Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
A total falsehood!!! | 20 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 1#A total falsehood!!! |
Reversion of false claims | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 1#Reversion of false claims |
Wikipedia does not work! | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 1#Wikipedia does not work! |
What kind of Talk Page is this? | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 1#What kind of Talk Page is this? |
RK continues to libel me on the history page. | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 1#RK continues to libel me on the history page. |
I am right after all!!! | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 1#I am right after all!!! |
The Future | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 1#The Future |
Overview | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#Overview |
Suggested changes for when the page becomes unprotected | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#Suggested changes for when the page becomes unprotected |
One Third of Symptoms Have Mysterious Origin | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#One Third of Symptoms Have Mysterious Origin |
No small point! | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#No small point! |
M 18:46, 13 Dec 2003 . . Snoyes (Reverted to last edit by Tristanb) | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#M 18:46, 13 Dec 2003 . . Snoyes (Reverted to last edit by Tristanb) |
(re-insert headlines, as it is POV to say that the content under the headlines either supports or undermines alternative medicine) | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#(re-insert headlines, as it is POV to say that the content under the headlines either supports or undermines alternative medicine) |
RK (Removing MNH's POV. He still doesn't understand our NPOV policy.) | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#RK (Removing MNH's POV. He still doesn't understand our NPOV policy.) |
Kindly remove weaselspeak from the Criticism section and Attribute its assertions! | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Kindly remove weaselspeak from the Criticism section and Attribute its assertions! |
It is now up to YOU! | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#It is now up to YOU! |
Reference, please | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#Reference, please |
Merge nonsense | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#Merge nonsense |
See CAM discussion for more on pros and cons of merger | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#See CAM discussion for more on pros and cons of merger |
Why is non-supporting material being claimed as support? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 2#Why is non-supporting material being claimed as support? |
My complete definition of Alternative Medicine | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#My complete definition of Alternative Medicine |
It is indisputable! | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#It is indisputable! |
Losing time for Wiki | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#Losing time for Wiki |
The latest changes are pure POV, of course! | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#The latest changes are pure POV, of course! |
Liking Theresa is not the issue, her "not able" comments are ! | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#Liking Theresa is not the issue, her "not able" comments are ! |
Reading the manual loud | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#Reading the manual loud |
Articulation goes before mediation : ) | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#Articulation goes before mediation : ) |
The meritocratic principles of editing, is an obstacle for democracy | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#The meritocratic principles of editing, is an obstacle for democracy |
Page protected | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#Page protected |
New argument in support! | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 3#New argument in support! |
A related discussion is taking place | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#A related discussion is taking place |
Advocacy vs. Neutrality | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#Advocacy vs. Neutrality |
Protection | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#Protection |
The neutrality of this article? | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#The neutrality of this article? |
Psychosocial treatment and life expectancy of cancer patients | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#Psychosocial treatment and life expectancy of cancer patients |
Ghostwriting concerns | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#Ghostwriting concerns |
Supporters of evidence-based medicine | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#Supporters of evidence-based medicine |
Issues of concern | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#Issues of concern |
Page Protection | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#Page Protection |
defintional issues | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#defintional issues |
False claims about Wikipedia policy by Mr-Natural-Health | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#False claims about Wikipedia policy by Mr-Natural-Health |
Psychosocial Treatments as Alternative Medicine | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Psychosocial Treatments as Alternative Medicine |
Point-counterpoint format | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 4#Point-counterpoint format |
Redirects impeding improvement | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Redirects impeding improvement |
"Support" section | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#"Support" section |
MNH's continuing vandalism of this talk page | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#MNH's continuing vandalism of this talk page |
More swings at NPOV, in support section | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#More swings at NPOV, in support section |
RK's Vandalism in Alternative Medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#RK's Vandalism in Alternative Medicine |
Page protection | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Page protection |
Libel by My Natural Health | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Libel by My Natural Health |
Structural suggestion | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Structural suggestion |
JREF prize | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#JREF prize |
proponents of alternative medicine sometimes cite ... Huh? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#proponents of alternative medicine sometimes cite ... Huh? |
alternative medicines are often sold as "dietary supplements," ... Huh? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#alternative medicines are often sold as "dietary supplements," ... Huh? |
potentially dangerous ... Huh? | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#potentially dangerous ... Huh? |
Research methodology | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Research methodology |
Anyone interested in the Wikiproject on Alternative Medicine? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Anyone interested in the Wikiproject on Alternative Medicine? |
Protected | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Protected |
Conventional? | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Conventional? |
Finalization of Standards of Quality Guidelines | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#Finalization of Standards of Quality Guidelines |
studies | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 6#studies |
I'm sorry but I read the talk and haven't found a convincing argument not to have this in. Especially in it's new form. | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 5#I'm sorry but I read the talk and haven't found a convincing argument not to have this in. Especially in it's new form. |
This view of alternative medicine is probably shared by most scientists. | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 6#This view of alternative medicine is probably shared by most scientists. |
The public wants to buy vitamins over the counter | 15 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 6#The public wants to buy vitamins over the counter |
Definition | 24 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 6#Definition |
Severe social disconnect | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 6#Severe social disconnect |
Deletion of other points of view | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 6#Deletion of other points of view |
So what was precisely wrong with the original presentation of a quote from Richard Dawkins? | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 6#So what was precisely wrong with the original presentation of a quote from Richard Dawkins? |
Theresa, stop being a Cop ! Immediately ! (second warning) | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 6#Theresa, stop being a Cop ! Immediately ! (second warning) |
Reverts without explanation | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#Reverts without explanation |
"Standards Of Quality Guidelines" | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#"Standards Of Quality Guidelines" |
"and animals" | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#"and animals" |
A serious question to MNH | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#A serious question to MNH |
