Dungan language

"Hui language" redirects here. Not to be confused with Huizhou Chinese or Tongan language.

Dungan (/ˈdʊŋɡɑːn/ or /ˈdʌŋɡən/) is a Sinitic language^[2] spoken primarily in the Chu Valley of southeastern Kazakhstan and northern Kyrgyzstan. It is the native language of the Dungan people, a Hui subgroup that fled Qing China in the 19th century. It evolved from the Central Plains Mandarin variety spoken in Gansu and Shaanxi. It is the only Sino-Tibetan language to be officially written in the Cyrillic script. In addition, the Dungan language contains loanwords and archaisms not found in other modern varieties of Mandarin.

Dungan
Хуэйзў йүян 回族語言 خُوِزُو یُوِیًا
Pronunciation	[xwɛ̌jt͡sû ʝŷʝɛ̃̌]
Native to	Central Asia
Region	Chu Valley (Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan), Altai Krai, Saratov Oblast (Rovensky District) (Russia), Fergana Valley (Uzbekistan)
Ethnicity	Dungan
Native speakers	110,000 (2009 censuses)[1]
Language family	Sino-Tibetan Sinitic Chinese Mandarin Central Plains Mandarin Dungan
Writing system	Cyrillic (official) Chinese characters (obsolete) Xiao'erjing (obsolete) Latin (historical)
Language codes
ISO 639-3	dng
Glottolog	dung1253
ELP	Dungan
This article contains IPA phonetic symbols. Without proper rendering support, you may see question marks, boxes, or other symbols instead of Unicode characters. For an introductory guide on IPA symbols, see Help:IPA.

Dungan language
Chinese name
Traditional Chinese	東干語
Simplified Chinese	东干语
Transcriptions Standard Mandarin Hanyu Pinyin Dōnggānyǔ Wade–Giles Tung1kan1 yü3 IPA [tʊ́ŋ.kán ỳ] other Mandarin Xiao'erjing دْوقًا يُوِ
Dunganese name
Dungan	Хуэйзў йүян
Xiao'erjing	خُوِزُو یُوِیًا
Hanzi	回族語言 (Huízú yǔyán; Hui2-tsu2 yü3-yen2)
Russian name
Russian	Дунганский язык
Romanization	Dunganskij jazyk
Kyrgyz name
Kyrgyz	Дунган тили دۇنعان تىلى Dungan tili
Kazakh name
Kazakh	Дүнген тілі دۇنگەن تىلى Düngen tılı

History

The Dungan people of Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan (with smaller groups living in other post-Soviet states) are the descendants of several groups of the Hui people that migrated to the region in the 1870s and the 1880s after the defeat of the Dungan revolt in Northwestern China. The Hui of Northwestern China (often referred to as "Dungans" or "Tungani" by 19th-century western writers, as well as by some Turkic peoples) would normally speak the same Mandarin dialect as the Han people in the same area^[3] (or in the area from which the particular Hui community had been resettled). At the same time, due to their unique history, their speech would be rich in Islamic or Islam-influenced terminology, based on loanwords from Arabic, Persian and Turkic languages, as well as translations of them into Chinese.^[3] The Hui traders in the bazaars would be able to use Arabic or Persian numbers when talking between themselves, to keep their communications secret from Han bystanders.^[4] While not constituting a separate language, these words, phrases and turns of speech, known as Huihui hua (回回話, "Hui speech"), served as markers of group identity.^[3] As early 20th century travellers in Northwestern China would note, "the Mohammedan Chinese have to some extent a vocabulary and always a style and manner of speech, all their own".^[5]

As the Dungans in the Russian Empire — and even more so in the Soviet Union — were isolated from China, their language experienced significant influence from the Russian and the Turkic languages of their neighbors.

In the Soviet Union, a written standard of the Dungan language was developed, based on a dialect of the Gansu Province, rather than the Beijing base of Standard Chinese. The language was used in the schools in Dungan villages. In the Soviet time there were several school textbooks published for studying the Dungan language, a three volume Russian–Dungan dictionary (14,000 words), the Dungan–Russian dictionary, linguistics monographs on the language and books in Dungan. The first Dungan-language newspaper was established in 1932; it continues publication today in weekly form.

