Loading AI tools
Hostages taken into Gaza 2023-present From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
On 7 October 2023, as part of the Hamas-led attack on Israel at the beginning of the Israel–Hamas war, Hamas and other Palestinian militant groups abducted 251 people from Israel to the Gaza Strip,[2][3][4] including children,[5] women, and elderly people.[6][7] In addition to hostages with only Israeli citizenship, almost half of the hostages are foreign nationals or have multiple citizenships.[8] Some hostages were Negev Bedouins.[9] The precise ratio of soldiers and civilians among the captives is unknown. The captives are likely being held in different locations in the Gaza Strip.[10]
| Israel–Hamas war hostage crisis | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part of the Israel–Hamas war | |||||
Posters in Tel Aviv calling for the return of Israeli hostages in Gaza | |||||
| |||||
| Belligerents | |||||
Involved in negotiations:  Hamas  Palestinian Islamic Jihad |
Citizens held hostage  Israel  Thailand  Nepal  Philippines  United States  Russia among others | ||||
| Commanders and leaders | |||||
|
Yahya Sinwar † In Negotiations Ismail Haniyeh X Khalil al-Hayya Basem Naim[1] Osama Hamdan |
Benjamin Netanyahu In Negotiations David Barnea Ronen Bar Nitzan Alon | ||||
| Units involved | |||||
Holding hostages: al-Qassam Brigades Al-Quds Brigades  Abu Ali Mustafa Brigades  Al-Nasser Salah al-Deen Brigades  Mujahideen Brigades |
 Israel Defense Forces YAMAM Shin Bet | ||||
As of 28 August 2024, 117 hostages had been returned alive to Israel, with 105 being released in a prisoner exchange deal, four released by Hamas unilaterally and eight rescued by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF).[11][12] 37 bodies of hostages were repatriated to Israel, with three of the hostages killed by friendly fire from the IDF[13][14] and the bodies of thirty-four hostages repatriated through military operations.[15][16] 73 hostages were reportedly killed on October 7 or in Hamas captivity according to Israel.[17][18][19] As of 1 September 2024, 101 hostages remained in captivity in the Gaza Strip, 97 of whom had been abducted on 7 October 2023, and the other four hostages captured earlier.[18][20][21]
At the start of the war, Hamas offered to release all hostages in exchange for Israel releasing all Palestinian prisoners.[22] By October 2023, Israel held 5,200 Palestinians, including 170 children, in its prisons.[23] Several countries have been involved in negotiations between Israel and Hamas, with Qatar taking the lead.[24]
On 22 November 2023, Israel and Hamas agreed to the release of 150 Palestinian prisoners and a four-day cease-fire in exchange for Hamas's release of approximately 50 of the hostages. The exchange involved hostages from the categories of women and children.[25][26][27] As of 30 November 2023[update], the last day of the ceasefire, 105 civilian hostages had been released, which included 81 people from Israel, 23 Thais and one Filipino.[11] On 12 February 2024, two Argentinian-Israeli civilians were rescued in Operation Golden Hand. On 2 September 2024, Hamas released statements which strongly insinuated that they now had a new policy of killing any hostage that the IDF attempted to rescue with military force, as opposed to a pause in fighting that allows for peaceful release of hostages.[28][29]
The issue of hostages and prisoners is considered emotional for both Israelis and Palestinians.[23] Since 1967, between 750,000 and 1 million Palestinians have been arrested by Israel.[30][23][31] As of October 2023, Israel held 5,200 Palestinian prisoners,[32] including 170 children.[23] (By November 2023, the number of Palestinian prisoners, including suspected militants and Gazans had increased to 10,000.[33]). Some have been convicted on terrorism-related charges[34] UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese described many convictions as resulting from "a litany of violations of international law, including due process violations, that taint the legitimacy of the administration of justice by the occupying power."[35] About 1,310 Palestinians are held in administrative detention, a practice that allows Israel to detain Palestinians indefinitely without charges or trial.[36] Israel justifies this practice citing security reasons.[37]
Hamas has used hostages as bargaining chips for prisoner exchanges,[38] which is a violation of international law.[39] Hostage-taking and the abduction of civilians are prohibited by international law and are war crimes.[40][41] Israel had mostly refrained from negotiating with organizations it deemed as terrorists, opting for military or alternative measures to secure the release of hostages.[38][42] However, Israel has engaged in prisoner exchanges with armed groups on several occasions.[43]
Notable incidents include the 1994 abduction of Israeli soldier Nachshon Wachsman by Hamas, resulting in his death during a failed rescue attempt by IDF forces.[44][45] Hamas actions were at times aimed at disrupting the peace process in the 1990s.[44] In 2006, Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit was captured and held for over five years until a prisoner exchange in 2011. Israel secured his release in exchange for 1,000 Palestinians from Israeli custody, some of whom were trialed as terrorists.[4][30]
The 2014 kidnapping and murder of three Israeli teenagers, Eyal Yifrach, Naftali Fraenkel, and Gilad Shaar, heightened tensions and contributed to opening of Operation Protective Edge in 2014.[46][47] Hamas has also held the bodies of two slain Israeli soldiers, Hadar Goldin and Oron Shaul, since the 2014 Operation Protective Edge. Additionally, at the time of its attack, Hamas was already holding two Israelis hostage: Ethiopian Israeli Avera Mengistu (since 2014) and Bedouin Israeli Hisham al-Sayed (since 2015). Hamas has also sought to ransom the remains of Israeli soldiers Oron Shaul and Hadar Goldin, which they seized during the 2014 Gaza War.[48][49] On 31 August 2023, Israel warned its citizens that Hamas was trying to kidnap them.[50]
On 7 October 2023, Hamas attacked Israel, initiating the 2023 Hamas-Israel war. The attack resulted in hundreds of Israeli casualties, leading to widespread condemnation and accusations of war crimes.[51][38] The use of hostages, primarily women, children, and the elderly, is highlighted as a violation by Hamas of international humanitarian law.[52]
