 916–938.

• Fox, R.C. (1976). "Cretaceous mammals (Meniscoessus intermedius, new species, and Alphadon sp.) from the lowermost Oldman Formation, Alberta". Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences. 13 (9): 1216–1222.

• Kielan-Jaworowska, Zofia; Hurum, J.H. (2001). "Phylogeny and Systematics of Multituberculate Mammals". Palaeontology. 44 (3): 389–429. doi:10.1111/1475-4983.00185.
• Lillegraven, J.A. (1987). "Stratigraphy and evolutionary implications of a new species of Meniscoessus (Multituberculata, Mammalia) from the Upper Cretaceous Williams Fork Formation, Moffat County, Colorado". Dakoterra. 3: 46–56.
• Marsh, O.C. (1889). "Discovery of Cretaceous Mammalia". American Journal of Science. s3-38 (223): 81–92. doi:10.2475/ajs.s3-38.223.81.

• Osborn, Henry Fairfield (1891). "A Review of the "Discovery of Cretaceous Mammalia"". The American Naturalist. 25 (295): 595–611.

• Prothero, Donald (2006). After the Dinosaurs: The Age of Mammals. Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana University Press. ISBN 0-253-34733-5.
• Weil, Anne. "Introduction to Multituberculates". University of California, Museum of Paleontology. Retrieved 18 January 2024.
• Wilson, Gregory P.; Deschene, Marieke; Anderson, Ingrid R. (2010). "New Latest Cretaceous Mammals From Northeastern Colorado With Biochronologic and Biogeographic Implications". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 30 (2): 499–520. doi:10.1080/02724631003620955.
• Wilson, Gregory P.; Evans, Alistair R.; Corfe, Ian J.; Smits, Peter D.; Fortelius, Mikael; Jernvall, Jukka (2012). "Adaptive radiation of multituberculate mammals before the extinction of dinosaurs". Nature. 483: 457–460. doi:10.1038/nature10880.