When Dru C. Gladney, who had spent some years working with the Hui people in China, met with Dungans in Almaty in 1988, he described the experience as speaking "in a hybrid Gansu dialect that combined Turkish and Russian lexical items".^[6]

Mutual intelligibility with Mandarin dialects

There is a varying degree of mutual intelligibility between Dungan and various Mandarin dialects. The Central Plains Mandarin varieties and Jin Chinese are both understood by Dungans. On the other hand, Dungan speakers like Iasyr Shivaza and others have reported that people who speak the Beijing Mandarin dialect can understand Dungan, but Dungans could not understand Beijing Mandarin.^[7]

Demographics

Dungan is spoken primarily in Kyrgyzstan, with speakers in Russia, Kazakhstan and Uzbekistan as well. The Dungan ethnic group are the descendants of refugees from China who migrated west into Central Asia.

According to the Soviet census statistics from 1970 to 1989, the Dungan maintained the use of their ethnic language much more successfully than other minority ethnic groups in Central Asia; however, in the post-Soviet period, the proportion of Dungans speaking the Dungan language as their native language appears to have fallen sharply.

Dungan speakers by population

Year	Dungan L1	Russian L2	Total Dungan population	Source
1970	36,445 (94.3%)	18,566 (48.0%)	38,644	Soviet census
1979	49,020 (94.8%)	32,429 (62.7%)	51,694	Soviet census
1989	65,698 (94.8%)	49,075 (70.8%)	69,323	Soviet census
2001	41,400 (41.4%)	N/A	100,000	Ethnologue

Grammar

Classifiers

Further information: Chinese classifier

Chinese varieties usually have different classifiers for different types of nouns, with northern varieties tending to have fewer classifiers than southern ones. 個 ([kə]) is the only classifier found in the Dungan language, though not the only measure word.^[8]

Phonology

In basic structure and vocabulary, the Dungan language is not very different from Mandarin Chinese, specifically a variety of Zhongyuan Mandarin (not Lan-Yin Mandarin) spoken in the southern part of the province of Gansu and the western part of the valley of Guanzhong in the province of Shaanxi. Like other Chinese varieties, Dungan is tonal. There are two main dialects, one with 4 tones and the other, considered standard, with 3 tones in the final position in phonetic words and 4 tones in the nonfinal position.

Consonants

Consonant phonemes of Dungan

		Labial	Alveolar	Retroflex	(Alveolo-) palatal	Velar
Nasal		m	n			ŋ
Stop	voiceless	p	t			k
	aspirated	pʰ	tʰ			kʰ
Affricate	voiceless		t͡s	ʈ͡ʂ	t͡ɕ
	aspirated		t͡sʰ	ʈ͡ʂʰ	t͡ɕʰ
Fricative	voiceless	f	s	ʂ	ɕ	x
	voiced	v		ʐ	ʝ
Approximant			l	ɻ

Consonant table with orthography

Unaspirated					Aspirated					Nasal					Fricative					Voiced
Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA		Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA		Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA		Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA		Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA
б	b	b	[p]		п	p	p	[pʰ]		м	m	m	[m]		ф	f	f	[f]		в	v	w	[v], [w]
д	d	d	[t]		т	t	t	[tʰ]		н	n	n	[n]							л	l	l	[l]
з	z	z	[t͡s]		ц	c	c	[t͡sʰ]							с	s	s	[s]		р	r	r	[ɻ]
җ	j	zh	[t͡ʂ]		ч	ch	ch	[t͡ʂʰ]							ш	sh	sh	[ʂ]		ж			[ʐ]
		j	[t͡ɕ]				q	[t͡ɕʰ]							щ		x	[ɕ]		й	y	y	[ʝ]
г	g	g	[k]		к	k	k	[kʰ]		ң	ng	ng	[ŋ]		х	h	h	[x]

• /ŋ/ can also be heard as a voiced fricative [ɣ] among other Gansw dialects.
• /v/ can be heard as [w] in the Şanşi dialects.

Vowels

Medial	Nucleus
	∅	a	ɤ	ɛ	ɔ	ʊ	əj	∅̃	æ̃	ɔ̃	ʊ̃	ɚ
∅	ɨ	a	ɤ	ɛ	ɔ	ʊ	əj	ə̃	æ̃	ɔ̃	ʊ̃	ɚ
j	i	ja	je		jɔ	jɤw		ĩ	jɛ̃	jɔ̃
w	u	wa	wɤ	wɛ	wɔ	u	wəj, wɛj		wæ̃	wɔ̃	ũ
ɥ	y	ɥa	ɥe					ỹ	yɛ̃