On the morning of 7 October 2023, around 6:30 a.m. IST, around 6,000 Palestinians including 3,800 from the Hamas "elite Nukhba forces" launched an attack into Israel from 119 sites on its border with the Gaza Strip.[53][54] The operation included attacks on Israel Defense Forces (IDF) bases as well as massacres of Israeli civilians. The ground incursion was combined with a sustained barrage of at least 4,300 of rockets.[55][53][54]
At around 7:00 am, militants raided many communities and kibbutzim (intentional communities) in the Gaza periphery area of Israel. They killed civilians and soldiers across many communities resulting in 1,200 deaths.[56][57][58] The Economist described the combined attacks as "the biggest terror attack in [Israel's] history".[58]
In the initial wave of attacks, militants kidnapped civilians and brought them back to Gaza as captives.[4][7][59] According to statements by Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad, around 200 soldiers and civilians were captured or abducted during the raid on the Gaza periphery communities.[60][61] Rear Admiral Daniel Hagari, an IDF spokesperson, reported on 7 October that military officers were among those captured.[62] Israel confirmed the identity of 203 captives, among them 30 children,[63] while Gaza spokespeople reported holding roughly 200, estimating that another 50 were held by other factions.[64] The IDF reported that it captured "handbooks" made by Hamas to instruct its militants; these handbooks instructed to "kill the difficult" captives, and use the rest as human shields.[65] The UN's Pramila Patten and Commission of Inquiry was unable to substantiate these claims.[66]
Civilians believed to be held captive in Gaza include families, children, festival-goers, peace activists, caregivers, and older adults.[67] Such as 75-year-old historian Alex Danzig who has written books on Poland's Jewish community and the Holocaust,[68][7] and the Bibas family were taken from their home, including an infant and 4-year-old were taken from Nir Oz.[69][70]
While many hostages had only Israeli citizenship, about half of the hostages are foreign nationals or have multiple citizenships. Some of these hostages hold citizenship from France, Germany, Russia, United Kingdom, and the United States.[24][71] Israel hosts a large number of international workers for agriculture work, with some workers also being kidnapped and held hostage. At least seventeen Thai citizens working in greenhouses in the Gaza periphery were also kidnapped.[24][71][72] One citizen of Nepal, Bipin Joshi, was confirmed to be abducted from kibbutz Alumim.[73] Two Filipinos were abducted and later released during the ceasefire.[74] Hamas also took members of the Negev Bedouin Arab community as hostages.[9]
There is a video depicting at least 64 of the abductees.[75] Video analysis from The Washington Post shows that some of the captives were killed shortly after their capture.[76] Images taken by the Associated Press also showed Yaffa Adar being kidnapped.[59]
On 19 November 2023, the Israeli military released reported CCTV footage that they claim shows hostages being led into Al-Shifa Hospital on 7 October. This was in the wake of Israel being put under pressure to substantiate claims that Hamas was operating an expansive command center under the hospital leading to its siege. However, shortly after the release BBC News indicated that they were unable to independently corroborate the claims and is not the evidence that Israel claimed to have.[77]
As part of Israel's counteroffensive, Israel implemented a "total blockade" of the Gaza strip until the hostages have been released.[78] Amnesty International describes this measure as having been "taken to punish civilians in Gaza for the actions of Palestinian armed groups," amounting to collective punishment.[79] Israel has also undertaken mass detentions of Palestinians in Israel and the Palestinian territories; several Israeli NGOs described the detention of several thousand Gazan workers as a form of retaliation or "vengeance" for the capture of Israeli citizens.[80][81][82]
American-Israeli author Robby Berman set up a fund offering a reward of 1 million Israeli shekels for the release of hostages in Gaza, specifically aimed at encouraging Palestinians to aid in the rescue of Jewish prisoners.[83]
Experts stated that an Israeli ground invasion of the Gaza Strip would endanger the lives of the hostages.[84] U.S. officials said the Biden administration advised Israel to delay the ground invasion of Gaza to allow more time for hostage negotiations.[85] According to Israeli officials, once Israel begins a ground invasion of Gaza, it will be almost impossible to reach a deal on the release of the hostages.[86] On 24 October, US President Joe Biden rejected calls for a ceasefire, stating "We should have those hostages released and then we can talk".[87]
On 22 October 2023, a list of the 204 hostages was published.[88]
According to Israel, at least 250 additional individuals were captured on the first day of the war, but rescued that day.[89][90]
As of 6 June 2024, Hamas refuses to allow representatives of the International Committee of the Red Cross to meet with the 7 October hostages in Gaza.[91][92][93] The hostages are believed to have been dispersed among different Hamas members and factions, as well as among other militant groups, gangs and families.[94]
On October 10, 2023, the spokesperson for Hamas’s military wing Abu Obaida broadcast a message on Al Jazeera that Hamas would not consider any hostage negotiations unless Israel ceased any military effort to respond to Hamas attacks.[95]
In a reconstruction of the negotiations, Franklin Foer has written that by October 13 2023, the Emir of Qatar, Tamim bin Hamad Al Thani in a discussion with Antony Blinken, said that Hamas had succeeded far beyond its expectations in taking far more hostages than it could manage, and was disposed to release some in exchange for a pause in Israeli airstrikes. Qatar had conveyed this readiness to Israel, without succeeding in getting the Israelis to focus on the proposal. Attempts by the Americans to follow up on this possibility only met with an Israeli unwillingness to explore the option. [96]
In November 2023, Hamas offered a deal dubbed as "everyone for everyone" or "all for all" — a release of all hostages being held in Gaza in exchange for Israel releasing thousands of Palestinians in Israeli prisons.[97][22] Some Israeli families have spoken in support for such a deal.[98][99]
