Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
The Goths and Scandinavia | 7 | Talk:Goths/Archive 1#The Goths and Scandinavia |
The Goths and Scandinavia | 25 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#The Goths and Scandinavia |
Scandinavian origin | 10 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Scandinavian origin |
equitatus gothorum | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#equitatus gothorum |
"...or better Gothones" | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#"...or better Gothones" |
Council of Basel? | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Council of Basel? |
Tacitus, "Mare Suebicum" | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Tacitus, "Mare Suebicum" |
Goth should redirect here | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Goth should redirect here |
Not Accurate | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Not Accurate |
Rawe edit | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Rawe edit |
A citation problem | 6 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#A citation problem |
Genetics | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Genetics |
Vandalism | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Vandalism |
Origins of Goths | 6 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Origins of Goths |
Goths in Finland? | 8 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Goths in Finland? |
I don't think we can or should equate Thervingi & Greuthungi w/ Visigoths & Ostrogoths | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#I don't think we can or should equate Thervingi & Greuthungi w/ Visigoths & Ostrogoths |
Germany? Germany?!? Germany?!?!? | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Germany? Germany?!? Germany?!?!? |
Where they came from vs. who they were | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Where they came from vs. who they were |
Does this actually mean anything, and if so, what? | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Does this actually mean anything, and if so, what? |
U5a1a & R1b1c9a | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#U5a1a & R1b1c9a |
Etymologically identical | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Etymologically identical |
Separate Gothic origins page? | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Separate Gothic origins page? |
D.H. Green on the Bastarnae | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#D.H. Green on the Bastarnae |
Roman and Cappadocian prisoners | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Roman and Cappadocian prisoners |
Sometimes I wonder about Wikipedia | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Sometimes I wonder about Wikipedia |
"Lost tribes of Israel" | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#"Lost tribes of Israel" |
Spinning off "Origin of the Name "Goth" (*Gut-)" | 7 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Spinning off "Origin of the Name "Goth" (*Gut-)" |
History | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#History |
High German Connection | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#High German Connection |
Encarta? | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Encarta? |
Jordanes | 7 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Jordanes |
Gotar compared to 'gotra' of Indo-Aryan | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Gotar compared to 'gotra' of Indo-Aryan |
Blatantly POV | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Blatantly POV |
Great Floor Mosaic | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Great Floor Mosaic |
Passage from etymology | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Passage from etymology |
Goths v. Goth | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Goths v. Goth |
Malplaced clause | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Malplaced clause |
Comments | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Comments |
Goth map in Sweden | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 2#Goth map in Sweden |
Wolfram | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Wolfram |
Map showing Ulmerugi-Ulmigeria-Culmigeria | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Map showing Ulmerugi-Ulmigeria-Culmigeria |
goty=THIUDA = "ти иуда"? | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#goty=THIUDA = "ти иуда"? |
Fritigern | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Fritigern |
Scythian Goths | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Scythian Goths |
Archaeological records for Goths on the Roman Borders | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Archaeological records for Goths on the Roman Borders |
Sources | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Sources |
Gothic groups | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Gothic groups |
Questions | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Questions |
Incorrect (comment moved from top of page) | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Incorrect (comment moved from top of page) |
Gutans | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Gutans |
Mainstream scholarship is not a citation | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Mainstream scholarship is not a citation |
Legacy of the Goths? Removed entries | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Legacy of the Goths? Removed entries |
Getica is not Gothica | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Getica is not Gothica |
Goths are not Getae | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Goths are not Getae |
Recceswinth | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Recceswinth |
Era Style- CE Current Era | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Era Style- CE Current Era |
germanic | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#germanic |
Ugly as a Goth | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Ugly as a Goth |
Dubious | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Dubious |
Where were they settled after the Adrianople revolt? | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Where were they settled after the Adrianople revolt? |
Rescued comment by another user from Archive | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Rescued comment by another user from Archive |
Expand lead from overview section | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#Expand lead from overview section |
A scythian heritage perhaps | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 3#A scythian heritage perhaps |
Gothic migration | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#Gothic migration |
GA Review | 13 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#GA Review |
Etymology section: verification issue | 8 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#Etymology section: verification issue |
Goths = Gutones and similar assumptions | 14 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#Goths = Gutones and similar assumptions |
Goths and Gutones again | 18 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#Goths and Gutones again |
Supposed evidence from the Sagas | 8 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#Supposed evidence from the Sagas |
A missing topic or topics: how to fit | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#A missing topic or topics: how to fit |
why all the wrong publication dates and even edit warring about it? | 9 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#why all the wrong publication dates and even edit warring about it? |
Undue genetic conclusions? | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#Undue genetic conclusions? |
Potentially useful sources? | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#Potentially useful sources? |
describe where the Goths lived | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#describe where the Goths lived |
Poor sources for potential deletion | 9 | Talk:Goths/Archive 4#Poor sources for potential deletion |
A comment on the edit war | 22 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#A comment on the edit war |
Footnote concern | 14 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#Footnote concern |
Christensen example | 35 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#Christensen example |
