Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
infobox? | 7 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#infobox? |
Some edits | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Some edits |
Intro overhaul | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Intro overhaul |
Specific traditions | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Specific traditions |
Adverse effects | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Adverse effects |
Origins of meditation; early images | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Origins of meditation; early images |
Meditation and quantum mechanics | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Meditation and quantum mechanics |
Re-edit, introducing new section | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Re-edit, introducing new section |
Removing section on Osho, awaiting a more comprehensive section on spiritual teachers | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Removing section on Osho, awaiting a more comprehensive section on spiritual teachers |
Source-critical observations | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Source-critical observations |
Spammy links | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Spammy links |
Removal of external links | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Removal of external links |
Removing new section on Osho | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Removing new section on Osho |
A whole lot of hoopla/flim-flam...Very one sided. | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#A whole lot of hoopla/flim-flam...Very one sided. |
Amygdala? | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Amygdala? |
Questionability of Transcendental Meditation | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Questionability of Transcendental Meditation |
Types of meditation | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Types of meditation |
A properggg definition of meditation? | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#A properggg definition of meditation? |
Lead paragraph | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Lead paragraph |
Doubling of images on page | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Doubling of images on page |
Descartes and Meditation | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Descartes and Meditation |
Objection To Removal of External Links As Spam | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Objection To Removal of External Links As Spam |
Gnostic (Modern) deletion | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Gnostic (Modern) deletion |
Citation needed | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Citation needed |
Minor edits | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Minor edits |
Sahaja Yoga and TM are not New Age | 4 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Sahaja Yoga and TM are not New Age |
Too much emphasis on Buddhism | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Too much emphasis on Buddhism |
Moved edit by Skant from article page to here | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Moved edit by Skant from article page to here |
Objection to repeated "cleansing" of External Links | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Objection to repeated "cleansing" of External Links |
Suggestion for link editing/organization | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Suggestion for link editing/organization |
There should be more on stress. Also proposing a useful external link on meditation and stress. | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#There should be more on stress. Also proposing a useful external link on meditation and stress. |
Meditation: Scientific Explanation | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Meditation: Scientific Explanation |
Who is maintaining this page?? | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Who is maintaining this page?? |
Removing redundant words and forced association of "Christian monastic" phrase | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Removing redundant words and forced association of "Christian monastic" phrase |
fundamentalists? | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#fundamentalists? |
Addition of Heart Rhythm Meditation | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Addition of Heart Rhythm Meditation |
anonymous user | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#anonymous user |
Krishnamurti in hinduism? | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Krishnamurti in hinduism? |
ethics are causally related to the attainment of religious insight | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#ethics are causally related to the attainment of religious insight |
Meditation on the brain | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Meditation on the brain |
Health applications and clinical studies of meditation | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Health applications and clinical studies of meditation |
Scientific Meditation | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Scientific Meditation |
MBSR | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#MBSR |
Dubious Claim in Health applications and clinical studies of meditation section | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Dubious Claim in Health applications and clinical studies of meditation section |
Buddhist <-> Christian | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Buddhist <-> Christian |
Tags | 13 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Tags |
Recent changes to article | 13 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Recent changes to article |
Overview section | 14 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Overview section |
Kriya Yoga | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Kriya Yoga |
Confusing sentence in lead | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Confusing sentence in lead |
Jedi | 15 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Jedi |
Sahaja Yoga | 14 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Sahaja Yoga |
video about scientific research on meditation | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#video about scientific research on meditation |
Change to the opening statement | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Change to the opening statement |
OBVIOUS ERROR UNDER CHRISTIANITY | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#OBVIOUS ERROR UNDER CHRISTIANITY |
Etymology of "meditation" | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Etymology of "meditation" |
Potential Hazards | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Potential Hazards |
Did anyone mention fraud? | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Did anyone mention fraud? |
its hard | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#its hard |
No mention of meditation originating in India? | 9 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#No mention of meditation originating in India? |
Health applications | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Health applications |
researchingmeditation.org | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#researchingmeditation.org |
Merge discussion | 8 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Merge discussion |
Beads | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Beads |
Etymology of Tibetan word "gom" | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 1#Etymology of Tibetan word "gom" |
Dating the appearance of meditation in Hindu scriptures | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Dating the appearance of meditation in Hindu scriptures |
Suggested addition to section "Transcendental Meditation" | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Suggested addition to section "Transcendental Meditation" |
Vandalism of Hindu Meditation section | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Vandalism of Hindu Meditation section |
Advertsing in the Meditation Bazaar | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Advertsing in the Meditation Bazaar |
Hindu Meditation Vandalism | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Hindu Meditation Vandalism |
Meditation in Hinduism | 9 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Meditation in Hinduism |
== Agenda in Edits == | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#== Agenda in Edits == |
Shankara and eminence on Hindu meditation | 13 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Shankara and eminence on Hindu meditation |
Strange searching | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Strange searching |