Shortly after the October attacks Thailand had been in official talks with Hamas with a group convened by the countries parliamentary speaker Wan Muhamad Noor Matha about the release of their citizens. The group conveyed to Hamas that the citizens were not party to the conflict, but instead part of the around 30,000 Thai laborers who work in the Israeli agriculture sectors. While some had been captured about 39 were killed in the attacks and about 8,600 repatriated back to Thailand.[100][101]
On 8 November, Hamas sources told news agencies that Hamas could release 10–15 hostages in exchange for a three-day humanitarian pause in fighting.[97] On 9 Nov, Benjamin Netanyahu had reportedly rejected such an exchange.[102] On 13 November it was reported that Hamas had told Qatari mediators that the group was willing to release up to 70 women and children hostages held in Gaza for a five-day truce and the release of 275 women and children held by Israel.[103]
On 9 November, Al-Quds Brigades released a video where spokesperson Abu Hamza states that they are prepared for the unconditional release of 77-year old Hanna Katsir, citing humanitarian reasons and their inability to provide her with her specific medical needs, as well as the release of 13-year old Yagil Yaakov. Israel refused the offer, claiming it would play into the captor's "psychological terror".[104] On 21 November, it was erroneously reported that Katsir had died from medical complications, however she was still alive and was released on 24 November.[105] Yagil Yaakov, alongside his older brother, were released on 27 November.[106]
On 22 November it was announced that Israel and Hamas had reached an agreement about a cease fire and the release of 50 hostages. While hostages held by Hamas would not be released until 23 November at the earliest, those released would be woman and children, in response the Israeli government would release 150 Palestinian prisoners, more aid would be allowed into Gaza and a four-day cease-fire which would be added onto for every 10 additional hostages released. Hamas has acknowledged that of the hostages released children would be the main component of the hostages released, and the IDF has planned that an IDF officer would be on hand to facilitate the crossing and handover with the hostages being transferred into Israel for medical care.[107][108] As of 26 November, Hamas had released a total of 58 hostages since the ceasefire went into effect, some of whom were foreign nationals and not included in the agreement to release 50 Israelis.[109][110]
In April 2024 it was reported that a senior Hamas official stated that the group did not have 40 living hostages in Gaza that met the criteria for an exchange under a proposed cease-fire that was being negotiated. Negotiators had proposed an initial six week cease-fire in which Hamas would have released held hostages in waves, with a primary group of 40 to consist of women, older people, ill hostages and five female IDF troops, with Israel releasing Palestinians held in Israeli prisons among other demands.[111]
.jpg)
A captured IDF private was freed on 30 October in an operation headed by the IDF, with assistance from Shin Bet and Mossad.[112][113] On 8 December, Hamas claimed they repelled an attempted hostage rescue by Israeli special forces, inflicting several military casualties.[114] Hamas also said that a hostage named Sahar Baruch died in the incident.[115] On the same day of 8 December, according to an IDF statement, two Israeli soldiers were wounded in a failed hostage rescue attempt.[116] It is unclear whether the statements of Hamas and the IDF refer to the same event.[115]
During the early morning of 12 February 2024, the IDF, Shin Bet and special police forces coupled with airstrikes, rescued two hostages with dual Israel-Argentinian nationality, 60 year-old Fernando Simon Marman and 70 year-old Louis Har, who were kidnapped from Kibbutz Nir Yitzhak on 7 October by Hamas, from a building in Rafah in southern Gaza. One Israeli soldier was injured and 37 Hamas militants, including the hostages' guards, were reported killed during the rescue operation.[117][118]
In May 2024, it was reported that—based on IDF interrogations of detained reported members of Hamas in Gaza—an overnight operation led to the recovery of the bodies of four people killed on October 7, near the site of the Re'im music festival massacre.[119][120] On 31 May 2024, the IDF withdrew from Jabalia after a weeks-long operation, during which troops recovered the bodies of seven Israeli hostages.[121]
On 8 June 2024 four hostages who had been abducted during the Re'im music festival massacre were rescued from two separate areas in the Nuseirat refugee camp by members of the Yamam, the Shin Bet and the IDF. Airstrike cover for the operation and resulting firefights reportedly caused the deaths of over 200 Palestinians per the Gaza Health Ministry, while Israel claims only 100 Palestinians were killed.[122]
On 20 October, Hamas released two American hostages for humanitarian reasons and in response to Qatari and US pressure.[123][124] The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) said it helped facilitate the release of the hostages by transporting them from Gaza to Israel.[124] On 23 October, Hamas released two Israeli women hostages, aged 79 and 85, for humanitarian reasons after mediation by Qatar and Egypt. The ICRC helped transport them out of Gaza. The released hostages were from the Nir Oz kibbutz.[24][125] One of the released hostages, Yocheved Lifshitz, and her husband Oded, a journalist still in captivity, are known peace activists that helped Palestinians in Gaza get to hospitals in Israel.[125][126] Lifshitz's daughter Sharone said that Lifshitz and other hostages were held in a "huge network" of tunnels. Lifshitz was critical of both the Shin Bet and the IDF, and the press conference was criticized as a PR disaster for Israel.[127][128]
On 27 October, a Hamas official said that Hamas could not release the hostages taken during the attack on Israel until a ceasefire is agreed.[129][130] On 22 November, Israel and Hamas agreed to the release 150 of Palestinian prisoners and a four-day cease-fire in exchange for Hamas's release of approximately 50 of the hostages.[25] On 24 November, the release of 50 women and children hostages by Hamas over a four-day period began after negotiations with Israel, with hostages being released into the care of the Red Cross through the Rafah Border Crossing and then to the Israeli Hatzerim Military Base. Some of this group were dual and foreign nationals, with individuals from Israel, Thailand, and the Philippines counted in the first group released.[25][131]