Vowel table

Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA		Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA		Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA		Cyrillic	Latin	Pinyin	IPA
ы	î	i	[ɨ]		и	i	i	[i], [ɪi]		ў	û	u	[u], [ɤu]		ү	ü	ü, u	[y]
а	a	a	[a]		я	ia (ya)	ia (ya)	[ja]		уа	ua	ua	[wa]		үa	üa	üa	[ɥa]
ә	ê	e	[ɤ]		е	ie (ye)	ie (ye)	[je]		уә	uê	ue	[wɤ]		үә	üe	üe	[ɥe]
э	e	ê, ai	[ɛ]							уэ	ue	uai	[wɛ]
о	o	ao	[ɔ]		ё	io (yo)	iao (yao)	[jɔ]		уэй	uei	ui	[wɛj]
ый	îi	ei	[əj]							уй	ui	wei	[wəj]
у	u	ou	[ʊ]		ю	iu (yu)	iu (you)	[jɤw]		уо	uo	uo	[wɔ]
ан	an	an	[æ̃]		ян	ian (yan)	ian (yan)	[jɛ̃]		уан	uan	uan	[wæ̃]		үан	üan	(j/q/x/y)üan	[yɛ̃]
он	on	ang	[ɔ̃]		ён	ion (yon)	iang (yang)	[jɔ̃]		уон	uon	uang	[wɔ̃]
ын	în	eng, en	[ə̃~ɤ̃]		ин	in	ing, in	[ĩ], [ɪĩ]		ун	un	ong	[ʊ̃], [ʊə̃]		үн	ün	iong, ün	[ỹ]
эр	er	er	[ɚ~əɻ]							ўн	ûn	ung	[ũ]

• /ə˞/ can be heard as [ɯ˞] in Kyrgyzstan.

Vowel constructs that can be used as independent syllable without consonants are shown in parentheses. There are rhotacised vowels, as well as some syllables only seen in loan words from Russian, Arabic, Kyrgyz, etc., in addition to the above table.

Tones

Tones in Dungan are marked with nothing (tone 1), a ъ (tone 2) and ь (tone 3).^[9]

Tonal comparison between Dungan and Mandarin

Standard Chinese tone number	Dungan tone number	Tone name	Dungan example		Chinese character		Gansu-Dungan		Shaanxi-Dungan		Standard Chinese		References
			Orthography	IPA	Orthography	IPA	Pitch pattern	Tone contour	Pitch pattern	Tone contour	Pitch pattern	Tone contour
1	1	陰平 (yīnpíng)	хуа	/xwǎ/	花	/xwá/	Rising	˨˦ (24)	Falling	˥˩ (51)	High	˥ (55)	Standard Gansu-Dungan doesn't distinguish tone 1 and tone 2 only in the final position of phonetic words.
2		陽平 (yángpíng)	хуа	/xwǎ/	華	/xwǎ/			Rising	˨˦ (24)	Rising	˧˥ (35)
3	2	上聲 (shǎngshēng)	вə(ъ)	/vɤ̂/	我	/wò/	Falling	˥˩ (51)	Falling	˥˧ (53)	Low/dipping	˩, ˨˩˦ (1, 214)
4	3	去聲 (qùshēng)	чў(ь)	/t͡ɕú/	去	/t͡ɕŷ/	High	˦ (44)	High	˦ (44)	Falling	˥˨ (52)	Some syllables originating in tone 4 fall into tone 1 in modern Mandarin.
0	0	輕聲 (qīngshēng)	зы	/t͡sɨ/	子	/t͡sɹ̩/	Short	Varies	Short	Varies	Short	Varies	Actual pitch depends on the preceding syllable.

Vocabulary

The basilects of Gansu/Shaanxi Mandarin and Dungan are largely mutually intelligible; Chinese journalists conversant in one of those Mandarin dialects report that they can make themselves understood when communicating with Dungan speakers. However, even at the level of basic vocabulary, Dungan contains many words not present in modern Mandarin dialects, such as Russian, Arabic, Turkic, and Persian loanwords. Furthermore, Dungan contains some archaic Qing dynasty-era Chinese vocabulary. Because of this, some Dungan vocabulary may sound old-fashioned to Chinese people. For example, they refer to a President as an "Emperor" (Хуаңды/皇帝, huan'g-di) and call government offices yamen (ямын/衙門, ya-min), a term for mandarins' offices in ancient China.^[10]