Poisoning the well | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Poisoning the well |
Just an FYI regarding reversions | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Just an FYI regarding reversions |
Forms section | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Forms section |
"In a Western context" section | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#"In a Western context" section |
Random personal commentary/lecturing | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Random personal commentary/lecturing |
Sprituality and Religion section | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Sprituality and Religion section |
Language in buddhist section | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Language in buddhist section |
Simplification | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Simplification |
This sentence must be a practical joke | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#This sentence must be a practical joke |
Transcendental Meditation | 18 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Transcendental Meditation |
Mental Discipline? | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Mental Discipline? |
Query | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Query |
Lead section needs expanding | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Lead section needs expanding |
Is this really inappropriate for the article lead-in? | 18 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Is this really inappropriate for the article lead-in? |
Etymology | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Etymology |
History? | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#History? |
This article deals mostly with religious beliefs regarding meditation, not with meditation itself. | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#This article deals mostly with religious beliefs regarding meditation, not with meditation itself. |
Holistic discipline? | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Holistic discipline? |
What is due coverage of "automatic self-transcending meditation"? (re WP:BRD process) | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#What is due coverage of "automatic self-transcending meditation"? (re WP:BRD process) |
New Lead | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#New Lead |
adding links, and brief and simple descriptions, of physiologically distinct practices | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#adding links, and brief and simple descriptions, of physiologically distinct practices |
Copy edit of referenced sentences | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Copy edit of referenced sentences |
Balancing the lede, avoiding POV | 35 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Balancing the lede, avoiding POV |
Still an inadequate description | 8 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 2#Still an inadequate description |
Meditation in Health Science | 4 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Meditation in Health Science |
Article schizophrenia? | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Article schizophrenia? |
Let us do this systematically | 10 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Let us do this systematically |
Scope of article - new paragraph added | 9 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Scope of article - new paragraph added |
Def table: content vs form | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Def table: content vs form |
Material on marginalization of contemplative traditions in Western Christianity | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Material on marginalization of contemplative traditions in Western Christianity |
meditation not always done to the exclusion of thought, seriously | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#meditation not always done to the exclusion of thought, seriously |
Suggested change to lede regarding position of The Catholic Church on meditation | 10 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Suggested change to lede regarding position of The Catholic Church on meditation |
Facts and Number of meditators | 21 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Facts and Number of meditators |
Discussion re. rewriting of the lede, moved from the above | 11 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 3#Discussion re. rewriting of the lede, moved from the above |
edited the motivations for meditating | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 4#edited the motivations for meditating |
Second discussion on suggested change to lede regarding position of The Catholic Church on meditation | 15 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 4#Second discussion on suggested change to lede regarding position of The Catholic Church on meditation |
Difference / comparison section | 11 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 4#Difference / comparison section |
Subsection length and WP:DUE | 13 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 4#Subsection length and WP:DUE |
page needs a mindfulness section - secular meditation | 16 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 4#page needs a mindfulness section - secular meditation |
Christian meditation - what methods? sentence unclear | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 4#Christian meditation - what methods? sentence unclear |
Soteriology of meditation | 13 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 4#Soteriology of meditation |
Studying meditation | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Studying meditation |
Incorrect edits again | 32 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 4#Incorrect edits again |
Postures in specific traditional religious traditions | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Postures in specific traditional religious traditions |
quieting the thoughts | 29 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#quieting the thoughts |
Suggestion: Avoid video links for references | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Suggestion: Avoid video links for references |
Problems with recently inserted material | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Problems with recently inserted material |
Universal Vibratory Meditation | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Universal Vibratory Meditation |
Qigong and Tai chi chuan | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Qigong and Tai chi chuan |
Community input needed--> A Proposal to more explicitly tie together the two subsections of Meditation#Modern definitions and Western models. | 9 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Community input needed--> A Proposal to more explicitly tie together the two subsections of Meditation#Modern definitions and Western models. |
Restoring/discussing some changes to lede, made on Nov 7 | 34 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Restoring/discussing some changes to lede, made on Nov 7 |
how we include the concept of ruminating thoughts | 11 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#how we include the concept of ruminating thoughts |
Meditation/ Vipassana at Dhammgiri Igatpuri by Vipassana Acharya Satyanarayan Goinkaji | 4 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 5#Meditation/ Vipassana at Dhammgiri Igatpuri by Vipassana Acharya Satyanarayan Goinkaji |
Encyclopedia of youtube? | 15 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#Encyclopedia of youtube? |
Create a separate page for postures? | 4 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#Create a separate page for postures? |
M's attempt to define mindfulness as central (section for WP:BRD discussion) | 16 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#M's attempt to define mindfulness as central (section for WP:BRD discussion) |
3O | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#3O |
5 cents | 5 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#5 cents |
minor proposed change | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#minor proposed change |
Need for mediation | 34 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#Need for mediation |
From non-Christian to Christian meditation | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#From non-Christian to Christian meditation |
You Need A Plan | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 6#You Need A Plan |
Another perspective. | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Another perspective. |
TM: to include or not to include.... or do we exclude MBSR? | 8 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#TM: to include or not to include.... or do we exclude MBSR? |