As of 26 November 2023, a total of 41 hostages had been released by Hamas during the four-day ceasefire.[12] Of those released, 26 were Israeli (some being dual citizens) with a breakdown of 13 released on 24 November and 13 on 25 November.[110] In addition, 14 Thai hostages and one Filipino were released as part of a separate deal.[110] An additional 17 hostages (including 14 Israelis and one American) were released on 26 November, in exchange for 39 Palestinian prisoners.[132]
Israel published a list of 300 Palestinian prisoners that it would potentially release in exchange for Israeli hostages in Gaza, 287 of which are children below the age of 18.[133] An analysis by NBC News of the list showed about 20% were convicted of a crime, while the roughly 80% of the list were not convicted of any crimes and had either not been prosecuted or had been detained under administrative detention.[134] However, some of the Palestinians prisoners that were freed as part of the deal had been convicted of offenses ranging from attempted murder, to less severe ones such as inflicting property damage, hindering police work or assembling unlawfully. Other offenses included assault of police officers, rock-throwing, hurling firebombs, arson, and possession of firearms or explosives. Some prisoners reportedly belonged to Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad and PFLP.[135]
A Russian-Israeli man was released on 26 November outside of the cease fire agreement. Musa Abu Marzouk, an official within Hamas indicated that the release was in appreciation for President Vladimir Putin's position. Putin has been openly critical of the Israeli operation in regards to Gaza and the mounting casualties.[136]
The IDF confirmed on 13 October that remains of missing Israeli people were located and retrieved in the Gaza Strip.[137] On 14 October, Hamas stated that nine hostages had been killed over a 24-hour period due to Israeli airstrikes.[138] On 4 November, Hamas reported that 60 hostages had died as a result of Israel's bombing of Gaza.[139] An Israeli official responded that "Regardless of what Hamas claims, any harm done to hostages is Hamas's responsibility and they will be held accountable."[140] According to the IDF, half of the hostages were killed during the abduction or died in captivity.[141][142] At least two bodies of deceased hostages have been recovered, as of 16 November.[143]
Along with reported CCTV footage released on 19 November, Israel announced that an IDF soldier who had been captured on 7 October had been killed by Hamas while being held at the Al-Shifa hospital. Hamas denied this and indicated the soldier had been previously reported by them as being killed by an Israeli airstrike on 9 November.[77]
On 29 November, Hamas claimed that the youngest hostage; a 10-month old toddler and his 4-year-old brother and mother were killed while in captivity due to Israeli bombings. The claim is being investigated by the IDF and other agencies, and Israeli officials have stated the account shows the "barbarism and cruelty of Hamas".[144]
Hamas released a video of the dead body of Arie Zalmanovich, 86, from kibbutz Nir Oz. He had been wounded during the October 7 attack and assaulted by bystanders in Gaza as he was driven on a motorcycle by his captors.[145] According to Hamas he died of a heart attack.[146] Zalmanovich had medical conditions and required medical treatment.[147] His son attributed the death to the lack of medicines and suitable food in captivity.[148]
On 15 December, the IDF stated that during operations in Shuja'iyya, they "mistakenly identified three Israeli hostages as a threat" and killed them via friendly fire.[149] The three hostages were three men in their 20s, who were identified after having their bodies returned to Israel.[149][13][150] According to an Israeli military official on 16 December, the three hostages were shirtless and "they have a stick with a white cloth on it. The [Israeli] soldier feels threatened and opens fire. He declares that they're terrorists"; more Israeli forces shoot, killing two hostages "immediately" and wounding the third hostage, who appealed for help in Hebrew, then "there's another burst of fire [by Israeli forces] towards the third [hostage] and he also dies".[151] Haaretz reported that the third hostage retreated into a building after the other two hostages were shot, with IDF soldiers following the third hostage and shooting him dead because they thought he was a terrorist setting a trap.[152] Yediot Ahronot reported that Israeli soldiers had called for the third hostage to come out of the building he was hiding in, and then shot him when he reappeared.[153] The Israeli military investigated the killings and concluded on 28 December that the Israeli "soldiers carried out the right action to the best of their understanding of the event at that moment".[154]
In February 2024, it was announced that through a confidential assessment conducted by Israeli intelligence officials, there were more deceased hostages than previously known. In the report thirty-two of the hostages held in Gaza were declared as deceased, with an additional twenty hostages status still undetermined.[155]
On 24 April, 2024, Hamas had released a two-minute video of Hersch Goldberg-Polin in which he stated the need for the Israeli government to bring him home as well as that 70 of the 130 hostages have been killed in Israeli bombings. He also stated in the video that he was living in an "underground hell without water, food, sun or medical treatment".[156]
On 31 August, 2024, Hersh Goldberg-Polin's body was among six recovered from a Hamas tunnel in Rafah, Gaza. According to the Israeli health ministry, all six were executed by their Hamas captors from "close range" 1–2 days earlier. The IDF said that the captors were not present when its soldiers recovered the bodies.[157][158] Hamas denied executing Goldberg-Polin, as well as the five other hostages, stating they died in an Israeli airstrike.[159] On 2 September, Hamas announced that since June, they had implemented new instructions for managing hostages in the event of approaching Israeli forces in Gaza. Abu Obaida, the spokesperson for Hamas' Al-Qassam Brigades, did not disclose specific details but criticized Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu's insistence on using military pressure to free prisoners instead of negotiating a deal.[28][29]
 | This section provides insufficient context for those unfamiliar with the subject. (December 2023) |