Furthermore, the acrolects of Dungan and Gansu/Shaanxi Mandarin have diverged significantly due to time and cultural influences. During the 20th century, translators and intellectuals introduced many neologisms and calques into the Chinese language, especially for political and technical concepts. However, the Dungan, cut off from the mainstream of Chinese discourse by orthographic barriers, instead borrowed words for those same concepts from Russian, with which they came into contact through government and higher education. As a result of these borrowings, the equivalent standard Chinese terms are not widely known or understood among the Dungan.^[11]

Writing system

Main article: Dungan alphabets

The modern Dungan language is the only Chinese language that is written in the Cyrillic alphabet, as they lived under Soviet rule. It is a Russian-based alphabet plus five additional letters: Ә, Җ, Ң, Ү and Ў. As such, it differs from the Palladius System that is normally used in Russia to render Chinese in Cyrillic.

Books in Dungan or about Dungan (in Russian or English). Most of them were published in Frunze, Kirghiz SSR in the 1970s and 80s

Bilingual sign in Dungan and Russian respectively, at the home of Soviet war hero Mansuz Vanakhun [ru]

Modern Dungan alphabet and letter pronunciations

Cyrillic	А/а	Б/б	В/в	Г/г	Д/д	Е/е	Ё/ё	Ә/ә	Ж/ж	Җ/җ	З/з	И/и	Й/й	К/к
Name	a	бэ	вэ	гэ	дэ	e	ё	ә	жэ	җe	зэ	и	йи	кa
IPA	[a]	[pɛ]	[vɛ]	[kɛ]	[tɛ]	[je]	[jɔ]	[ɤ]	[ʐɛ]	[t͡ɕʲe]	[t͡sɛ]	[i]	[ʝi]	[kʰa]
Latin	a	be	ve	ge	de	ye	yo	ê	re	jie	ze	i	yi	ka
Cyrillic	Л/л	М/м	Н/н	Ң/ң	О/о	П/п	Р/р	С/с	Т/т	У/у	Ў/ў	Ү/ү	Ф/ф	Х/х
Name	эль	эм	эн	ың	o	пэ	эр	эc	тэ	у	ў	ү	эф	xa
IPA	[ɛlʲ]	[ɛm]	[ɛn]	[ɨŋ]	[ɔ]	[pʰɛ]	[əɻ]	[ɛs]	[tʰɛ]	[ʊw]	[u]	[y]	[ɛf]	[xa]
Latin	el	em	en	îng	o	pe	er	es	te	u	û	ü	ef	ha
Cyrillic	Ц/ц	Ч/ч	Ш/ш	Щ/щ	Ъ/ъ	Ы/ы	Ь/ь	Э/э	Ю/ю	Я/я
Name	цэ	чэ	шa	щa	нин xo	ы	ван xo	э	ю	йa
IPA	[t͡sʰɛ]	[t͡ʂʰɛ]	[ʂa]	[ɕa]	[nʲɪ̃ xɔ]	[ɨ]	[vã xɔ]	[ɛ]	[jʊw]	[ja]
Latin	ce	che	sha	sh(i)a	nin ho	î	van ho	e	yu	ya

• The letters ъ and ь are only used to write Russian loanwords and tone markings on children's primers dictionaries^[9]

Dungan is unique in that it is one of the few varieties of Chinese that is not normally written using Chinese characters. Though it may be seen written in Chinese characters, this writing system is now considered obsolete. Originally, the Dungan, as descendants of the Hui, wrote their language in an Arabic-based alphabet known as Xiao'erjing. The Soviet Union banned all Arabic scripts in 1925,^[12] which led to a Latin orthography based on Yañalif. The Latin orthography lasted until 1940, when the Soviet government promulgated the current Cyrillic-based system. Xiao'erjing is now virtually extinct in Dungan society, but it remains in limited use by some Hui communities in China.

The writing system is based on the standard 3-tone dialect. Tone marks or numbering do not appear in general-purpose writing, but are specified in dictionaries, even for loanwords. The tones are specified using the soft sign, hard sign, or none.

Comparison with Palladius system

Pinyin	Palladiy	Dungan		Pinyin	Palladiy	Dungan		Pinyin	Palladiy	Dungan		Pinyin	Palladiy	Dungan
b	б	б		p	п	п		m	м	м		f	ф	ф
d	д	д		t	т	т		n	н	н / л		l	л	л
z	цз	з		c	ц	ц		s	с	с
j	цз(ь)	җ(ь)		q	ц(ь)	ч(ь)		x	с(ь)	щ(ь)
zh	чж	җ		ch	ч	ч		sh	ш	ш / с / ф		r	ж	ж
g	г	г		k	к	к						h	х	х

Literature

A number of books in the Dungan language, which includes textbooks, Dungan-Russian and Russian-Dungan dictionaries, a Dungan etymological dictionary, collections of folk tales, original and translated fiction, and poetry have been published in Kyrgyzstan. Usual print runs were no more than a few hundred copies. A newspaper in Dungan has been published as well.