Sources | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Sources |
Discussion on deletion of sourced content on research | 13 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Discussion on deletion of sourced content on research |
Sudden page restructuring | 27 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Sudden page restructuring |
Difference between Prayer and Meditation | 30 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Difference between Prayer and Meditation |
Which are problematic links? | 20 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Which are problematic links? |
Link on the effects of meditation in relation to pain | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Link on the effects of meditation in relation to pain |
Scientific Studies | 20 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Scientific Studies |
AHRQ Report | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#AHRQ Report |
There we go again: east and west | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#There we go again: east and west |
Definition | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 7#Definition |
Stress | 21 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Stress |
Clarification | 27 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Clarification |
Prayer and Meditation, or Prayer as Meditation? | 11 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Prayer and Meditation, or Prayer as Meditation? |
Meditation and monasticism | 22 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Meditation and monasticism |
Why a picture of a statue of something called Buddha? | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Why a picture of a statue of something called Buddha? |
consistency in the Definitions and scope section | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#consistency in the Definitions and scope section |
Meditative brain alpha wave dominance | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Meditative brain alpha wave dominance |
Which meditation? | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Which meditation? |
Edit request on 29 June 2012 | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Edit request on 29 June 2012 |
the lead | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#the lead |
Benefits of meditation | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Benefits of meditation |
Citation that shows that meditation lowers blood pressure | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Citation that shows that meditation lowers blood pressure |
Defining meditation | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Defining meditation |
Nomination for GA status | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Nomination for GA status |
GA Review | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#GA Review |
quick questions from nominator | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#quick questions from nominator |
textbook error | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#textbook error |
Stoicism | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Stoicism |
Jose Silva redirect | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Jose Silva redirect |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#External links modified |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#External links modified 2 |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#External links modified 3 |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#External links modified 4 |
Meditation in the Workplace | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Meditation in the Workplace |
Policy misunderstanding | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Policy misunderstanding |
Special status for Transcendental Meditation? | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Special status for Transcendental Meditation? |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#External links modified 5 |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#External links modified 6 |
External links modified | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#External links modified 7 |
Misleading definition | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Misleading definition |
Surprised this part stayed here for so long | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Surprised this part stayed here for so long |
Kirtan Kriya content moved to talk | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Kirtan Kriya content moved to talk |
This article is now too long | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#This article is now too long |
Can anyone update the PsychINFO ref? | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Can anyone update the PsychINFO ref? |
Removing evo4soul | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Removing evo4soul |
Dictionary definition | 4 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Dictionary definition |
Bond-definition | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Bond-definition |
Article length is too long -- looking for feedback on a possible solution | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#Article length is too long -- looking for feedback on a possible solution |
infobox? | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 8#infobox? |
Ethnocentric propaganda vs Facts | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Ethnocentric propaganda vs Facts |
Removed from lead and parked here | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Removed from lead and parked here |
Definitions | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Definitions |
CRITICISM | 6 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#CRITICISM |
Better definition? | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Better definition? |
Change lead sentence towards exercise/cite-link... | 7 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Change lead sentence towards exercise/cite-link... |
Edit war | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Edit war |
Merger proposal with "Guided meditation" article | 8 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Merger proposal with "Guided meditation" article |
Further reading | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Further reading |
Earliest references to meditation | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Earliest references to meditation |
History | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#History |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 2 |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 3 |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 4 |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 5 |
Further reading pruning | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Further reading pruning |
Earliest mention of meditation | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Earliest mention of meditation |
Section on "no thought" | 3 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Section on "no thought" |
Recent edits and revert on opening sentence | 10 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Recent edits and revert on opening sentence |
Overweighting a flimsy reference? | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Overweighting a flimsy reference? |
Table of Definitions - Time to Bring it Back? | 2 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Table of Definitions - Time to Bring it Back? |
Wiki Education assignment: Language in Advertising | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Wiki Education assignment: Language in Advertising |
Wiki Education assignment: Research Process and Methodology - FA22 - Sect 200 - Thu | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Wiki Education assignment: Research Process and Methodology - FA22 - Sect 200 - Thu |
Wiki Education assignment: Psychology Capstone | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Wiki Education assignment: Psychology Capstone |
Article issues and classification | 1 | Talk:Meditation/Archive 9#Article issues and classification |
Self-Inquiry | 1 | Talk:Meditation#Self-Inquiry |
Applause! | 1 | Talk:Meditation#Applause! |
Removal of Mindfulness from the definition & moving the definition difficulties up to the lead | 20 | Talk:Meditation#Removal of Mindfulness from the definition & moving the definition difficulties up to the lead |
Effects of meditation improvement | 2 | Talk:Meditation#Effects of meditation improvement |
Recent edits | 1 | Talk:Meditation#Recent edits |
Wiki Education assignment: Psychology Capstone | 1 | Talk:Meditation#Wiki Education assignment: Psychology Capstone |