Many hostages require medical treatment due to their medical conditions (such as Parkinson's, cardiovascular diseases, heart failure, diabetes mellitus, and cancer), according to a report sent to the ICRC on 15 October by Hagai Levine, a public health physician and epidemiologist who heads the medical and resilience team of the Hostages and Missing Families Forum.[160] As of 5 December 2023, Hamas refuses to grant the ICRC access to the hostages.[92][161][93]
On 13 October, Hamas released a video purporting to demonstrate its compassion towards abducted children. The video shows armed Hamas militants patting children on the back, rocking children in a stroller, and giving a child water.[162] On 16 October, Hamas released a video of a 21-year-old French Israeli woman pleading to be returned to her family, while someone bandages her injured arm and a scar is visible.[163] A released hostage, who was a nurse, was moved throughout her captivity to treat other hostages and could ask for specific medicines. Although she has alleged the medicines were often in insufficient amounts.[164]
Israel's Health Ministry found that the released hostages lost an average of 17–33 pounds (≈8–15 kilograms) in seven weeks, and they said their diet in captivity was minimal.[165] Gilat Livni, a pediatrician and consultant in infectious diseases who worked with some of the returned children at Schneider's children's hospital, stated that they were in "generally good condition" but raised caution about the trauma that was faced. A physician advising the families of held hostages also echoed this statement, warning of the trauma faced and the long process of restoring a sense of trust and control after being released.[166]
Renana Eitan, the head of psychiatry at the Ichilov Tel Aviv medical centre, said that among the freed hostages she examined were children drugged by their captors, including with ketamine, and were suffering from withdrawal.[167] Israel's Health Ministry’s confirmed that before they were released, liberated hostages were given psychoactive pills by their captors. Blood tests showed the drug was Clonazepam, commonly used to treat epilepsy, anxiety, OCD and other cases on a short-term basis. Hamas reportedly aimed to make the hostages appear calm and happy after enduring prolonged physical abuse, deprivation, and psychological terror in captivity.[168][169]
Dror Mendel, director of the Dana-Dwek Children's Hospital, described orthopedic injuries, scarring and burns, and "very low hygiene standards... lice, rashes, skin irritation [and] inflammation". Prof. Ronit Lubetzky, director of the Pediatrics department, stated that some of the children have lost as much as 10 kg of body weight.[170] Prof. Itay Pesach, Director of the Edmond and Lily Safra Children's Hospital, said that patients describe "the entire range of abuse you could dream of... not different from the testimonies of people who came back from the ghetto or concentration camp".[170] Levine spoke on the lacking medical care given to the hostages, physical and psychological abuse, and starvation: "at first there was an implicit assumption that the conditions of captivity by Hamas are reasonable. This assumption no longer exists... The situations is terrible... There's no time. The clock of some [of the hostages] is already ticking."[171] A doctor[who?] who treated some of the 110 hostages released from captivity told the Associated Press that at least ten male and female hostages of them were sexually assaulted or abused. He declined to give his name or speak on any further details, claiming to protect the hostages identities.[172]
A former IDF mental health officer said returning hostages who have experienced continual psychological trauma will be very cautious about saying anything that endangers other captives. She also stated returning hostages can have "black holes in their memory" and can also express sympathy for their captors due to "Stockholm syndrome".[173][better source needed] Many hostages told relatives that they were totally isolated from the outside world and had no information about their family members, who in many cases[174] were also kidnapped or killed in the attack.[175] Yaniv Yaacov, the uncle of hostages, said in an event in North Macedonia with the Israeli foreign minister that his two nephews were branded using the exhaust pipe of a motorcycle by Hamas. He alleged it was done so that if they escaped they could be detected through the burn. He also said his nephews were drugged.[176]
Hostages released by Hamas later relayed their experiences in captivity, either firsthand, via family members, or through a report from the United Nations:[177][178]
Israeli student Noa Argamani, who was at the trance party near Re'im, was kidnapped while with her partner Avinathan Or.[7][206] They were filmed being taken by the militants to Gaza, after WhatsApp messages they sent asking for help from their hiding place from 8:10 a.m. were exposed. The footage showed Argamani being taken on a motorcycle while reaching out for Or, who was led away by his captors on foot.[207] Argamani was rescued along with three other hostages on 8 June 2024.[208]
.png)
Militants abducted the Bibas family from kibbutz Nir Oz during the Nir Oz massacre: 9-month-old Kfir, 4-year-old Ariel, 32-year-old mother Shiri, and her 34-year-old husband Yarden.[209][210] Shiri's parents, also abducted from their kibbutz, were later found deceased. Efforts to release Shiri and her children during the ceasefire between Israel and Hamas were unsuccessful, leading to claims by Hamas that they were killed in an Israeli airstrike. The IDF expressed doubts about these claims, amidst widespread concern and a campaign for their release.[211][212]
23-year-old American-Israeli Hersh Goldberg-Polin was abducted by Hamas during the Re'im music festival massacre. During the festival, Hersh took refuge in a field shelter. His friend Aner Shapira died while repelling grenade attacks, and Hersh lost an arm before being abducted. His mother, Rachel Goldberg, has since been vocal in international and diplomatic arenas, including the United Nations and the March for Israel in Washington, D.C., campaigning for his release and demanding humanitarian intervention.[213][214][215] He was held hostage for almost 11 months, until his body was recovered from a tunnel in Rafah in the Gaza Strip on 31 August 2024.[216][217] It was later reported by the Israeli government that Goldberg-Polin and five other hostages with him were killed by Hamas, shot from "close range" 1–2 days before their bodies were found. Their killings sparked nation-wide protests in Israel about the continuation of the hostage crisis.[218][219]