Osteopathy is still being attacked as alternative medicine. | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#Osteopathy is still being attacked as alternative medicine. |
Wikipedia:No personal attacks | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#Wikipedia:No personal attacks |
Request for Comments on Theresa Knott | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#Request for Comments on Theresa Knott |
In an attempt at compromise, I have maintained TK's version of criticism and MNH's of support. I suggest that each user avoid editing the other section, as this has led to extreme POV in the past | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#In an attempt at compromise, I have maintained TK's version of criticism and MNH's of support. I suggest that each user avoid editing the other section, as this has led to extreme POV in the past |
The plural of anecdote still isn't data | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#The plural of anecdote still isn't data |
Move references if you must, don't just delete them | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#Move references if you must, don't just delete them |
Other Issues | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#Other Issues |
Mr NH's latest edit summary | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#Mr NH's latest edit summary |
Weird commit messages | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 7#Weird commit messages |
Tone | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 8#Tone |
Arbitration | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 8#Arbitration |
It may also be described as... | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 8#It may also be described as... |
We need something on the history of the classification "Alternative medicine" | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 8#We need something on the history of the classification "Alternative medicine" |
from within function "Article::updateArticle". MySQL returned error "1205" | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 8#from within function "Article::updateArticle". MySQL returned error "1205" |
Cognitive Behavioural therapy isn't exactly Alternative Medicine | 30 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 8#Cognitive Behavioural therapy isn't exactly Alternative Medicine |
Dispute needed to be resolved! | 25 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 8#Dispute needed to be resolved! |
1 | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 9#1 |
Voting | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 8#Voting |
Voting | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 9#Voting |
Another solution | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 9#Another solution |
Simplified Vote - should we go back to Older version of Alternative Medicine and start again? (Vote Ends Friday 9am UTC unless a consensus is not reached) | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 9#Simplified Vote - should we go back to Older version of Alternative Medicine and start again? (Vote Ends Friday 9am UTC unless a consensus is not reached) |
A better idea | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 9#A better idea |
Results of the polls | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 9#Results of the polls |
Collection of links | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 9#Collection of links |
Pseudoscience | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 10#Pseudoscience |
Basis of conventional medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 10#Basis of conventional medicine |
Addition of another critique of alt. medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 10#Addition of another critique of alt. medicine |
Not Proto-science? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 10#Not Proto-science? |
NPOV warning? | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 11#NPOV warning? |
RV More of Snowspinner's Vandalism -- Discussion | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 12#RV More of Snowspinner's Vandalism -- Discussion |
Project Infobox | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 11#Project Infobox |
Case of Snowspinner Deliberately Destroying An Article | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 12#Case of Snowspinner Deliberately Destroying An Article |
Alternative Medicine is making good progress | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 12#Alternative Medicine is making good progress |
I detect a problem | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 12#I detect a problem |
No, the confusion arises because you are both partly right and partly wrong | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 12#No, the confusion arises because you are both partly right and partly wrong |
NPOV, and what should this article really be about? | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 12#NPOV, and what should this article really be about? |
Benedetti et al. (2003) - Discussion regarding "the placebo effect" | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 12#Benedetti et al. (2003) - Discussion regarding "the placebo effect" |
Support Section | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 12#Support Section |
Section entitled "Medical education" | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#Section entitled "Medical education" |
Maprovonsha172's edits | 27 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#Maprovonsha172's edits |
Section entitled "Contemporary use of alternative medicine" | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#Section entitled "Contemporary use of alternative medicine" |
Suggestion change in section entitled "Safety issues" | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#Suggestion change in section entitled "Safety issues" |
Trauma | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#Trauma |
Adherence To Topic | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#Adherence To Topic |
External links | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#External links |
NPOV | 39 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#NPOV |
Time to archive? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#Time to archive? |
Section entitled "Medical education" | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 13#Section entitled "Medical education" 2 |
Patient empowerment | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Patient empowerment |
Definition of alternative medicine | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Definition of alternative medicine |
Complementary and Alternative Medicine? | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Complementary and Alternative Medicine? |
Gastrointestinal Origin of Mental Illness? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Gastrointestinal Origin of Mental Illness? |
weasel words | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#weasel words |
Yes, evidence-based medicine! Alas, the problem that "evidence" costs money | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Yes, evidence-based medicine! Alas, the problem that "evidence" costs money |
The information structure is important | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#The information structure is important |
Merged CAM to this article | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Merged CAM to this article |
Merged Integrative Medicine into this article | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Merged Integrative Medicine into this article |
Spamming for integrative medicine? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Spamming for integrative medicine? |
Modern, mainstream, conventional | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Modern, mainstream, conventional |
Death Toll | 22 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Death Toll |
Infobox on Alternative Medicine Article | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 14#Infobox on Alternative Medicine Article |
Electromagnetic Therapy | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Electromagnetic Therapy |
Complementary and Alternative Medicine | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Complementary and Alternative Medicine |
Link removed - could someone check if it should be used or not? | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Link removed - could someone check if it should be used or not? |
"Alternative" definition of alternative medicine - why? | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#"Alternative" definition of alternative medicine - why? |
A redirect is not a merge | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#A redirect is not a merge |
Osteopathic medicine? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Osteopathic medicine? |
Neutrality box | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Neutrality box |
"Bad medicine" | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#"Bad medicine" |
Information from OED | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Information from OED |
Cleanup tag | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Cleanup tag |
Lead section | 16 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Lead section |
Anthroposophical medicine? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Anthroposophical medicine? |
self-serving biases and demand characteristics | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#self-serving biases and demand characteristics |
increasing social malaise | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#increasing social malaise |
