Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
Legendarium? | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Legendarium? |
Finnish translation | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Finnish translation |
Preview of Sequel | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Preview of Sequel |
Merge minor dwarves? | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Merge minor dwarves? |
Differences in tone: TH and LotR | 6 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Differences in tone: TH and LotR |
Beowulf | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Beowulf |
Influences & Adaptations | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Influences & Adaptations |
Influences through Beowulf | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Influences through Beowulf |
Film | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Film |
Peter Jackson version? | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Peter Jackson version? |
Image | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Image 2 |
Continuity error(s) | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Continuity error(s) |
Explicit differences and inconsistencies | 5 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Explicit differences and inconsistencies |
Reverend Mother? | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Reverend Mother? |
Recent Edits | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Recent Edits |
Differences | 4 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Differences |
ISBN | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#ISBN |
Story of the inspiration | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Story of the inspiration |
Differences : Original Research & Attribution | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Differences : Original Research & Attribution |
not sure if anyone is aware of its existance ... | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#not sure if anyone is aware of its existance ... |
Earlier planned German translation 1938 | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Earlier planned German translation 1938 |
Smaug's metal wings? | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Smaug's metal wings? |
History of Middle-earth reference | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#History of Middle-earth reference |
Accents | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Accents |
The Hobbit is a children's book | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#The Hobbit is a children's book |
Fair use rationale for Image:The hobbit ced.jpg | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Fair use rationale for Image:The hobbit ced.jpg |
Fair use rationale for Image:TheHobbit FirstEdition.jpg | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Fair use rationale for Image:TheHobbit FirstEdition.jpg |
Merge of The Hobbit (2009 film) | 7 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Merge of The Hobbit (2009 film) |
Archive 1 | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Archive 1 |
The Hobbit#editions copyvio | 15 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#The Hobbit#editions copyvio |
Overhaul | 10 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Overhaul |
Animals/Creatures Talking? | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Animals/Creatures Talking? |
copyedit | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#copyedit |
plot summary | 16 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#plot summary |
Introduction | 4 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Introduction |
Style and Themes | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Style and Themes |
Concept and creation section | 6 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Concept and creation section |
section | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#section |
How it was published | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#How it was published |
Riddles in the Dark differences | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Riddles in the Dark differences |
Film | 6 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Film 2 |
Criticism | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Criticism |
what about led zepplin? | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#what about led zepplin? |
Citations | 8 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Citations |
Adaptations | 4 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Adaptations |
Influence | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Influence |
Major Themes | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Major Themes |
Huge Gap | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Huge Gap |
Changes by Strebe | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#Changes by Strebe |
characters | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#characters |
John Bauwens? | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 1#John Bauwens? |
"Children's fantasy" and genre | 5 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#"Children's fantasy" and genre |
RFC: Is classifying the Hobbit as primarily a "children's fantasy" appropriate? | 18 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#RFC: Is classifying the Hobbit as primarily a "children's fantasy" appropriate? |
'Commentary' editions | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#'Commentary' editions |
Why a GA nom? | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Why a GA nom? |
GA Review | 44 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#GA Review |
Dust jacket art | 5 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Dust jacket art |
Del Toro Quote | 6 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Del Toro Quote |
Sources needed! | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Sources needed! |
Bias | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Bias |
Does Peter Jackson Have any Film Plans for "The Hobbit"? | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Does Peter Jackson Have any Film Plans for "The Hobbit"? |
List of editions | 4 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#List of editions |
Award-winning | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Award-winning |
Lead | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Lead |
J.R.R.Tolkien | 14 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#J.R.R.Tolkien |
Usage of the word "evil" | 20 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Usage of the word "evil" |
Title | 7 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Title |
Educational assignment | 15 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Educational assignment |
Titular Protagonist | 18 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Titular Protagonist |
setting the Scene/stage | 5 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#setting the Scene/stage |
Russian adaptations | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#Russian adaptations |
2012-2013 Films? | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 2#2012-2013 Films? |
Would a dwarf of that importance really be traveling alone? | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Would a dwarf of that importance really be traveling alone? |
Genre | 12 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Genre |
Highbeam Research | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Highbeam Research |
Should the article have a redirection with Saint George? | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Should the article have a redirection with Saint George? |
Author could have given more information on Bag End | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Author could have given more information on Bag End |
Hobbit Article Grammar | 10 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Hobbit Article Grammar |
Plot section references | 10 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Plot section references |
Names of the dwarves, and new article for criticism characters? | 21 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Names of the dwarves, and new article for criticism characters? |
Proposal: Add the twelve names of the dwarves to the article | 35 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Proposal: Add the twelve names of the dwarves to the article |
Vandalism alert | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Vandalism alert |
Never out of print claim | 9 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Never out of print claim |
Taking note of the upcoming movie release in the lede | 13 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Taking note of the upcoming movie release in the lede |
Background Section | 22 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Background Section |
Demonstrating consensus among Tolkien scholars. | 40 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#Demonstrating consensus among Tolkien scholars. |
Reference Check | 20 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 3#Reference Check |
"Largely a sustained exploration of evil"? | 4 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#"Largely a sustained exploration of evil"? |
copied section | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#copied section |
Joanna Russ' play of "The Hobbit" | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#Joanna Russ' play of "The Hobbit" |
"The name of the wizard Radagast is widely recognized..." | 8 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#"The name of the wizard Radagast is widely recognized..." |
Copy Editing | 4 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#Copy Editing |
Synopsis detail | 15 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#Synopsis detail |
Bewilderland | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#Bewilderland |
"Altogether it was a very slow business following the track" | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#"Altogether it was a very slow business following the track" |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#External links modified |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#External links modified 2 |
Should the Brief or Descriptive version of the plot be used? | 4 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#Should the Brief or Descriptive version of the plot be used? |
"Warg" or "warg"? | 16 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#"Warg" or "warg"? |
The Kalevala, Influences on Tolkien, Gandalf, and (perhaps) The Hobbit | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#The Kalevala, Influences on Tolkien, Gandalf, and (perhaps) The Hobbit |
Bilbo romantic? | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#Bilbo romantic? |
Soviet Hobbit | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit/Archive 4#Soviet Hobbit |
Individuation | 2 | Talk:The Hobbit#Individuation |
"Little Hobbit" listed at Redirects for discussion | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit#"Little Hobbit" listed at Redirects for discussion |
A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion | 1 | Talk:The Hobbit#A Commons file used on this page or its Wikidata item has been nominated for deletion |
Titular vs Eponymous | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit#Titular vs Eponymous |
recent edit summary | 3 | Talk:The Hobbit#recent edit summary |
Sales figures | 4 | Talk:The Hobbit#Sales figures |