Naama Levy, a 19-year-old female Israeli soldier, was abducted by Hamas militants, during the attack on the Nahal Oz kibbutz military base. Footage released by Hamas showed Levy with multiple visible injuries, including injuries to her ankles and a large bloodstain on the seat of her gray sweatpants, which led to widespread concern that she had been raped or sexually assaulted.[220][221]
Yarden Roman-Gat, a 36-year-old woman who is a dual national of Germany and Israel, along with her husband Alon and their 3-year-old daughter Gefen, were abducted by Hamas militants from their home in Kibbutz Be'eri during the Be'eri massacre and taken towards the Gaza Strip border. Yarden's act of self-sacrifice in saving her daughter during an escape attempt, and her subsequent two-month-long captivity in Gaza, garnered significant attention until her release on 29 November.[222][223]
On 16 October 2023, Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh and Turkey's Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan discussed the possibility of releasing the hostages taken during the Hamas attack on Israel.[224]
In a video released by Hamas, three female hostages are shown. One of the women speaks, and lays the blame for their continued situation on the Israeli government and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. She chides the Israeli government's bombing campaign, asking if they wanted all the hostages killed, and asks for the release of all Palestinian prisoners held by Israel.[225]
A poll by the Israeli newspaper Maariv, conducted on 18–19 October, found that 65% of Israelis supported a ground invasion of the Gaza Strip and 21% opposed it.[226] In comparison, according to a poll conducted for the same newspaper on 25–26 October, only 29% of Israelis supported an immediate large-scale ground offensive into the Gaza Strip. Maariv said that "It is almost certain that the developments on the matter of the hostages, which is now topping the agenda, have had a great impact on this shift."[227]
On 21 February 2024, Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich stated the hostages' return "is not the most important thing".[228] In May 2024, Orit Strook, the Minister of Settlements and National Missions, criticized a potential hostage deal, stating there are "soldiers who left everything behind and went out to fight for goals that the government defined, and we throw it in the trash to save 22 people or 33 or I don't know how many".[229]
During a debate regarding the status and repatriation of bodies of deceased suspected and confirmed Hamas militants in a June 2024 political-security cabinet meeting, Minister Ben Gvir stated the releasing of the bodies of militants limited Israel's ability to use them as leverage to exchange for hostages or bodies of hostages.[230]
Human rights groups, international organizations, and families of those held captive have called for an immediate release of the hostages.[231] On Sunday evening, 8 October, the families of the kidnapped and missing held a press conference, demanding the government open ongoing talks with the families and carry out an operation to bring the missing home, appoint someone to maintain ongoing contact with the families, immediately involve Turkish President Erdogan, Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, and Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi, to release the captives.[232] The government appointed Gal Hirsch to be in charge of the issue.[233]
On 26 October, the families of the hostages met with Netanyahu.[234] The Hostages and Missing Families Forum, that represents families of the abducted people, complained that no-one had explained "whether the ground operation endangers the well-being of the 229 hostages".[235] The families also raised complaints that the government and Netanyahu had failed to provide updates to the families or meet with them until the meeting on 26 October.[234] Meirav Gonen, a representative for the families, expressed support for a full prisoner swap, stating: "a deal of a return of our family members immediately in the framework of 'all for all' is feasible, and there will be wide national support for this."[33] According to one rabbi, Alberto Somekh, citing Talmud Gittin 45A, the Mishnah affirms that ‘captives should not be redeemed for more than their value, to prevent abuses.’ The view has been cited as one where religious principles are interpreted in a way to support the Netanyahu government’s widely criticized position.[236]
.jpg)
On 14 November, it was reported that families of those held hostage began a five-day-long march to Netanyahu's home in Israel to demand action and answers. One family member was quoted as saying they did not feel like they were in good hands, and that they do not get enough information, while another called on the perceived in action of the Israeli government.[237] On 2 December, at a rally outside the IDF headquarters in Tel Aviv, Israeli hostages released by Hamas called for the immediate release of fellow hostages left behind.[238] On 4 December, eight released Israeli hostages wrote a letter to the International Committee of the Red Cross, asking the organization to provide medical assistance and to visit their relatives still being held by Hamas in Gaza.[239] The appeal was made due to reports, that the Red Cross was not allowed to visit the hostages since the beginning of the war, as for 29 November.[240]
In an early December 2023 meeting with Netanyahu and other members of the war cabinet, family members of those who are still held hostage by Hamas forces showed their outrage and frustration with the continued situation. In a published recording, Netanyahu can be heard blaming the end of the November 2023 cease-fire on Hamas while family members and supporters can be heard calling him a liar. Some former hostages also attended the meeting and spoke about the conditions they were held in, which were exasperated by Israeli airstrikes.[241] One unnamed freed hostage from the kibbutz Nir Oz told Netanyahu: "Every day in captivity was extremely challenging. We were in tunnels, terrified that it would not be Hamas, but Israel, that would kill us, and then they would say Hamas killed you."[242][243]
In January 2024, the mother of Ron Sherman, a deceased hostage whose body was recovered by the IDF, accused the Israeli military of killing her son by filling the tunnel he was in with poison gas.[244] (Sherman was killed by an Israeli airstrike on 12 December.[245]) About 20 relatives of hostages still held as captives by Hamas stormed a Knesset finance committee on 22 January, a day after Netanyahu rejected new Hamas conditions for ending the war and releasing the remaining hostages. Many voiced their displeasure at the apparent lack of resolution in having the remaining hostages freed.[246][247]