Cognitive dissonance | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Cognitive dissonance |
Rampant Criticism | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Rampant Criticism |
this is all rampant criticsim | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#this is all rampant criticsim |
I removed two links | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#I removed two links |
Criticism of alternative medicine | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Criticism of alternative medicine |
RfC regarding article status for this article and a dead article | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#RfC regarding article status for this article and a dead article |
"Official" Request for Comment (RfC) on proposed separation/merge of Complementary and alternative medicine | 22 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#"Official" Request for Comment (RfC) on proposed separation/merge of Complementary and alternative medicine |
Minor point in criticism section | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Minor point in criticism section |
Criticism - Explanations section | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Criticism - Explanations section |
Request for Orangemarlin to discuss multiple reverts of good faith edits | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Request for Orangemarlin to discuss multiple reverts of good faith edits |
Useful reference | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Useful reference |
Sections to be Merged into the Other Articles | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Sections to be Merged into the Other Articles |
This article should be more focused | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#This article should be more focused |
New Times article | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#New Times article |
Boldly merged where no merge has gone before | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Boldly merged where no merge has gone before |
"food" for thought | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#"food" for thought |
Improper use of the word "non-traditional" | 15 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Improper use of the word "non-traditional" |
Fundamental problem in the definition of alternative medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Fundamental problem in the definition of alternative medicine |
Allopathic medicine | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Allopathic medicine |
Deletion of section lacking sources | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Deletion of section lacking sources |
Medical Education | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 15#Medical Education |
Two new RS by two authorities on this subject | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 16#Two new RS by two authorities on this subject |
NPOV dispute | 36 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 16#NPOV dispute |
pp and RfC | 29 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 16#pp and RfC |
RfC comments | 14 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 17#RfC comments |
pp and RfC 2 | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 16#pp and RfC 2 |
References 2 and 6 - two proposals | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 16#References 2 and 6 - two proposals |
Obvious problems | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 16#Obvious problems |
Request for corrections | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 17#Request for corrections |
one small study does not generalize | 33 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 16#one small study does not generalize |
a few changes - conversation about a few more | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 16#a few changes - conversation about a few more |
tone issue | 49 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 17#tone issue |
Towards a global picture of CAM | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 17#Towards a global picture of CAM |
Merging CAM, alt. med, and comp. med into one article | 25 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Merging CAM, alt. med, and comp. med into one article |
Why no criticism? | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Why no criticism? |
pseudoscience "see also" | 49 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#pseudoscience "see also" |
Three new sections, rationale and suggestions: | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Three new sections, rationale and suggestions: |
Notable situations where alternative therapies have been misused or classical therapies have petered out | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Notable situations where alternative therapies have been misused or classical therapies have petered out |
Proposal | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Proposal |
Finalizing merge | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Finalizing merge |
Edits by User:207.112.125.217 | 20 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Edits by User:207.112.125.217 |
merge done, redirects added | 20 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#merge done, redirects added |
Cultural/political definition | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Cultural/political definition |
Alternative medicine is not the opposite of evidence based medicine | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Alternative medicine is not the opposite of evidence based medicine |
Consolidating the EBM section of Definitions | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Consolidating the EBM section of Definitions |
The word compelling as used by Edzard Ernst | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#The word compelling as used by Edzard Ernst |
Suspending autoarchiving? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Suspending autoarchiving? |
is there a place | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#is there a place |
Bot report : Found duplicate references ! | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Bot report : Found duplicate references ! |
"Rejected"? | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#"Rejected"? |
Series of edits | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Series of edits |
Section on evidence-based medicine | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Section on evidence-based medicine |
Interesting article. Possible source? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Interesting article. Possible source? |
Another interesting article | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Another interesting article |
Testing of efficacy | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Testing of efficacy |
Diagnosis | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Diagnosis |
Page move and lead changes | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Page move and lead changes |
AHRQ evidence reports | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#AHRQ evidence reports |
New list | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#New list |
Where is the integrative medicine when the topic was there 5 min ago? | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Where is the integrative medicine when the topic was there 5 min ago? |
Interesting article: Life and Death on Fringes of Medicine | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Interesting article: Life and Death on Fringes of Medicine |
Wall Street Journal: "Alternative Medicine is Mainstream | 31 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Wall Street Journal: "Alternative Medicine is Mainstream |
Universities drop “pseudo-science” degrees "in subjects that are not science" | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Universities drop “pseudo-science” degrees "in subjects that are not science" |
Criticism section | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Criticism section |
TGA's Guideline on Submission of Marketing Authorisation Applications (SMAA)....???? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#TGA's Guideline on Submission of Marketing Authorisation Applications (SMAA)....???? |
Auto-archiving | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Auto-archiving |
A standardized definition of alternative medicine is needed.... | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#A standardized definition of alternative medicine is needed.... |
Please do not auto direct conventional medicine to the article of medicine..... | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Please do not auto direct conventional medicine to the article of medicine..... |
Combining this article with Traditional medicine....??? | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Combining this article with Traditional medicine....??? |
$2.5 billion spent, no alternative cures found | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#$2.5 billion spent, no alternative cures found |
"Variouis bodies of evidence" & Other Issues | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#"Variouis bodies of evidence" & Other Issues |
U.S. military uses alternative medicine | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#U.S. military uses alternative medicine |
Integrative Medicine not the same as Alternative Medicine | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Integrative Medicine not the same as Alternative Medicine |
Integrative Medicine and what's controversial about Andrew Weil, M.D. | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Integrative Medicine and what's controversial about Andrew Weil, M.D. |