Caricatures of Walter Goffart | 14 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#Caricatures of Walter Goffart |
a drafting table | 17 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#a drafting table |
RfC on publication date | 17 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#RfC on publication date |
some specific tweak proposals in lead | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#some specific tweak proposals in lead |
Request to replace links behind paywall | 12 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#Request to replace links behind paywall |
Proposed changes to paragraph 3 in the lead | 23 | Talk:Goths/Archive 5#Proposed changes to paragraph 3 in the lead |
More Editors | 7 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#More Editors |
Names section | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Names section |
Request for permission to rewrite section Goths#Name | 72 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Request for permission to rewrite section Goths#Name |
Verification failure requiring tweaks: please comment | 13 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Verification failure requiring tweaks: please comment |
RFC about the Name section | 14 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#RFC about the Name section |
Discussion relevant to this article, on less watched article. Topics include Walter Goffart as source. | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Discussion relevant to this article, on less watched article. Topics include Walter Goffart as source. |
Gapt versus Gaut | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Gapt versus Gaut |
Speculation | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Speculation |
Duplication on this article | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Duplication on this article |
Where does "History" really start? | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Where does "History" really start? |
boranoi/boradoi doubts | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#boranoi/boradoi doubts |
Should the Origins 3.1 and Migration 3.2 sections be move out of History? | 8 | Talk:Goths/Archive 6#Should the Origins 3.1 and Migration 3.2 sections be move out of History? |
Problem with lede | 7 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#Problem with lede |
Request for permission to reduce duplication | 18 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Request for permission to reduce duplication |
Request for permission to reduce duplication and improve article | 5 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Request for permission to reduce duplication and improve article |
Edit request | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Edit request |
Edit request Visigoths | 6 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Edit request Visigoths |
Edit request: sentences which use poor sources to "explain" good sources | 18 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Edit request: sentences which use poor sources to "explain" good sources |
Edit request: Christensen citation | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Edit request: Christensen citation |
Better source needed tag: Gdansk | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Better source needed tag: Gdansk |
Sub-section title | 14 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Sub-section title |
Genetics sections: remove? reduce? | 16 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Genetics sections: remove? reduce? |
The two "physical appearance" sections | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#The two "physical appearance" sections |
Speculative origins: The too much too early concern | 7 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#Speculative origins: The too much too early concern |
change publication date proposals | 6 | Talk:Goths/Archive 7#change publication date proposals |
Proposal to reduce duplication and restructure the History section | 18 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#Proposal to reduce duplication and restructure the History section |
Crucial | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#Crucial |
Have made Origin stories of the Goths | 5 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#Have made Origin stories of the Goths |
minor edit requests on section headings and "See" templates | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#minor edit requests on section headings and "See" templates |
New article Gutones | 1 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#New article Gutones |
Disputed link to Scandinavia, the imperative of major publishing houses concerning "History" | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#Disputed link to Scandinavia, the imperative of major publishing houses concerning "History" |
Intro | 42 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#Intro |
Change proposal in prehistory section | 13 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#Change proposal in prehistory section |
Change proposal in classification section | 16 | Talk:Goths/Archive 9#Change proposal in classification section |
The new source Kasperski | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 9#The new source Kasperski |
Proposal for modifications to the Prehistory section | 24 | Talk:Goths/Archive 9#Proposal for modifications to the Prehistory section |
Request to add links to Orrin W. Robinson and Marek Olędzki | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 8#Request to add links to Orrin W. Robinson and Marek Olędzki |
Restarting | 12 | Talk:Goths/Archive 9#Restarting |
Another proposal for modifications to the Prehistory section | 10 | Talk:Goths/Archive 9#Another proposal for modifications to the Prehistory section |
Prehistory section: similar new material that also needs removal for the same reasons | 24 | Talk:Goths/Archive 9#Prehistory section: similar new material that also needs removal for the same reasons |
The Goths in Ancient History (2020) by David M. Gwynn | 10 | Talk:Goths/Archive 10#The Goths in Ancient History (2020) by David M. Gwynn |
Review of new proposal by Krakkos 31 March 2021 | 30 | Talk:Goths/Archive 10#Review of new proposal by Krakkos 31 March 2021 |
AGF or WTF | 6 | Talk:Goths/Archive 10#AGF or WTF |
RfC | 32 | Talk:Goths/Archive 13#RfC |
RFC on article focus | 26 | Talk:Goths/Archive 13#RFC on article focus |
Problems in first paragraph of Prehistory section | 4 | Talk:Goths/Archive 10#Problems in first paragraph of Prehistory section |
Can we archive the first 10 sections? | 6 | Talk:Goths/Archive 10#Can we archive the first 10 sections? |
RfC on proposal to simplify the Prehistory, Early history and Movement towards the Black Sea sections and merge them into a single Origins and early history section | 56 | Talk:Goths/Archive 13#RfC on proposal to simplify the Prehistory, Early history and Movement towards the Black Sea sections and merge them into a single Origins and early history section |
RfC on re-focusing the lead | 38 | Talk:Goths/Archive 11#RfC on re-focusing the lead |
Thoughts from a visitor | 6 | Talk:Goths/Archive 10#Thoughts from a visitor |
New online open access source: Many papers | 40 | Talk:Goths/Archive 12#New online open access source: Many papers |
Sketches for an origins section | 7 | Talk:Goths/Archive 11#Sketches for an origins section |
Link error in bibliography | 5 | Talk:Goths/Archive 12#Link error in bibliography |
Nishidani comments | 8 | Talk:Goths/Archive 12#Nishidani comments |
Material culture | 14 | Talk:Goths/Archive 12#Material culture |
The Kazanski 1991 source | 6 | Talk:Goths/Archive 12#The Kazanski 1991 source |
New lead draft feedback | 3 | Talk:Goths/Archive 12#New lead draft feedback |
RFC to move ahead on previous Intro and Origins proposals | 52 | Talk:Goths#RFC to move ahead on previous Intro and Origins proposals |
A potential clue in regards to Gothic origins? | 2 | Talk:Goths/Archive 12#A potential clue in regards to Gothic origins? |
re-appearance of DNA section | 22 | Talk:Goths#re-appearance of DNA section |
collecting quotes to help future discussion about pre 3rd century "pre" Goths | 2 | Talk:Goths#collecting quotes to help future discussion about pre 3rd century "pre" Goths |
New section on warfare | 1 | Talk:Goths#New section on warfare |