That same month, the group Tsav 9 was created on Facebook and grew to over 400 members of family members of those taken hostage. The group became active in disrupting the delivery of humanitarian aid into the Gaza Strip. The group actions have caused it to be characterized as a "violent extremist" group by the United States in June 2024.[248][249]
After a "Settlement Brings Security" (Hebrew: התיישבות מביאה ביטחון, romanized: Hitiashvút Mevi’ávi Takhón) Conference was held in Jerusalem on 28 January 2024, sponsored by the right-wing Nachala (Israeli settler organization) pushing for resettlement of the Gaza Strip, many family members expressed their concerns about the conference in context of the crisis. It was strongly criticized for the festive atmosphere, for the movement's forming a perceived impediment to the hostages' release, and for its calls for coerced emigration of Palestinians from their country. One family member stated of the conferencegoers "you're dancing on their blood".[250][251]
A delegation of family members of Israeli hostages, along with several dozen lawyers, went to The Hague to file complaints against Hamas leaders at the International Criminal Court, which is empowered to prosecute individuals for serious violations of the Geneva Conventions that amount to war crimes.[252]
After Israel's National Security Advisor Tzachi Hanegbi in May 2024 had a discussion with several relatives of the hostages, one relative told the media that Hanegbi had indicated that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu would only agree to a deal regarding the hostages if, according to the relative, "it's going to be politically good for [Netanyahu], that if he sees polls that say that the Israeli public wants to see the hostages home more than it wants the continuation of the war, then he will make a deal that will bring all the hostages home".[253][254]
In early-September 2024, hostage families stated that executives at Channel 14 had told them a hostage deal would not happen because it would threaten Netanyahu's coalition government.[255] On 7 September 2024, mass demonstrations were held in support of the liberation of hostages in exchange for a cease-fire deal with Hamas.[256] The organising groups estimated that 500,000 participated in the Tel Aviv protest, with 250,000 more at rallies around the country.[256] This made it the largest-ever rally in Israel after the 25 September 1982 street protest organised by Peace Now after the Sabra and Shatila massacre with an estimated 400,000 participants, c. 10% of Israel's population,[257] and the 2023 Israeli judicial reform protests.[258]
On 16 October 2023, a report sent to the International Committee of the Red Cross by the Geneva-based organization Hostage and Missing Families Forum medical team, headed by Hagai Levine, said hostages are "in urgent need of treatment and lifesaving medication" and are "prone to immediate mortality." The report also expressed concern about babies requiring infant formula.[259][260]
On 25 October 2023, Qatar's Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin Jassim Al Thani stated that there had been some progress in the hostage negotiations.[261] That same day, World Health Organization Director General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus met with the Hostages and Missing Families Forum and said:
There is an urgent need for the captors of the hostages to provide signs of life, proof of provision of health care and the immediate release, on humanitarian and health grounds, of all those abducted.[262]
US State department spokesman, Mathew Miller suggested in response to a question about evidence of Hamas sexual and gender based violence on 7 October, that the reason Hamas was holding on to female Israeli hostages was to prevent them from testifying about their experiences in Hamas captivity.[263][264]
In October 2024, a government building in Tehran—frequently used for displaying murals in both Hebrew and Persian—was updated to feature a collage of photographs of hostages held by Hamas, accompanied by the phrase "No hostages will be freed," shown in both languages.[265]
| Date | Summary |
|---|---|
| 7 October 2023 | Hostages taken from Supernova music festival, Nir Oz, Be'eri, Kfar Aza Hostages taken from Nahal Oz and Israeli soldiers captured from Nahal Oz base Additional hostages were taken in other Gaza envelope communities
|
| 8 October 2023 | Analysis from the Washington Post determines that four hostages were killed shortly after being taken captive in Kibbutz Be'eri.[266][citation needed] |
| 9 October 2023 | Hamas's Al-Qassam Brigades threatened to execute hostages if civilian homes were bombed "without warning". |
|
14 October 2023 |
Hamas reported that nine hostages had been killed over a 24-hour period due to sustained IDF airstrikes. Israeli officials responded that as the hostages were in Hamas custody, the hostages well being was their responsibility.[138] |
| 17 October 2023 | Hamas releases a video of hostage Mia Schem; after her release she describes the video as being coerced.[267][268] |
| 22 October 2023 | Hamas releases two American hostages unilaterally.[269] |
| 24 October 2023 | Hamas releases two elderly Israeli female hostages unilaterally.[270] |
| 30 October 2023 | Israeli forces rescue Ori Megidish, an Israeli female soldier that had been held hostage in northern Gaza.[271] Hamas releases a video showing three female hostages pleading to be released.[272] |
| 4 November 2023 | Hamas claims that more than 60 hostages are missing "because of Israeli airstrikes on Gaza."[273] |
|
9 November 2023 |
Hamas Al-Quds Brigades spokes person released a video stating they were prepared to release an elderly and teenage hostage, citing humanitarian reasons. Both were released during the cease-fire later in the month.[106][105] |
| 14 November 2023 | Three hostages were killed by an Israeli airstrike which targeted and killed Hamas Gaza City Brigade Chief Ahmed Ghandour on 14 November.[245][274] Their bodies were recovered by the IDF on 15 December but the Israeli government not publicly reveal their existence or names until September 2024.[245][274] A Hamas statement issued 22 December 2023 along with video of the hostages had stated that the organization "tried to keep them alive - but Netanyahu insisted on killing them."[245]