The Title: Alternative Medicine | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#The Title: Alternative Medicine |
Blood electrification | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Blood electrification |
Website survey | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Website survey |
Definition of "Integrative" (vs. Complementary/Alt) | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Definition of "Integrative" (vs. Complementary/Alt) |
Suggested Merge: Home Remedy and Folk Medicine into Alternative Medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Suggested Merge: Home Remedy and Folk Medicine into Alternative Medicine |
Controversial addition needs discussion: "Mainstream"? | 29 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Controversial addition needs discussion: "Mainstream"? |
Cleanup and weasel tags on Alternative medicine#Relation to evidence-based medicine section | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 18#Cleanup and weasel tags on Alternative medicine#Relation to evidence-based medicine section |
Need for new section on evidence basis | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Need for new section on evidence basis |
Getting Focus | 27 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Getting Focus |
RfC: Proposed new section "Alternative medicine as mainstream" | 39 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#RfC: Proposed new section "Alternative medicine as mainstream" |
revising lead paragraph | 43 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#revising lead paragraph |
Western culture? | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Western culture? |
Can we edit and organise this article | 20 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Can we edit and organise this article |
revising lead paragraph, cont'd | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#revising lead paragraph, cont'd |
reversions and consensus | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#reversions and consensus |
Reboot and proceed | 63 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Reboot and proceed |
POV Intro tag | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#POV Intro tag |
arbcom | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#arbcom |
Protected | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Protected |
Continued from above... | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Continued from above... |
the terms Alternative Medicine vs. Complementary Medicine | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#the terms Alternative Medicine vs. Complementary Medicine |
Name change to Complementary and Alternative Medicine | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Name change to Complementary and Alternative Medicine |
Proposed lead | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Proposed lead |
Organized | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Organized |
What is conventional medicine? | 23 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#What is conventional medicine? |
Add Link | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 19#Add Link |
Revision Suggestion | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Revision Suggestion |
Proposed revision | 38 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Proposed revision |
Characterization | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Characterization |
complementary? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#complementary? |
Efficacy of complementary medicine in children | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Efficacy of complementary medicine in children |
Levity | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Levity |
Appeal | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Appeal |
Merge from Integrative medicine | 36 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Merge from Integrative medicine |
Removed "Rationalization" section as it was entirely uncited; science-based medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Removed "Rationalization" section as it was entirely uncited; science-based medicine |
Alt Med journals revisited - Application of MEDRS re biomed conclusions "peer reviewed" by alt med and pseudoscience journals | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Alt Med journals revisited - Application of MEDRS re biomed conclusions "peer reviewed" by alt med and pseudoscience journals |
The placebo effect | 26 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#The placebo effect |
Good Source for Int Med - Institute on Medicine of the National Academies of Sciences & Engineering and National Research Council | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Good Source for Int Med - Institute on Medicine of the National Academies of Sciences & Engineering and National Research Council |
Use of placebos by MDs | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Use of placebos by MDs |
Attention needed at Osteopathy | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Attention needed at Osteopathy |
Alt med self describes itself as science, using wording from def of pseudoscience | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Alt med self describes itself as science, using wording from def of pseudoscience |
Stress | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Stress |
shamanic healing method | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#shamanic healing method |
contradictory claims in the lead | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#contradictory claims in the lead |
Rewriting the lead | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Rewriting the lead |
history | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#history |
"Criticism" Section | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#"Criticism" Section |
I think theres a form youall missed | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#I think theres a form youall missed |
Ontario medical college votes for tougher scrutiny for alternative medicine | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Ontario medical college votes for tougher scrutiny for alternative medicine |
Australian doctors protest teaching of alt med in universities | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Australian doctors protest teaching of alt med in universities |
Appeal | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Appeal 2 |
This article is entirely biased | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#This article is entirely biased |
Navel glazing | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Navel glazing |
Tim Minchin comments | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Tim Minchin comments |
Remove unsourced copy | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Remove unsourced copy |
This article is biased | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#This article is biased |
"Based on historical or cultural traditions, rather than on scientific evidence" statement in lead | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#"Based on historical or cultural traditions, rather than on scientific evidence" statement in lead |
Free issue of FACT | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Free issue of FACT |
Reads like an extended attack piece | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Reads like an extended attack piece |
Use of CAM by cancer patients | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Use of CAM by cancer patients |
University of Aberdeen avoids "quackery" accusation | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#University of Aberdeen avoids "quackery" accusation |
Which Complementary and Alternative Therapies Merit Study? - Medscape | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Which Complementary and Alternative Therapies Merit Study? - Medscape |
Studying Complementary and Alternative Therapies - JAMA | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Studying Complementary and Alternative Therapies - JAMA |
Clinical outcomes for cancer patients using complementary and alternative medicine - Altern Ther Health Med. | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Clinical outcomes for cancer patients using complementary and alternative medicine - Altern Ther Health Med. |
Final paragraph of Lede | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Final paragraph of Lede |
QuackWatch and NPOV | 54 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#QuackWatch and NPOV |
NPOV issues in Lede | 19 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#NPOV issues in Lede |
Ex hypothesi | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Ex hypothesi |
Lead: propose voluntary editing ban on lead for a month or two | 44 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Lead: propose voluntary editing ban on lead for a month or two |
Additional reliably sourced content needed re criticism of evidence based medicine by some alt med practitioners | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Additional reliably sourced content needed re criticism of evidence based medicine by some alt med practitioners |
The lead is top-heavy | 24 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#The lead is top-heavy |
Creeping watering down of content and Dominus Vobisdu vigilance; RS, BLP, and UNDUE | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Creeping watering down of content and Dominus Vobisdu vigilance; RS, BLP, and UNDUE |