Many literary works of Dungan poet Iasyr Shivaza have been translated into Russian, Standard Chinese and a number of other languages, with print runs in some of them been much higher than in the original Dungan. English translations of some of them, along with the original Dungan text, are available in the book by S. Rimsky-Korsakoff (1991).

See also

• Cyrillization of Chinese

References

Citations

1. Dungan at Ethnologue (18th ed., 2015) (subscription required)
2. "Dungan".
3. Dru C. Gladney, Muslim Chinese: Ethnic Nationalism in the People's Republic. 1st ed.: Harvard University Press, 1991, ISBN 0-674-59495-9; 2nd ed., 1996. ISBN 0-674-59497-5. Pages 393-394 in the 1991 edition. The following pages in this book, 321–395, are occupied by "A Select Glossary of Hui Chinese Islamic Terms", into which Gladney included only words (many found in older publications) that he could verify as known or recognized by people in at least some Hui communities he visited.
4. Gladney (1991), p. 68
5. Owen Lattimore, The Desert Road to Turkestan. London, Methuen & Co, ca. 1928–1929. Page 196.
6. Gladney, pp 33, 102
7. Rimsky-Korsakoff Dyer, Svetlana (1977). "Soviet Dungan nationalism: a few comments on their origin and language". Monumenta Serica. 33: 349–362. doi:10.1080/02549948.1977.11745054. p. 351.
8. Yue, Anne O. (2003). "Chinese dialects: grammar". In Thurgood, Graham; LaPolla, Randy J. (eds.). The Sino-Tibetan languages. Routledge. pp. 84–125. ISBN 978-0-7007-1129-1.
9. "Dungan language, alphabet and pronunciation". www.omniglot.com. Retrieved 2019-11-18.
10. "The "Shaanxi Village" in Kazakhstan". China Radio International - CRIENGLISH.com. 2004-07-09. Archived from the original on 2006-04-24.
11. Mair, Victor (May 1990). "Implications of the Soviet Dungan Script for Chinese Language Reform". Sino-Platonic Papers (18).
12. Dietrich, Ayşe. "Soviet and Post-soviet Language Policies in The Central Asian Republics and The Status of Russian". ayk.gov.tr. S2CID 173988643.

Sources

General references

• Rimsky-Korsakoff, Svetlana (1967). "Soviet Dungan: The Chinese language of Central Asia: alphabet, phonology, morphology". Monumenta Serica. 26: 352–421. doi:10.1080/02549948.1967.11744973. JSTOR 40725857.
• Svetlana Rimsky-Korsakoff Dyer, Iasyr Shivaza: The Life and Works of a Soviet Dungan Poet. 1991. ISBN 3-631-43963-6. (Contains a detailed bibliography and ample samples of Shivaza works', some in the original Cyrillic Dungan, although most in a specialized transcription, with English and sometimes standard Chinese translations).
• Olga I. Zavjalova. "Some Phonological Aspects of the Dungan Dialects." Computational Analyses of Asian and African Languages. Tokyo, 1978. No. 9. Pp. 1–24. (Contains an experimental analysis of Dungan tones).
• Olga Zavyalova. “Dungan Language.” Encyclopedia of Chinese Language and Linguistics. General Editor Rint Sybesma. Vol. 2. Leiden–Boston: Brill, 2017. pp. 141–148.
• Hai Feng (海峰). 《中亚东干语言研究》 (Zhongya Donggan yuyan yanjiu—A Study of the Dungan Language of Central Asia.) Urumchi, 2003. ISBN 7-5631-1789-X. (Description of the Dungan language by a professor of Xinjiang University).
• Salmi, Olli (2018). Dungan–English Dictionary. Manchester, England: Eastbridge Books. ISBN 978-1-78869-154-3.

External links

• "Implications of the Soviet Dungan Script for Chinese Language Reform": long essay on Dungan, with sample texts
• Dungan writing system in Omniglot
• The Shaanxi Village in Kazakhstan
• Soviet census data for mother tongue and second language, in English
• Central Asian Dungan as a Chinese Dialect