|
| 16 November 2023 | Israel announces that it has recovered the bodies of two hostages, Yehudit Weiss and Corporal Noa Marciano, from buildings adjacent to Al-Shifa hospital.[275] |
|
17 November 2023 |
Hamas released a video confirming the death of 86-year-old hostage Arye Zalmanovich, claiming he had died due to a heart attack caused by IDF airstrikes.[146] |
| 21 November 2023 | Israel releases footage that it says shows hostages being taken into Al-Shifa hospital by armed men.[276] According to Israel, a third hostage, Corporal Noa Marciano, was taken to Al-Shifa hospital and executed there. Hamas had previously claimed that Marciano was killed in an Israeli airstrike on 9 November.[276] |
| 4–30 November 2023 | Hamas and Israel agree to a four-day ceasefire in which 50 Israeli hostages would be released for 150 Palestinian prisoners. The ceasefire was extended by three additional days. The hostages to be released during the ceasefire included women and minors.[277][278] Hamas releases 80 Israeli hostages in exchange for the release of 240 prisoners during the weeklong ceasefire.[279] Separate from the broader hostage release, on 26 November 2023, Hamas releases a dual citizen Russian-Israeli hostage, "as a result of the movement’s appreciation for President Putin’s positions".[280] Hamas also releases 23 Thai hostages and 1 Filipino hostage during the weeklong ceasefire in a separate agreement between Hamas and the Thai government.[281]
|
| 29 November 2023 | Hamas reported that members of the Bibas family, a 10-month old, a 4-year-old and their mother were reportedly killed by Israeli airstrikes in Gaza.[144] |
| 1 December 2023 | The IDF recovers the body of hostage Ofir Tzarfati in the Gaza Strip.[282] Four hostages from Nir Oz were announced to have died in captivity.[283] |
| 8 December 2023 | Hamas says hostage Sahar Baruch was killed in a failed rescue attempt.[284] On 3 January 2024, the IDF admitted that Baruch was killed during a failed rescue attempt and two Israeli soldiers were wounded while attempting the rescue attempt.[285] |
| 12 December 2023 | The IDF recovers the bodies of two hostages in underground tunnels in Jabalia, Gaza:[286] They were:
|
| 15 December 2023 | Three Israeli hostages are shot dead by the IDF while waving a white-flag in Shuja'iyya, Gaza in a friendly fire incident.[287] The IDF recovers the bodies of three additional hostages in Gaza.[288]
|
| 18 December 2023 | Hamas released a video of three elderly Israeli hostages on 18 December.[289] |
| 19 December 2023 | Palestinian Islamic Jihad released a video of two Israeli hostages on 19 December.[290] |
| 4 January 2024 | Three Israelis that had been previously presumed as missing are announced as held hostage in Gaza. Israel believes 136 hostages are being held in the Gaza Strip.[b][291] |
| 15 January 2024 | Hamas releases a video showing three Israeli hostages. Hamas claims that two of the hostages were killed in Israeli airstrikes, with Israel disputing the claim.[292] |
| 19 January 2024 | The Al-Nasser Salah al-Deen Brigades released a video of an Israeli captive who it claimed was killed by an Israeli airstrike in the Gaza Strip.[293][294] |
| 6 February 2024 | According to a confidential assessment conducted by Israeli intelligence officers, it was reported that there were more deceased hostages then previously known, with an additional 20 hostages reportedly deceased.[155] |
| 12 February 2024 | The IDF, Shin Bet and special police forces rescue two hostages, who were kidnapped from Kibbutz Nir Yitzhak, from a building in Rafah in southern Gaza, one soldier is reportedly injured and 37 Hamas militants are reportedly killed.[117][118] |
| 10 April 2024 | Hamas tells mediators that it does not have 40 hostages that match the criteria for a ceasefire deal.[295][94] |
| 17 May 2024 | The IDF reported that they had recovered the bodies of three of the hostages, including that of Shani Louk, who were reportedly kidnapped during the attack on the Nova festival. Per the IDF, all three were killed near the site of the attack and their bodies were taken into Gaza and later recovered in a Hamas tunnel.[119] |
| 18 May 2024 | It was announced by the IDF that they had also recovered the body of deceased hostage Ron Benjamin, and his body was recovered alongside those announced the day before. Benjamin was 53-years-old and abducted from the Be'eri kibbutz while riding his bike on the day of the attack.[296] |
| 24 May 2024 | The IDF reported that they had recovered the bodies of three hostages from a tunnel in Jabalia.[297] |
| 28 May 2024 | Saraya Al-Quds released a video of an Israeli hostage.[298] |
| 3 June 2024 | The IDF reported the deaths of four hostages, possibly by IDF fire in Khan Yunis.[299] |
| 8 June 2024 | Four hostages are successfully rescued by the IDF in an operation in Nuseirat in central Gaza. The four hostages were taken during the Nova music festival massacre. One Israeli officer and dozens of Palestinians are killed in the rescue operation.[300] |
| 22 July 2024 | The IDF confirmed the death of Polish-Israeli historian and educator Alex Dancyg, and of Yagev Buchshtav - both abducted from their homes in Kibbutz Nir Oz and Kibbutz Nirim during the 7 October (2023) massacres. Buchshstav's wife - Rimon - was kidnapped along with her husband, but she was released in November 2023 in a hostage deal with Hamas.[301] |
| 24 July 2024 | Five bodies of hostages are recovered by the IDF in a tunnel in Khan Younis in southern Gaza.[302] |
| 19–20 August 2024 | Six bodies of hostages are recovered by Israeli forces in a Khan Younis tunnel. The bodies had gunshot wounds, likely indicating they were killed by their captors.[303] |
| 27 August 2024 | A Negev Bedouin hostage, Farhan Al-Qadi, is rescued by Israeli forces operating in a tunnel in Rafah. Al-Qadi had been left alone and unguarded in a tunnel, and IDF forces did not encounter any resistance from Hamas when they rescued him.[304] |
| 31 August 2024 | Six bodies of hostages, including Israeli-American Hersh Goldberg-Polin, are recovered by the IDF in a tunnel in Rafah. According to an autopsy report performed by the Abu Kabir Forensic Institute, the hostages were murdered by Hamas approximately 48–72 hours before being found.[305] |
Seamless Wikipedia browsing. On steroids.
Every time you click a link to Wikipedia, Wiktionary or Wikiquote in your browser's search results, it will show the modern Wikiwand interface.
Wikiwand extension is a five stars, simple, with minimum permission required to keep your browsing private, safe and transparent.