Removal of one possible definition | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Removal of one possible definition |
Trimming subtopic | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Trimming subtopic |
Rewrite of Lede required under WP:MEDRS, WP:MOS (lede), WP:FRINGE, and WP:NPOV | 50 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Rewrite of Lede required under WP:MEDRS, WP:MOS (lede), WP:FRINGE, and WP:NPOV |
In context with other articles | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#In context with other articles |
Greg Bard's recent edit to the Lede first paragraph | 19 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Greg Bard's recent edit to the Lede first paragraph |
Alternative definitions of "health" | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 20#Alternative definitions of "health" |
Lede first paragraph - Gregbard edit trimmed; sources wikified; exact quotes added from definitions of CMA, NYAS, NCCAM, BMJ, and WHO per above discussion | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Lede first paragraph - Gregbard edit trimmed; sources wikified; exact quotes added from definitions of CMA, NYAS, NCCAM, BMJ, and WHO per above discussion |
The third lede paragraph violates MOS (lede) | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#The third lede paragraph violates MOS (lede) |
Replace false sentence re efficacy in lede per MEDRS Academic Medicine, the Journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Replace false sentence re efficacy in lede per MEDRS Academic Medicine, the Journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges |
Arc de ciel's recent edit to lede first paragraph | 14 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Arc de ciel's recent edit to lede first paragraph |
"propaganda"? "fraud"? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#"propaganda"? "fraud"? |
parody | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#parody |
What a bs article | 18 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#What a bs article |
Proposal to help improve the lead according to WP:NPOV | 14 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Proposal to help improve the lead according to WP:NPOV |
NPOV noticeboard discussion | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#NPOV noticeboard discussion |
Clarifying | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Clarifying |
What is the RS for this part of the lede? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#What is the RS for this part of the lede? |
Reverting minor and non-controversial edits | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Reverting minor and non-controversial edits |
Recent Reverts | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Recent Reverts |
Possible Tendentious editing? | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Possible Tendentious editing? |
Evidence? "materialism"? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Evidence? "materialism"? |
GypsySpirit edit re Florida Institute for Complementary and Alternative Medicine | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#GypsySpirit edit re Florida Institute for Complementary and Alternative Medicine |
Terms section | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Terms section |
Terminology | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Terminology |
Which sources should and shouldn't be in the lead | 62 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Which sources should and shouldn't be in the lead |
Why are some editors trying to obscure the unscientific nature of alt med to Wikipedia users? | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Why are some editors trying to obscure the unscientific nature of alt med to Wikipedia users? |
Constant misleading ambiguities violate WP:MOS - "conventional", "mainstream" | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Constant misleading ambiguities violate WP:MOS - "conventional", "mainstream" |
Examples and images | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Examples and images |
Usage | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Usage |
Proposal - replace "conventional medicine" and "mainstream medicine" | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Proposal - replace "conventional medicine" and "mainstream medicine" |
Name an alternative medicine that was based on the scientific method, and not on something else? | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Name an alternative medicine that was based on the scientific method, and not on something else? |
Voodoo Science is a reliable source | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Voodoo Science is a reliable source |
conventional = state board "usual standard of care"? | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#conventional = state board "usual standard of care"? |
"Unconventional" is a symptom, not a cause | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#"Unconventional" is a symptom, not a cause |
"Biology-based practices" does not refer to being based on the science of biology, and may include use of toxic chemicals having nothing to do with biology | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#"Biology-based practices" does not refer to being based on the science of biology, and may include use of toxic chemicals having nothing to do with biology |
Cochrane reviews | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Cochrane reviews |
Examples and classes of alternative medicines | 16 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Examples and classes of alternative medicines |
Revised first para. for Terminology | 14 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Revised first para. for Terminology |
Ignorance... | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 21#Ignorance... |
Appeal: Big Pharma science fraud - a conspiracy theory? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Appeal: Big Pharma science fraud - a conspiracy theory? |
Sources re Mao and the fraud of TCM and acupuncture? | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Sources re Mao and the fraud of TCM and acupuncture? |
Required Marketing class in chiropractic education | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Required Marketing class in chiropractic education |
Section: Examples and classes of alternative medicines | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Section: Examples and classes of alternative medicines |
Efficacy | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Efficacy |
Use Plain English ("supernatural" for "antiscience"?) | 15 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Use Plain English ("supernatural" for "antiscience"?) |
Science based Medicine is not based on a theory of opposites; TCM's supernatural ideas do not come from Ancient Greece | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Science based Medicine is not based on a theory of opposites; TCM's supernatural ideas do not come from Ancient Greece |
Please don't remove terms from sources - "Antiscience" or "supernatural" | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Please don't remove terms from sources - "Antiscience" or "supernatural" |
"Basis of treatment" in "western" medicine has nothing to to imbalance of humors | 21 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#"Basis of treatment" in "western" medicine has nothing to to imbalance of humors |
Points to clarify in body by end April: proposal | 39 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Points to clarify in body by end April: proposal |
Misuse of sources and reverting with respect to the lead | 33 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Misuse of sources and reverting with respect to the lead |
Unsourced and unverifiable | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Unsourced and unverifiable |
Please don't put editorializing in article | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Please don't put editorializing in article |
Comments that National Science Foundation is not a reliable source | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Comments that National Science Foundation is not a reliable source |
Ayurvedic medicine and six reliable sources | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Ayurvedic medicine and six reliable sources |
Warring, Socking, Gaming and other Great Crimes | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Warring, Socking, Gaming and other Great Crimes |
Definitions a) - By medical associations; national or supra-national political bodies; other important representative bodies [vague]; or uniquely important and influential definitions | 58 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Definitions a) - By medical associations; national or supra-national political bodies; other important representative bodies [vague]; or uniquely important and influential definitions |
Pending current review of sources etc. | 60 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#Pending current review of sources etc. |
Medical education | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Medical education |
Use of EBM in the article | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Use of EBM in the article |
Omit items of personal opinion | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Omit items of personal opinion |
Integrative medicine | 15 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#Integrative medicine |
Primary sources in lead, weasel words | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Primary sources in lead, weasel words |
