Ikhtilaf

Ikhtilāf (Arabic: اختلاف, lit. 'disagreement, difference') is an Islamic scholarly religious disagreement, and is hence the opposite of ijma.

Direction in Quran

According to Verse of Obedience, disagreements about any religious matter are to be arbitrated by referring to the Quran and Sunnah to dismiss ikhtilaf and to avoid taqlid.^[1][2][3] While those in authority are absent from arbitration in that verse, they are mentioned in verse 4:83, which includes the passage, "And whenever tidings come unto them, whether of security or fear, they spread it about, whereas had they referred it to the Messenger and to those in authority among them, those of them whose task it is to investigate would have known it."^[4] This argument has been attributed to Muhammad al-Baqir (d. c. 114/732),^[5] which also appears in al-Jami' li-ahkam al-Quran by the Sunni al-Qurtubi (d. 671/1272).^[4]

Hadith

The hadith of Muhammad which states that "Allah will ensure my ummah will never collude en-masse upon error"^[6] have been mentioned in the books of Tirmidhi, Ibn Majah, Musnah Ahmad, and Darimi. This is often quoted as the primary proof of Ijma as well as rejection of ikhtilaf from the Hadith from the Sunni View.

Some Islamic scholars teach that when there is a scholarly disagreement on a certain issue, it is impermissible to condemn a person who follows a position that is different from one's own. The requirement to command the right and forbid the wrong does not apply when there is ikhtilaf upon a position.

However there is doubt as to the authenticity of this statement as to whether it truly came from Muhammad or not. People often quote this statement as a hadith, but it is not mentioned in the six authentic collections of hadith and its chain of narrators is also not known. There are various versions of this statement. In some versions it is rendered: "The difference of opinions among my Companions is a mercy for you"; alternately, it is rendered as: "The difference of opinions of my Companions is a mercy for my Ummah". Many scholars of hadith consider both of these versions as weak or da'if as far as their narration is concerned.^[7]

Jurisprudence

The term ikhtilāf al-fuqahā or ikhtilāf al-fiqh, meaning "disagreement of the jurists", refers to the differences of opinions among early Islamic jurists and especially to the genre of works compiling and comparing conflicting opinions. Such compilations were usually organized topically and might contrast different schools of fiqh or differences within a given school. Ikhtilāf al-fuqahā is the title of a work by al-Ṭabarī.^[8]

See also

• Ijma
• Adiaphora
• Bid‘ah
• Ghulat
• Uli al-amr
• Seventy-three Sects (Hadith)

References

1. Ad-Dahlawi, Waliyullah; Achmad, Bahrudin (19 May 2022). HISTORIOGRAFI IKHTILAF DALAM ISLAM: Al-Inshof fi Bayani Asbabil Ikhtilaf (in Indonesian). Almuqsith Pustaka. pp. 176–178. Retrieved 3 December 2022.
2. M.S.I, Ahmad Musadad, S. H. I. (26 October 2017). MUQARANAH MADZAHIB (in Indonesian). Duta Media Publishing. pp. 117, 118. ISBN 978-602-6546-29-6. Retrieved 3 December 2022.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)^{[permanent dead link‍]}
3. Syirazi, Dr Abdul Karim Biazar (1 January 2015). Menuju Persatuan Islam: Pandangan Ulama Internasional (in Indonesian). Nur alhuda. p. 110. ISBN 978-602-306-015-3. Retrieved 3 December 2022.
4. Nasr et al. 2015, p. 533.
5. Lalani 2000, pp. 63–4.
6. Narrated by al-Tirmidhi (4:2167), ibn Majah (2:1303), Abu Dawood, and others with slightly different wordings.
7. al-Suyuti al-Jami al-Saghir Ibn al-Hajib Mukhtasar
8. John L. Esposito (ed.), The Oxford Dictionary of Islam (Oxford University Press, 2003), s.v. "Ikhtilaf al-Fiqh".

Works cited

• Nasr, S.H.; Dagli, C.K.; Dakake, M.M.; Lumbard, J.E.B.; Rustom, M., eds. (2015). The Study Quran: A New Translation and Commentary. Harper Collins. ISBN 9780062227621.
• Lalani, Arzina R. (2000). Early Shi'i Thought: The Teachings of Imam Muhammad al-Baqir. I. B. Tauris. ISBN 978-1860644344.