Neutrality? | 31 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#Neutrality? |
CAM vs. AM | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#CAM vs. AM |
Flexner model (western medicine) in the east | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Flexner model (western medicine) in the east |
Massive undue, and introduced ambiguity - "conventional" occurs 200 times in this article, without the context provided in the cited sources | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#Massive undue, and introduced ambiguity - "conventional" occurs 200 times in this article, without the context provided in the cited sources |
First use of the term "alternative medicine" | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 22#First use of the term "alternative medicine" |
CBT as complementary medicine | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#CBT as complementary medicine |
Outdated primary sources, incorrect use of references and POV forks (Quackwatch, Science Based Medicine, soapboxing of Barrett, Ernst, etc... | 19 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#Outdated primary sources, incorrect use of references and POV forks (Quackwatch, Science Based Medicine, soapboxing of Barrett, Ernst, etc... |
and a belief.... | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#and a belief.... |
Efficacy section | 35 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#Efficacy section |
White-washing of all evidence of effectiveness at Alt. Med. | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#White-washing of all evidence of effectiveness at Alt. Med. |
New criticisms proposal | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#New criticisms proposal |
Terms | 35 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#Terms |
Vankevich and Barrett | 16 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#Vankevich and Barrett |
Sources | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Sources |
History section | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#History section |
Requested move | 76 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Requested move |
Surgical medicine: "alternative" or "complementary"? | 57 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 23#Surgical medicine: "alternative" or "complementary"? |
New terminology/definition | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#New terminology/definition |
Alternative is culturally racist, can we avoid it's use? | 18 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Alternative is culturally racist, can we avoid it's use? |
Is there a new "conventional" in the making? | 16 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Is there a new "conventional" in the making? |
Example of typical thinking in alternative medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Example of typical thinking in alternative medicine |
Effect of CAM on cancer survival and quality of life | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Effect of CAM on cancer survival and quality of life |
Alphabiotics | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Alphabiotics |
Two/three points waiting resolution | 18 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Two/three points waiting resolution |
Major undiscussed change, edit warring, copyvio | 61 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Major undiscussed change, edit warring, copyvio |
Flexner Report in lead | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Flexner Report in lead |
Edit request on 17 August 2013 | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Edit request on 17 August 2013 |
Fact Compendium | 24 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Fact Compendium |
Rewrite the lead | 24 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#Rewrite the lead |
Updating sources and text for lead and/or main body | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Updating sources and text for lead and/or main body |
confusing "conventional" with "evidence based" | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 24#confusing "conventional" with "evidence based" |
Update "...Social and Judgmental Biases ..." | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Update "...Social and Judgmental Biases ..." |
List "Examples and classes" alphabetically? | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#List "Examples and classes" alphabetically? |
Dawkins - wonder | 18 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Dawkins - wonder |
Reference formatting | 48 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Reference formatting |
Clearer on Integrative Medicine | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Clearer on Integrative Medicine |
CAM for Arthritis: Is There a Role? Medscape discussion | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#CAM for Arthritis: Is There a Role? Medscape discussion |
Reddit discussion on Wikipedia: Alternative medicine article | 26 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Reddit discussion on Wikipedia: Alternative medicine article |
Definitions by type | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Definitions by type |
Complementary medicine | 32 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Complementary medicine |
In lieu of current "Examples and classes" section | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#In lieu of current "Examples and classes" section |
Category:Pseudoscience revisited | 19 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Category:Pseudoscience revisited |
Recent series of edits | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Recent series of edits |
Chinese medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Chinese medicine |
Naturopathic medicine is not quackery. | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Naturopathic medicine is not quackery. |
Sources Used In This Article | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Sources Used In This Article |
Image | 40 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Image |
Note in lead not needed | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Note in lead not needed |
Proposal to have any images or non-text media in article | 41 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Proposal to have any images or non-text media in article |
Possible disruptive editing | 106 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Possible disruptive editing |
Why is this sentence in the lead? | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Why is this sentence in the lead? |
Lead criticism paragraph | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Lead criticism paragraph |
Excessive | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Excessive |
Unsourced coment removed | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Unsourced coment removed |
Is NCCAM WP:RS on physics, anthropology, sociology, and theology? | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Is NCCAM WP:RS on physics, anthropology, sociology, and theology? |
Another discussion of how to edit plant and herb articles with alternative medicine content | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Another discussion of how to edit plant and herb articles with alternative medicine content |
Ayurvedic Medicine does not advise Suppressing natural urges can be used to heal | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Ayurvedic Medicine does not advise Suppressing natural urges can be used to heal |
Orphaned references in Alternative medicine | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Orphaned references in Alternative medicine |
RTP | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#RTP |
Proceeding with the newly revised version | 16 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Proceeding with the newly revised version |
Ayurveda in America | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Ayurveda in America |
Child abuse exemption content moved out of examples into regulation section | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Child abuse exemption content moved out of examples into regulation section |
Why are subsections on definitions and terminology under a section header called "background"? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 25#Why are subsections on definitions and terminology under a section header called "background"? |
Missing from this article - alternative psychiatry/psychology | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Missing from this article - alternative psychiatry/psychology |
Discussion of guidelines for editing alternative medicine sections in herb and plant articles | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Discussion of guidelines for editing alternative medicine sections in herb and plant articles |
Medscape articles | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Medscape articles |
Real Medicine and Alternative Medicine | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Real Medicine and Alternative Medicine |
How does edit summary explain removal of source? | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#How does edit summary explain removal of source? |
acupuncture | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#acupuncture |
First sentence - scientific method | 28 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#First sentence - scientific method |
Botanica | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Botanica |
Junk addition | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Junk addition |
RfC on COI for alt-med practitioners | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#RfC on COI for alt-med practitioners |
The lede's definition is UNDUE, cf. Harrison's | 71 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#The lede's definition is UNDUE, cf. Harrison's |
Definitions section | 14 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Definitions section |
Where is talk page discussion for recent deletion of entire block of sourced content? | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Where is talk page discussion for recent deletion of entire block of sourced content? |
Biomedicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Biomedicine |
Is chiropractic considered alt med in Denmark? | 15 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Is chiropractic considered alt med in Denmark? |
Is osteopathic medicine an alternative medicine or integrative medicine? | 18 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Is osteopathic medicine an alternative medicine or integrative medicine? |
Do "all definitions" use "other than" and "conventional"? | 35 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Do "all definitions" use "other than" and "conventional"? |
Is there a typo or something missing in this sentence? | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Is there a typo or something missing in this sentence? |
Chiropractic in Switzerland | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Chiropractic in Switzerland |
LeadSongDog's insertion of Image:Jan Steen's "The Quacksalver" | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#LeadSongDog's insertion of Image:Jan Steen's "The Quacksalver" |
Empty references | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Empty references |
Explanation of 2 (nitpicky) "dubious" tags | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Explanation of 2 (nitpicky) "dubious" tags |
Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine is a questionable source | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine is a questionable source |
Should errors be repeated at Wiki because they occur in what is an otherwise RS? | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Should errors be repeated at Wiki because they occur in what is an otherwise RS? |
New age, postmodernism, cultural relativism | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#New age, postmodernism, cultural relativism |
Are there RS for adding "therapy that has a non-scientific explanation" and "type of spiritual practice" to def of alt med? | 25 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Are there RS for adding "therapy that has a non-scientific explanation" and "type of spiritual practice" to def of alt med? |
Defining secondary terms used in literature about alt med, "quackademic medicine", "postmodernism", "natural", "organic", ... | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Defining secondary terms used in literature about alt med, "quackademic medicine", "postmodernism", "natural", "organic", ... |
Marketing using "non-scientific explanations": definition and section | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Marketing using "non-scientific explanations": definition and section |
Percent adverse side effects | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 26#Percent adverse side effects |
What is the earliest grouping under one category, "alternative medicine" ? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#What is the earliest grouping under one category, "alternative medicine" ? |
NBC News source | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#NBC News source |
Herbal remedies and other substances used, phytology | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Herbal remedies and other substances used, phytology |
Acupuncture lead and summary in this article | 24 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Acupuncture lead and summary in this article |
$$$ Reward levels for editing the science out of alt med articles? Need for sources on alt med marketing schemes. | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#$$$ Reward levels for editing the science out of alt med articles? Need for sources on alt med marketing schemes. |
Trouble archiving links on the article | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Trouble archiving links on the article |
External links modified | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#External links modified |
Split | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Split |
Too many images? | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Too many images? |
Need help to fix a ref error | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Need help to fix a ref error |
References | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#References |
Drive-by tagging | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Drive-by tagging |
Hatnote referring to CAM | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Hatnote referring to CAM |
Ethics and controversial sentence about marketing being taught in schools of chiropractic | 20 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Ethics and controversial sentence about marketing being taught in schools of chiropractic |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#External links modified 2 |
Mistaken vandalism on page | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Mistaken vandalism on page |
New review | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#New review |
I know I said... | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#I know I said... |
Proof | 51 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Proof |
Citation code errors | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Citation code errors |
$2.5 billion spent .... testing alternative medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#$2.5 billion spent .... testing alternative medicine |
Invalid an non WP:MEDRS citation | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Invalid an non WP:MEDRS citation |
Extension of personal experience | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Extension of personal experience |
NPOV | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#NPOV |
Science-based = disproven, unproven, impossible to prove, or only harmful?! | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Science-based = disproven, unproven, impossible to prove, or only harmful?! |
Issues with definition in lede | 94 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Issues with definition in lede |
Conflict of interest section | 16 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Conflict of interest section |
Alternative medicine vs. SCAM vs. Integrative | 49 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Alternative medicine vs. SCAM vs. Integrative |
Rough Draft for "Integrative Medicine" | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Rough Draft for "Integrative Medicine" |
Mumbo jumbo as a synonym | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#Mumbo jumbo as a synonym |
See also | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 27#See also |
Commented out citations | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Commented out citations |
Ruthless? | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Ruthless? |
Use of word "prove" in lead | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Use of word "prove" in lead |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#External links modified |
Placebo effect section not about placebo effect? | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Placebo effect section not about placebo effect? |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#External links modified 2 |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#External links modified 3 |
Excellent source | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Excellent source |
Wait.... | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Wait.... |
Need for balance and NPOV | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Need for balance and NPOV |
A failure of mainstream medicine | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#A failure of mainstream medicine |
Possible new section on reasons for CAM's appeal to many | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Possible new section on reasons for CAM's appeal to many |
New section entitled "Shortcomings of mainstream medicine" | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#New section entitled "Shortcomings of mainstream medicine" |
Proposed edits to lede | 48 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Proposed edits to lede |
The heart of the problem | 23 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#The heart of the problem |
Sources! | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Sources! |
Issues with shamanism | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Issues with shamanism |
Is {{Medicine}} due? | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Is {{Medicine}} due? |
Herbal Medicine is what now? | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Herbal Medicine is what now? |
Complementary and Integrative Medicine | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 28#Complementary and Integrative Medicine |
Sources | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Sources |
Holistic medicine for healing trauma | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Holistic medicine for healing trauma |
Overstated | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Overstated |
Reliable Sources | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Reliable Sources |
Alternative medicine which is now medicine | 16 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Alternative medicine which is now medicine |
Alternative medicine is still medicine | 15 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Alternative medicine is still medicine |
Alternative medicine is still medicine | 15 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Alternative medicine is still medicine 2 |
Edit Efficacy section | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Edit Efficacy section |
Biased. | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Biased. |
RfC - Again | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#RfC - Again |
Bias | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Bias |
What happened to this article? | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#What happened to this article? |
Is the graphic at the top not excessively POV? | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Is the graphic at the top not excessively POV? |
Edit reverted | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Edit reverted |
Proposed re-write of lede | 25 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Proposed re-write of lede |
Unproven vs. Disproven | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Unproven vs. Disproven |
Sources and references? | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Sources and references? |
The word "clearly" | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#The word "clearly" |
Pseudomedicine | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Pseudomedicine |
Complementary Medicine | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Complementary Medicine |
Alternative medicine's links (in uk at least) to alternative approaches to health. | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Alternative medicine's links (in uk at least) to alternative approaches to health. |
Alternative medicine's links (in uk at least) to alternative approaches to health. | 17 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Alternative medicine's links (in uk at least) to alternative approaches to health. 2 |
Mechanisms of action | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Mechanisms of action |
The Inefficacy of Security through Obscurity | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#The Inefficacy of Security through Obscurity |
Errant definition | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Errant definition |
Serious lack of impartiality | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Serious lack of impartiality |
"Foundational medicine" listed at Redirects for discussion | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#"Foundational medicine" listed at Redirects for discussion |
Semi-protected edit request on 25 June 2020 | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Semi-protected edit request on 25 June 2020 |
Semi-protected edit request on 1 September 2020 | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Semi-protected edit request on 1 September 2020 |
Broken refs | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Broken refs |
Semi-protected edit request on 10 May 2021 | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Semi-protected edit request on 10 May 2021 |
Displacement of effective conventional treatment | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Displacement of effective conventional treatment |
Current Article is Unscientific Opinion Piece | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Current Article is Unscientific Opinion Piece |
Removal of material from the Model Guidelines for the Use of Complementary and Alternative Therapies in Medical Practice | 14 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Removal of material from the Model Guidelines for the Use of Complementary and Alternative Therapies in Medical Practice |
Medical consensus | 12 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Medical consensus |
Rebranding | 23 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Rebranding |
Suggested rephrasing | 11 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Suggested rephrasing |
Failed verification in Efficacy section | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Failed verification in Efficacy section |
Request for comment on phrasing of statement | 13 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Request for comment on phrasing of statement |
"'Eastern medicine' typically refers to the traditional medicines of Asia where evidence-based medicine penetrated much later." | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#"'Eastern medicine' typically refers to the traditional medicines of Asia where evidence-based medicine penetrated much later." |
Article is biased | 24 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Article is biased |
Risks and problems chronology | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Risks and problems chronology |
False definition | 18 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#False definition |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 2 |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 29#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment 3 |
Recreate IM article? | 33 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Recreate IM article? |
Remove unprofessional words/provocative language | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Remove unprofessional words/provocative language |
Proof Homoeopathy is not pseudoscience | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Proof Homoeopathy is not pseudoscience |
Skeptics dictionary for acronym sCAM | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Skeptics dictionary for acronym sCAM |
To avoid edit warring, let's discuss this removal | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#To avoid edit warring, let's discuss this removal |
Request to reconsider Integrative Medicine/Integrative Health having its own page | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Request to reconsider Integrative Medicine/Integrative Health having its own page |
Removal of navbox pages | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Removal of navbox pages |
Natural course of disease ≠ regression to the mean | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Natural course of disease ≠ regression to the mean |
Honey for Coughing - Clinical Evidence? Folk Remedy? Alternative Medicine? All of the above? | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Honey for Coughing - Clinical Evidence? Folk Remedy? Alternative Medicine? All of the above? |
Updating and Improving Alternative Medicine Article so it is not rated as C-Class | 14 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Updating and Improving Alternative Medicine Article so it is not rated as C-Class |
Reducing fluff and matching sources to statements | 5 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Reducing fluff and matching sources to statements |
Lead is long and not obviously sourced | 10 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Lead is long and not obviously sourced |
Complementary or integrative medicine section is one sided | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Complementary or integrative medicine section is one sided |
Is there any difference between what would be called pseudomedicine and so called "alternative" medicine? | 15 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Is there any difference between what would be called pseudomedicine and so called "alternative" medicine? |
Alternative Medicine and Complementary Therapy are not the same. | 53 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Alternative Medicine and Complementary Therapy are not the same. |
Should we simplify the lead? | 18 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Should we simplify the lead? |
Let's use a better third sentence | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Let's use a better third sentence |
Stuff to move around | 8 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Stuff to move around |
Strange sentence | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Strange sentence |
What needs to be merged so we avoid duplication | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#What needs to be merged so we avoid duplication |
"Derogatory"? | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#"Derogatory"? |
Usage/prevalence | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Usage/prevalence |
Testing and diagnoses | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Testing and diagnoses |
Recent sources that address usage | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Recent sources that address usage |
Rose Shapiro | 9 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Rose Shapiro |
The Skeptic's Dictionary | 18 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#The Skeptic's Dictionary |
The entire defining opening of this article is bias and insulting | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#The entire defining opening of this article is bias and insulting |
Claims | 6 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Claims |
Accuracy of article | 4 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Accuracy of article |
Too skeptical | 3 | Talk:Alternative medicine#Too skeptical |
A Biased Perspective? | 7 | Talk:Alternative medicine#A Biased Perspective? |
Wiki Education assignment: ENGL A120 Critical Thinking | 1 | Talk:Alternative medicine/Archive 30#Wiki Education assignment: ENGL A120 Critical Thinking |
Add Type: Physical therapy | 2 | Talk:Alternative medicine#Add Type: Physical therapy |